Cupcakes near Centereach, NY

“Attn store manager: the young men working tonight need a pass from closing side work- they were SLAMMED. Online orders were out of control; I was having anxiety w each ticket printing and I wasn’t even working. I waited 30min in line for my cake batter ice cream [always be worth the wait], but despite being slaughtered w orders, I was greeted w kindness. I received great service & witnessed professional and kind young men doing their best. I was impressed with their work ethic and ability to stay calm.“

“Every time I order anything, from pastries to event cakes, The Rolling Pin never disappoints! This past event was my daughter-in-law’s baby shower. I sent David a picture of what I wanted and it was better than the picture! My family will be a forever customer here! Paulette “

“I came to the bakery on Easter Sunday early in the morning after going by a local bakery and seeing a huge line. I remembered someone recommending this bakery so I drove up the road and decided to stop by and give them a try. My first impression of the well decorated simple and the cakes and desserts really stood out. They even had a section for dog treats that were made for the pups. The customer service was exceptional. The young lady who helped me with my pretty large order considering I was going to two Easter festivities and was in charge of dessert was beyond helpful very patient and very welcoming. When I arrived, of course I took time looking at the cakes and desserts that they had to offer and I was unable to make a choice. I finally did make a choice and decided on the bunny cake, which is white or vanilla cake with chocolate and buttercream, and I also got a rainbow cookie cake, which was phenomenal not dry, it was delicious I also got the assortment of Italian pastry, platters with cannoli Napoleons and tarts, and those were delicious as well. I got a small box of cookies which were good as well as a box of assorted donuts, and linzor tart. I wish I would've taken pictures of everything that I purchased, but unfortunately I didn't. I must say everything that I tried. I had a small sampling at the different events. I went to that day and I must say I was not disappointed at all by anything that I purchased, the lobster tail was delicious. It was right amount of crunch. It was not soggy and the inside was just perfectly sweetened. I would recommend recommend and have been recommending this bakery to everyone I come across. I must say it's way better than it competitor which is down the road, but it's also a little slightly more expensive but like I've told everyone I rather pay a little more for gracious service a pleasant experience and a great product. Kudos I think I have my regular bakery and I hope to try other delicious treats from here very soon.“

“Had a 21st birthday cake made for our daughter. It was not an easy order as it was a heart shaped cake with a special filling and a very specific pink color.The cake was perfect and absolutely delicious. Thank you for always taking great care of your customers ❤️“

“Immediately! Immediately I walked in and loved the atmosphere. I could tell right away it was Colombian. Very nice gentleman at the counter. I just didn't catch his name. Very friendly and welcoming.The place looked so nice. 100% I'm going back and possibly regularly. Looking forward to trying other menu items. ??“

“This bakery is the absolute BEST!!!! The owner goes above and beyond for her customers. You will have some customers that will always leave negative reviews even though nothing was done wrong on the owners part. You actually have to take the negative reviews and let them go and actually see where they are coming from. It is usually a person that constantly leaves negative reviews for many places as to they are just a a complainer and maybe looking for items for free. This community all knows how excellent this bakery is and how hard the owner works!“

“Five stars definitely she made a beautiful amazing delicious cake for my daughter’s baby shower with macaroons and chocolate covered pretzels everything came out delicious. Everything was done perfectly in a timely manner. The lady that made the cake was just amazing and so polite and just as sweet as her cake. If you’re looking for a delicious beautiful cake or sweets , she’s the person to go to.“