New American Restaurants near Chautauqua, NY

1

2 Ames

2 Ames American • $$
2 Ames Ave, Chautauqua

Customers` Favorites

Charcuterie Board
Shrimp and Grits
Oxtail Poutine
Cheese

“Just had the pork snitzel with red cabbage and potato pancake. Amazing!!“

3.4 Good44 Reviews
Guppy's Restaurant & Tavern Seafood • $$
4663 NY-430, Bemus Point - 3.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheeseburger with Steak Fries
Beer Battered Haddock Fish Fry
Steak Salad with French Fries
Meatball Sub with Fries
The Buffalo Chicken
Mussels Appetizer
Lime Margherita
Broiled Haddock
Chicken Pot Pie
Chicken Alfredo

“We walked in with a table of 5 on a Saturday night and were instantly greeted and offered a seat in the heated gondola. We were well informed on the food and drink specials too. They had a huge selection of draft beers and special cocktails, kids drinks could add Boba which was a big hit! Our meals were delicious, build your own Stromboli was a table favorite. The chicken parm was delicious and everything tasted so fresh.and delicious. Disappointed that we were in a time crunch and couldn’t try any desserts from the diverse menu, we will absolutely be back! This place is a hidden gem!!“

4.6 Superb158 Reviews
Bemus Point Inn Restaurant American • $
4958 Main St, Bemus Point - 5.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Steak & Eggs w Hash Brown Casserole & Toast
11 Eggs Bacon Home Fries Toast
Jumbo Cinnamon Roll
English Muffin
French Fries
Cinnamon Bun
Creme Brulee
Hashbrowns
Sandwich
Homefries

“Great people great food 😎“

4.9 Superb127 Reviews
Bemus Point Ferry. And Casino restaurant American • $$
Bemus St, Bemus Point - 5.11 miles

“The village casino has a decent atmosphere. The food is mediocre and their food menu is over priced. This place would not survive outside the village That being said it’s a nice place To enjoy a cocktail or drink and watch the sunset.“

4.6 Superb11 Reviews
Cassadaga Country Club New American • $
55 Frisbee Rd, Cassadaga - 11.61 miles

“Went here for a quick 9 after work. It was easy to get a tee time and pace of play was great. My one criticism was that you went back and forth over the same creek a couple of times and the fairways were close together. Definitely some places where you can lose balls.“

4.6 Superb25 Reviews
6

Splash

Splash American • $$
60 Lakeside Dr, Bemus Point - 5.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Salmon Strips

“Outstanding wine selection and phenomenal desserts, not to mention the fantastic service, I highly recommend a visit to a unique and worthwhile establishment. We were able to impress our out of town guests with delicious wine and delectable desserts. Thank you, Splash!“

4.6 Superb80 Reviews
Bemus Point Golf Club & Tap House New American • $
72 Main St, Bemus Point - 5.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

Medium Rare Steak and Frited
Fried Brussel Sprouts
Fried Chicken PO
Flight of Beers
Tap House Salad
Club Sandwich
Burrito Bowl
Tuna Bites
Fish Tacos

“We love the Taphouse. Great people and always trying to improve Bemus!“

4.6 Superb85 Reviews
Stella: A Kitchen & Bar Fine Dining • $$
60 Chautauqua Ave, Lakewood - 10.18 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Calamari

“Just had one of the best meals of the summer at Stella’s last night! 10/10/25. I ordered their special of stuffed haddock and was not disappointed. Thank you to your entire staff for another outstanding dining experience! Great date night thanks to ALL of you!!“

4.6 Superb268 Reviews