New American Restaurants near Bemus Point, NY

“I swung through for the eclipse, and Rachel&Bryce opened their doors to me (before opening time), introduced themselves, their friends, and their wonderful dogs, all before 10am!! 100% I will visit again! They have a small 9hole course, carts and light play, very affordably. The town is small and quaint and beautiful! It looks just like the New England style lake town you might imagine. It happens to be an easy drive and there are so many things to do outside nearby! I hope to see my friends again soon and I recommend the Bloody Mary!“

“We avoided the Casino because the food wasn't very good and not cooked well. The 2023 season was a pleasant surprise. The quality of the food had greatly improved. We are looking forward to 2024. I hope whatever changes were made in the kitchen will carry on. The service has always been great. The view of the lake is exceptional.“

“Another great dinner at Stella! We sat outdoors for the first time, and enjoyed dining al fresco. Our foursome enjoyed soup, Caesar salad, salmon, lasagna and Jaegerschnitzel. Stella has a nice menu of wine by the glass or bottle and assorted cocktails. Save room for the house-made desserts! It's an hour drive for us, but always worth the trip.“

“Gluten and soy-free diner here. First, my wife and I need to thank the reservations staff who answered the phone late yesterday afternoon and were able to squeeze us in for dinner. We were not disappointed! Their space is bright, and it overlooks Chautauqua Lake. Our server, Gabby, helped me navigate their menu, and she let me know that I could order gluten-free pasta with my crab, scallops, and shrimp scampi. It was topped with Parmigiano cheese and tomatoes, and it was delicious! My wife's Filet Mignon was cooked to her liking (medium rare), so we were two for two. For dessert, Gabby mentioned that they had one gluten-free offering. But she did not know if it was soy-free. Thankfully, she checked because the ingredient list, which she brought to our table, because their gluten-free dessert did contain soy lecithin. Thank you once again, Gabby, for looking out for me, and we will be back sooner rather than later.Dietary restrictions: Gluten and soy-free selections.“