22 Best Pizza Restaurants near Churchville

“Churchville Pontillos is always our go-to pizza place. They have AMAZING pizza, and are always friendly and accommodating.Tonight, though, they went above and beyond! I asked for a heart shaped pizza for Valentine's Day, and not only did they deliver, they even through in a Valentine on the inside of the box! Little things like this show how much they truly care and put their heart into these amazingly delicious pizzas! Not to mention, it was delicious as always!“

“This is my second time ordering from here, and definitely won't be my last. First, the staff and owners are some of the kindest people. Very friendly and welcoming. The inside of the restaurant is not too small and not too big where you feel like you don't matter. Very clean inside. This was hands down one of the best meals I've had. The chicken shawarma pita is perfectly toasted with grilled chicken and veggies inside. The spice mix was delicious and not overwhelming. The falafel is perfectly crispy on the outside, and moist on the inside without drying out. 5 stars.“

“I called in my order and the man on the phone taking my order seemed like I was putting him out calling my order in! We ordered a large pizza, light sauce, 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 plain cheese. When we get there, there is a sign on the register 'Cash Only'. Now, I thought why did this grown man taking my order not tell me on the phone. A surprising coincidence they have an ATM in the store. Are they getting a cut of the ATM surcharge? Luckily I had enough cash. The pizza was flat and looked like old dough was used. The crust took up about 2 inches of the pizza, then about 1 inch of just dried red sauce. With a light sprinkle of cheese in the center. Only a few pepperonis were on half. Across the street behind the firehouse is the best pizza Rochester has had since Bay and Goodman pizza... Perri's. So- pass by Pizza Shack and go directly to Perri's!“

“Pretty good Italian. Had the lasagna and pizza. The pizza was good, but I'd prefer a bit more cheese and sauce. The lasagna was quite unique. Has a sweet flavor. Was good..service was good and accommodating when the lasagna was served a bit cold in the middle. Brought out a new piece that was hot. She saw we were splitting it, so I was a little disappointed that when it came back out hot she didn't split it in the kitchen. Had to cut and split it at the table which was messy. Overall, good place. Would go back.“

“We moved to the Chili area a couple of years ago. For a bit, we struggled to find a good pizza on this side of town. Then we tried this place, we have now ordered from there 4 times and this has become our go-to spot. This seems to be the only pizza place on this side of town that is capable of consistently producing great pizza. This time, we ordered a white pizza with broccoli, onions, and spinach. It was absolutely delicious, not to mention visually appealing as well. It was coming out of the oven right at pick up as well. This Pontillos location is amazing. We will be back for sure.“

“This is our favorite Mark's Pizzeria location. We literally have a Mark's location 2 miles from our home but we drive to this location because of their outstanding service, wonderful food & if there is ever an issue with our order, they happily correct it. Everyone who greets you is so friendly & helpful. We also like that there is a convenient store right there & we can pick up additional treats. Great location!!!“

“Hidden in a little knook in the town of Holley is Dustin's Pizzeria. They were steadily busy with takeouts while we waited for our pie, although there is plenty of room for dining in.The sauce to cheese ratio complemented each other's flavor to perfection. The sauce tasted homemade and had hints of oregano and basil. I don't know if it is a homemade sauce recipe, as I did not ask, but it brought back memories of a New York City pizza we ate while exploring the Statue of Liberty. Yummmm.Dustin's Pizzeria crust was neither too thick nor too thin, crispy on the bottom, and held up nicely to the thick cheese and pepperoni toppings.We were surprised to find that both the flavor of the food and the price of it far exceeded the other guy that only sometimes treats you like family.When we go again, we will dine in and eat that pizza as it was intended, hot out of the oven.“

“I'm the Italian son of a second-generation pizzeria owner - and I love pizza! I've had just about every kind of pizza available on the westside. After trying Cusimanos several times they have moved into my top three favorites, and may even be #1 depending on what kind of pizza I'm hungry for. Their largest non-sheet pie is quite big, cooked just right with plentiful toppings (and lots of cheese). Excellent all the way around.“

“You HAVE to stop at Nick's if you're in town. Great service and even though the subs were huge, our whole group couldn't resist finishing them. I think the owner helped us and seemed like a nice old-fashioned guy. Great place for lunch.“

“Pizza and wings are always great at roosters! The owners Austin and Harry are amazing and run a great establishment! Mark , the nice fellow whom I've been told was a star in the Special Olympics is a little hard to understand but does a great job as the door greeter. Keep up the good work guys!“

“The most amazing, caring and sweet family run this place. The food is excellent and the attention to detail is top notch. Thank you tracy and family for all you have done for us. We truly appreciate you. XoxoKid-friendliness: Made amd gave us special treats the kids and adults loved“

“I’m an idiot and put my order in for ASAP instead of 3 hours later when I actually needed it and they remade everything even though it was my fault! Just want to say thank you for that and say they’re the best. Order from them all the time.“

“Wow what a menu! There is always something mouth watering, fresh to eat. Now that I'm watching carbs I order the cauliflower crust pizza with ham and pineapple a salad with chicken. My husband loves the calzones and the chicken wings. All freshly made !“

“Perri's has consistently great wings! I'm picky about my wings and I'm always happy with them. They also offer oversized single slices of pizza which is perfect for my son who only likes cheese pizza. Our favorite by far is the fried dough!“

“I think I might have given this place a 5 star already. But what the hell. I'm giving them another one. I love this place. I love the food, I love the staff, I love the cleanliness. I wish I could eat here every day. Bathrooms are extremely clean too.“

“The pizza here is a little pricey but is usually very good, as is the service from the staff. We usually dine-in a couple of times a month, but we've also done some pick-up orders without any big issues. One guy with glasses who works here (the owner?) isn't always the friendliest person in the world, but that's a whole separate issue and has nothing to do with the pizza.“

“Stopped here while passing through and were glad we did. Very comfortable, clean and welcoming spot. We were greeted and seated immediately, and continued to receive excellent service from our hostess. Capish has a well stocked bar with lots to choose from. They have a nice variety of entrees which looked excellent, but we really had a taste for pizza. We weren't disappointed. The place boasts a beautiful brick oven producing a great meal, with a great tasty and still light crust.“

“The slices are so good! Stop in for one! You won't regret it! They're so warm and have the most perfect crisp! The buffalo chicken slice is my go to. Dip it in a side of bleu cheese (: the best! The staff is always so friendly and the atmosphere is nice as well.“

“Hard working crew making sure everyone is happy with their food. I really liked their wing flavours. If you just want some good pizza and no fuss, this is a good spot. I also liked the obvious care they have for the community. Sponsoring teams, hiring students and actually caring. Great to see. Make sure to say hi to Matt.“

“I order from this place a lot and never have any issues. Occasionally they run a little behind but its understandable because they do get busy quite a lot but the wait is worth it since their food is so good! I usually go at night and the crew always seems like they are having fun with what they're doing and they are very friendly towards me sometimes I enjoy coming here for the conversations.“

“Always a great experience. The food is consistently good. Great salad bar. Amazing service "thank you, Nicole". Clean eating environment.The staff is friendly, helpful, and always greets you with a smile. I would recommend this place to anyone, especially families looking for a good, inexpensive meal outside of the house. The children will be entertained while coloring at the table, and the parents will be happy with not only a hard to find mini night out of the house but also the price. Great place with amazing staff.“

“I order from Colombini's every weekend. I usually just get a the large pie. Last night hands down best Pepperoni pizza I've ever had! So good! Very generous amount of cheese, they use the "good" Pepperoni and it crisps up nicely, the crust is great with a hint of garlic, which makes those corner pieces the first piece everyone in the house grabs.“