12 Best American Restaurants near Cobleskill

“Charming inn built in 1802. Staff is very friendly and extremely helpful. The menu is varied and interesting with options for every palate!. If you’re in the area, don’t miss it.“

“very good service food was yummy (wings and a reuben) cool place!“

“tried tagua cafe for The first time yesterday. staff was extremely friendly the food arrived quickly and was very good.....definitely going to be back.“

“Great condition and the scenery this time of year was spectacular!!!“

“Best Ice Cream in New York State!! If you are anywhere near Cobleskill, it is well worth the stop!! 🍦 If you aren't close, it's well worth the drive! 😊“

“I had an interview in Cobleskill. I had the great fortune of staying in the American. I got in late, after normal check-in, and got a fantastic email taking me through the steps of how to get access and then on to my room.To say I was blown away is an understatement. The decor and overall vibe of the place is amazing. It’s history, culture, and spirit all rolled into different rooms with different personalities. The building is, well, alive with all of the history and fun things you see on the walls and generally decorating the place. Same goes for outside. It’s just so welcoming.That was only surpassed by Garth and Doug. What kind, kind men and what lovely humans. You get a clear sense that the openness and warmth of the hotel is a direct result and reflection of them. It’s not often you want to get to know your hotel hosts better, but they create the space where this kind of thing is possible.Being on an interview is stressful and one needs all the help to be calm. The American, Doug and Garth, gave me the opportunity to gather myself, relax and be my best.Do yourself a favor. Go see this treasure.“

“This is the best place in the area for great food! After a 2 time terrible experience at another local "Fancy" restaurant, with a 2 hr wait for our dinner that never came, we left! We stopped at the Sharon Tavern, they had just stopped serving, but when the owner Paula heard what happened too us, she fired up her oven again and fed us! What a wonderful thing to do! Waitress Heather, & Bartender Greg always happy too see you, and the service they give is unmatched, always making sure that everything is going well at your table! Their experience clearly shows how a restuarant should run!! Thank you again Paula for taking care of us! We will not forget your kind hospitality!!“

“My husband and I came here tonight for the first time for dinner and it was INCREDIBLE. Our drinks were delicious as well and the staff were very friendly and inviting. We are tractor lovers (my husband has a tractor business) so the atmosphere made us feel very comfortable. Beautiful attention to every detail. We highly recommend Fancy Farmer and we definitely will be frequent visitors!“

“A wonderful find. Made my day. The food, the drink, the people, the art, all of it.“

“This place has really good food, Sandwiches,pizza ,burgers,Best Breakfast Sandwiches and much moreStaff very friendly also they have liquor store ,laundromat,Gas,propane on propertyVery convenient and good AtmosphereVery nice Sitting area to eat inside“

“I drive 45 miles just to have his hot fudge sundea and onion rings.“