47 Best Italian Restaurants near Elma

“Great friendly staff.. Excellent food. Have eaten at this restaurant multiple times. The food has always been fantastic! Cannot say enough good things about the restaurant, and the staff!“

“Best Pizza in the area. Tastes like the way I remember pizza to tast.“

“Delicious and fresh no sugar amazing quality“

“Mario is so welcoming! The food is just amazing! The best meatball bomber I have ever had .“

“me and my wife just got some slices from there and they were the best slices we ever had. we will be back for food“

“I cannot recommend this restaurant enough!! I give it 10 ⭐️!The food was amazing, the portions huge snd everything is made from scratch. I had the Polish platter; I chose fresh Polish sausage ( no joke it went from one side of the plate to the other), sauerkraut with mushrooms, huge potato pancake, and added 2 pierogi. All delicious. The table next to us ordered the cabbage roll, you could get 2 meals out of it! Service was fast and friendly. I'll go back and try the Italian side because they make their own pasta. Go! You won't be disappointed.“

“Everything was amazing!!!! Clams casino... Grilled Pork Chops... Chicken Maria all delicious!!!! And the homemade pasta was so good!!!! Highly recommend!!! Great atmosphere and Fantastic service!!!“

“The BEST Italian food ever. I've been many, many time in the restaurant as well as caterer food for the Christmas Holidays for years and years. I wouldn't choose anywhere else. Thanks for such great service and being so friendly. Lorenzo gets an A+++“

“Highly recommended. Food was excellent , staff was nice“

“I LOVE IT HERE! ❤️ One of my favorite restaurants - hands down. Staff are SO nice and friendly and everything I’ve tried is very good. Please come try it! (I ask for extra parm and they DELIVER)“

“the good we had for dinner which was delicious.“

“Delicious pasta sauce, very good service!“

“Awesome food! You pick everything you want by Sharpie on the menu and hand it back to them. It's the best, actually! We had the pizza boat that is new. So good! Also, great big salad and pasta that was to die for. Can't go wrong has something for everyone. Great place for take-out, also.“

“🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Mangia Ristorante & Caffé is an absolute gem!
From the moment you walk in, you feel that cozy, authentic Italian vibe – like you’re being welcomed into someone’s home 🇮🇹🍝

The food? Absolutely delicious!
Fresh pasta, rich sauces, and every bite bursting with real Italian flavor. You can tell it’s made with love. Definitely a place that lives up to its name — Mangia! (Eat!)

The service was warm and attentive, and the place is clean and inviting.
If you’re in the area and craving genuine Italian food, this is the spot.
I’ll 100% be coming back again!“

“Always great food and the service is awesome. Keep up the good work!“

“Fast take out service and friendly employees. Excellent Fish Fry, Fries, side of Pasta, and other co-side items plus the Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken and Shrimp was excellent and two meals for meal which includes 2 pieces of bread and butter. Will come back again and recommended!“

“love your pizza wish I could have gotten a whole slice“

“I used to live near there and ate there regularly. Moved away 10 years ago, but was back in the area and had to stop in. The food is as good as it always was. Hubby had to have the fried chicken, his favorite! The food was good, the service friendly and attentive...we'll have to go back again!“

“Pizza was pretty good. Would be cool if the owner would pay me back the money hes owed me for 2 years“

“GREAT Italian Food, so many options and the fish fry is HUUUUUGE!“

“Another awesome experience, our server was Lexi and she was amazing, knew how to joke around and took our antics in stride. Extremely courteous, attentive, friendly and made our dining experience a great one. We we’re at the Transit location a month prior for a club dinner and had a great time then too. If you go and have either Lexi or Lydia as your server - just know you’re going to have a great time! They both went above and beyond. Food was good, service was incredible. Our visit was only disappointing in the fact that we had to leave. I don’t eat out often but the last 2 times I’ve chosen Olive Garden on Transit and do not regret it at all. Hopefully those servers are there the next time we go!“

“Are waitress Lucy was fabulous. The food was delicious.“

“Outstanding from beginning to end. Best food I've ever had. Service was wonderful too. Highly recommend the short rib and calamari.“

“Dinner on a Saturday night for 4, glad we made reservations as it seemed to fill up fast. Service was friendly, but a bit hands off (Did not get offered any refill of water after a 1st glass). Complimentary bread service was decent and served alongside the soup/salad that was included with most entrees. Others said the house salads were quite impressive. The Rosa sauce was a highlight. Chicken and veal parms were well received, as was the eggplant. Whole group got lukewarm pasta, but luckily we had filled up by that point and just left it for a doggie bag. Tiramisu for dessert impressed the group - worth squeezing it in!“

“We love the chicken bacon ranch and the Italian rainbow pizza. Highly recommend!“

“Awesome Food, lousy jingle“

“The service was top notch. From the Reservation Desk, the Maitre' D, our waiter Chris, and all the staff...just excellence in service. Food was fabulous! Cocktail and wine menu are excellent. Truly a 5 star experience! We stopped in for a one night stay at the Delavan and so happy that we chose to dine here.“

“The show was amazing, funny and emotional. I loved the show and the actors. The director (Bobby J) is an amazing host and director. While the place is a bit expensive, the show was totally worth it.“

“Great food, great service!“

“10/10 would recommend. Amazing food. Not one sub bar option. Everything is perfect. Great beers and wines. Very nice people working and owning the restaurant. Perfect for the casual night cap or a very nice romantic night out“

“A family favorite for us, whenever we are out in the Clarence area, GM is a must stop, just can't pass up the amazing service and food!“

“Great food decent prices nice staff great atmosphere 4 12 stars“

“Thank you once again to Marcos for providing an excellent lunch to our department at Millard Fillmore Suburban Radiology!!!! Always a treat!!!“

“Once again we had an exceptional dinner at Trattoria Aroma this evening. From the warm and genuine welcome to our excellent dessert it was pure pleasure! The food is always delicious with a unique presentation and excellent prices! In the past 30 years we have always been accustomed and greeted by name by the wonderful owners and staff! Continues to be our go to favorite in Buffalo!“

“Ordered pizza and wings and they were phenomenal!!! The flair was outstanding!!! We ordered 3 flavors, lemon pepper Cajun, kickin bourbon bbq and mango habanero. All 3 were delicious!!! The pizza was so good too! Pepperoni, sausage and banana peppers. Definitely going back!“

“Amazing food and wonderful service!!!“

“This was my first time here, and WOW! I ordered the "Chairman of the Board" and it was fantastic. The turkey was tender & juicy. The roll was super fresh. It wasn't heavy in my stomach like fried food can be. People in my group also ordered a "How-You_Doin?" sangwich and "Hey Sonny!" burger. They were both very pleased and we all agreed that we wanted to order from this restaurant again soon. My order was ready pretty fast.“

“was there for my birthday on 3/11 with my kids .we had a very nice time .“

“The food was excellent and our waitress was absolutely wonderful, friendly, attentive, and on top of everything.

However, the seating policy was a bit frustrating. My cousin called ahead to explain that she was planning a surprise 40th birthday dinner for a party of 18. My cousin confirmed with the manager that we would be seated even if the birthday girl arrived last (so the surprise wouldn’t be ruined). When we got there, the staff initially refused to seat us and the hostess said the manager said no — even though it had been pre-approved (maybe a different manager at the time of the call and didn't communicate to the next on shift or the staff?).

After a small, friendly conversation, they did go ahead and seat us (finally but too close to the birthday girl arrival), and the rest of the evening went smoothly.

Great food and service overall, but the inconsistency with the seating policy made the start of the night more stressful than it needed to be.“

“I slept on this place for years after I actually tried them last year realized what I was missing if you haven't had ferris what you waiting for?!?!“

“Friendly, family-like service; amazing soup, awesome Italian food imports! <3“

“Excellent foods, awesome prices, great staff“

“Thank you for serving pan fried eggplant instead of the usual deep fried....it is delicious. My boyfriend got the haddock special and that was one of the best meals he has had at a restaurant in a long time. We will be back! Our waiter Drew was also excellent.“

“Quint restaurant with a unique menu and some reasonably priced specials“

“cheeseburger sub is good. Pizza is good, sauce doesn't rot your gut out. Large Beef taco with sour cream is good too. I go here regularly.“

“By far the best pizza in my area! They build a pie the way I remember most pizzarias did it back in the day. No frozen crust, no canned sauce, and definitely no fake cheese. Their pizza is baked well done creating a the perfect crust and the pepperoni cupped and charred just they way it should be.
Consistency is the norm at Santora's, I have never received a sub par order. The prices are a bit high but you get what you pay for and you won't be disappointed.“

“I know this is Buffalo and this is chain pizza but trust me when I say this, if you are stopping by the mall you HAVE to get this pizza. It is so good. The slices are enormous for what you pay for them, and you get your money's worth. Its really like getting 2 slices of pizza especially if you get the roman square slice. If you are from out of town and aren't coming back, don't leave the mall without getting a slice of this pizza, you will regret it. They have many different kinds of pizza here. Not too many places make a white pizza and this place has that too and its good. In fact I've never been greeted by such friendly staff at a food restaurant in my life and I don't review things lightly on here. If I could give this restaurant 11 out of 10 stars I would. I've ordered this more than once and never a negative experience.“