19 Best Sandwich Shops near Elma

“This location is clean and the employees are friendly! Lucas went above and beyond to make my dinner how I wanted it, accommodated all of my requests and was so kind and patient. My wrap was great and I was 100% pleased with the service and quality. Thank you!!!“

“Good food and consistent. Nice service in addition. I recommend trying them, you will not be disappointed!!“

“Always fresh, the owners have kept the menu and quality in place“

“very good value , soup is very good and changes daily great lunch spot“

“Some of the best sandwiches around. By far! The spicy Cajun chicken and the Engineer are our favorite.“

“My daughter and I went here for the first time today and it was GREAT!

First of all, the place was nice and clean. The staff was super friendly, efficient and just great.

And then the food. It was quickly made, warm and delicious and NOT a rip off.

Two regular customers were made today.“

“Went there for the first time and had a great experience and the food was Really good Two BIG thumbs up!!! 🤪“

“everybody loves Subway right? But most of the ones in Buffalo have like three stars or less... so when I saw that this location had 4+, I was like 'okay, I'll go a little out of my way to try it out!!'

um, definitely worth the trip!! Gas station subways are goaded but this one being in the building it is larger with a better floor plan. But other than aesthetics:
• I walked to see probably the cleanest subway I've ever been in
• the lovely girl who was working greeted me so kindly that all of my ordering anxiety melted-away instantly! bless ?
On top of that - I am a vegetarian and very often tend to come across places that don't properly sanitize or will cross contaminate, and it is a major fear of mine for when I go out to eat... (I literally got pepperonis on a meatless sub I ordered the other day!! like what!)
in my experience, subway can be either hit-or-miss on whether or not they take care not to cross contaminate, is like rolling the dice to see what you get when you pick a random location...
Had a clean counter clean up gloves and a clean knife for me and my vegetarian sub, again I was so appreciative because this -simple- thing can be so hard to come by sometimes!!
The vegetarian sub I get isn't too complicated, but sometimes it gets messed up and that makes sense. i never really would complain!
but not only was she was so kind (and helped turn my mood around because I was having a rough day even) on top of that she made my regular sub for me PERFECTLY!! made sure there wasn't too many jalapeños -but just enough :) - ; she took my kind of strange request for two different sauces lately on top of my sub , and killed it !

five out of five stars would recommend ... for the food atmosphere and conversation I had! ?“

“Very chill guy when I walked in for my pickup order using a coupon, even reassured me and promised me he packed my sub with veggies like my note said. I can absolutely attest to the fact that this sub is heavy and packed and made correctly too!! Versus the orchard park location i normally went to, this one had better reviews and that showed immediately. Better atmosphere, fresher ingredients it seems, plenty of people to help each other out seemingly, and overall just a good spot in the area. Will definitely be coming back here as my main subway! Nice find for me, as I've had issues with other places either not listening to my note, somehow getting my simple subs wrong, or otherwise just some kind of issue generally. sometimes I had success but overall unreliable with the other location, so thank you to the people who made my sub today! Appreciate you all and I'll for sure return in the future! It's only a few minutes further out anyways.“

“So excited to get a Jersey Mike's in our town. Food is ALWAYS fresh and they hire great people. Met Will & Adam and they're doing an awesome job. It's been here less than a week and we've visited twice already. Will for sure be weekly customers for life.“

“Zane provided excellent customer service and saved a long term customer relationship. I purchased a sub and soup and was very disappointed in the quantity and quality of how the items were delivered to me. But Zane made it right by redoing the order.“

“Natasha & Cedric gave me amazing service! They aimed to please and did just that!“

“Ryder has made me subs multiple times at this location and is one of the hardest workers I have ever seen. Great customer service, speedy, and great quality work. I certainly recommend this Subway just based on Ryder alone, if the other worker's are close to him, you will not be disatisfied.“

“This was my first time here, and WOW! I ordered the "Chairman of the Board" and it was fantastic. The turkey was tender & juicy. The roll was super fresh. It wasn't heavy in my stomach like fried food can be. People in my group also ordered a "How-You_Doin?" sangwich and "Hey Sonny!" burger. They were both very pleased and we all agreed that we wanted to order from this restaurant again soon. My order was ready pretty fast.“

“very nice place to stop in for a sub. the young lady behind the counter was very friendly and helped us out even though we didn't really know what we wanted... She was very patient with us. we love coming to this little town everyone is so friendly. we will definitely be back. oh, and we came to see the grinch sleigh behind vidlers. It was the original one from the movie. We ended up going to the Aurora theater to see the new Willy wonka movie. Which, by the way, was really good. And that theater is awesome. What a gem, you must stop in and see it. all in all, it was a great day to spend with my wife. I do love her.“

“Placed a big order with the app. Got there early. Cleaner and better organized and other subways I've been in. Polite employees. No mistakes in the order. Everything seemed fresh, unlike other subways. No complaints whatsoever. Will be back.“

“My experience at this restaurant was truly exceptional. The food was delicious and expertly prepared, reflecting the quality of the ingredients and the skill of the chefs.
The staff were friendly, well-presented, and provided outstanding, professional service.
The cleanliness of the place was noticeable from the moment I walked in, which added a sense of comfort and trust.
I highly recommend visiting, and I will definitely return.“

“My sub was absolutely terrible, but the employee who was working had such amazing service. I think his name was Aaron or something, I forgot lowkey but he was chill af. the cookies were good though so that was a plus. keep up the good service!“

“Hadn’t had Subway in a while and it just sounded good…. Double Meatball sub for my son, Baja Chipotle Chicken for my wife and 2x Turkey for me. All delicious, fresh and perfect. The young lady working was a sweetheart and service was excellent!!!! Will definitely be adding Subway (this location) back into my regular places for lunch!!! FANTASTIC!!!!“