22 Best Sandwich Shops near Elma

“Just went to this subway and I just have to leave a review because the two gentlemen working the counter were so nice, amazing customer service that you don’t see to often they deserve a raise!
Thank you for being so kind! (Unfortunately I did not get their names)“

“Good food and consistent. Nice service in addition. I recommend trying them, you will not be disappointed!!“

“OH MY GOODNESS!!!! AMAZING FOOD, SERVICE, ATMOSPHERE, AND LOCATION!!!! I live in the north towns, but I will definitely head down here again in the future. Highly recommend the lemon pepper wings, Jedi Melt, Gold Mine chicken sandwich, and Banana pepper rings. Enjoy!“

“Always fresh, the owners have kept the menu and quality in place“

“Very friendly and great food! I was given a sample, of the roasted pepper soup, It is awesome! I highly recommend.“

“Some of the best sandwiches around. By far! The spicy Cajun chicken and the Engineer are our favorite.“

“I had been at a different subway for 15 years. They had new management, and went downhill very fast. I came to this subway Southgate Plaza West Seneca, New York, and found it to be very clean. The atmosphere was friendly. The workers, especially the owner, were extremely efficient in what they do. In fact, many of them remembered what I ate and what I didn’t eat. I give the subway the highest recommendation.“

“My daughter and I went here for the first time today and it was GREAT!

First of all, the place was nice and clean. The staff was super friendly, efficient and just great.

And then the food. It was quickly made, warm and delicious and NOT a rip off.

Two regular customers were made today.“

“Older guy and his trainee with black hair were amazing! I'd been going to numerous other subways for some time and they all have botched online orders and don't listen to instructions for some reason, admittedly I was standing there watching them make it but ultimately they did a great job and given the other reviews I'd like to think they would've just did it right even if I wasn't there watching. Thank you for the service!“

“Ryder has made me subs multiple times at this location and is one of the hardest workers I have ever seen. Great customer service, speedy, and great quality work. I certainly recommend this Subway just based on Ryder alone, if the other worker's are close to him, you will not be disatisfied.“

“Went there for the first time and had a great experience and the food was Really good Two BIG thumbs up!!! 🤪“

“I couldn't find a place to sit that the table wasn't full of previous customers crumbs and grease. Also the floor was pretty bad. I felt very rushed when trying to decide what I wanted. But the mini sub was a perfect size and very tasty!“

“Placed a big order with the app. Got there early. Cleaner and better organized and other subways I've been in. Polite employees. No mistakes in the order. Everything seemed fresh, unlike other subways. No complaints whatsoever. Will be back.“

“Jersey Mike's makes the best subs, hands down. Maybe I'm partial as I grew up in New Jersey, eating at the original locations before they franchised, but the Orchard Park location does not disappoint. It tastes just like the original!“

“Took one bite and the smell of the location i had to go throw up. With a smoke shop next door there needs to be a better way to keep it next door, I have other locations in the future. But will not return to this location unless real steps are taken to correct this issue. Ar least for me im glad I made it outside embarrassing“

“Placed an online order for pickup and got there at 9:30pm about, the girl working at the time (5/21/2026) had followed my instructions perfectly and filled my sub all the way with all that was requested, like stacked... I dunno your name, brunette / dark hair girl, but you deserve the best! Thank you so much for not just ignoring my instructions, it genuinely means so much, you a real one lady! I really wish I knew your name, so I could appropriately label you in this review, but I'm sure you know who you are! Me and my mom were the only one who'd walked in at the time, and I gotta give it to her too, she made that footlong like a swift speedster pro! Love your work ethic, thank you for making my night! Sub was excellently made too, she a natural! Will be back for sure! Wish you the best of the best, too! Dunno if you'll read my review, but you the GOAT. Appreciate you! I'm the one who asked for extra vegetables, and I was dutifully impressed by the amount you'd went above and beyond to make it truly inspiring! Thank you!“

“This was my first time here, and WOW! I ordered the "Chairman of the Board" and it was fantastic. The turkey was tender & juicy. The roll was super fresh. It wasn't heavy in my stomach like fried food can be. People in my group also ordered a "How-You_Doin?" sangwich and "Hey Sonny!" burger. They were both very pleased and we all agreed that we wanted to order from this restaurant again soon. My order was ready pretty fast.“

“Wow. Words can’t describe how much I love Jersey Mikes. Nothing makes me happier than seeing the nice, hardworking employees (shoutout Mariam) and my chipotle chicken sub. My day is always uplifted and the food is just spectacular. I HIGHLY recommend.“

“Absolutely awesome people The food was great but they definitely could put more meat on their steak subs I could have ate four of them especially cuz they're expensive as well but the friendliness of the staff and the cleanliness of the restaurant everything was 100%. Thank you guys“

“Natasha & Cedric gave me amazing service! They aimed to please and did just that!“

“The two brothers that run this subway are very nice, I have been in there on Saturdays with my 3 small grandchildren. They are so patient with the boys especially my grandson with Autism. Food was great, the service was great!! I will be going back a lot.“

“Hadn’t had Subway in a while and it just sounded good…. Double Meatball sub for my son, Baja Chipotle Chicken for my wife and 2x Turkey for me. All delicious, fresh and perfect. The young lady working was a sweetheart and service was excellent!!!! Will definitely be adding Subway (this location) back into my regular places for lunch!!! FANTASTIC!!!!“