14 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fairport

Perinton Pizza Emporium Pizza • $
7374 Pittsford Palmyra Rd, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Turkey and Bacon Wrap
Shirls Garlic Pizza
Turkey Bacon Sub
Breakfast Pizza
Landfill Pizza
Fish Sandwich
Tossed Salad
French Fries
Loaded Fries
Chili Cheese

“Picked up a delicious pizza tonight, and bought a container of Italian cookies….the BEST I’ve ever had.“

4.8 Superb66 Reviews
J & L's Pizza Korner Pizza • $
347 Hogan Rd, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Fried Mushrooms
Buffalo Chicken
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Finger
Cheeseburger
Onion Rings
Wings

“First time ordering here since we moved to the East side and I have to say it’s the best pizza I’ve had yet! Great for people who like a thinner crust with a healthy amount of sauce. The brick oven crust is SO good. We loved the buffalo chicken pizza, their house wing sauce they use is unique, and it was a nice shake up to traditional buffalo sauce. Also their house red on our pepperoni pizza was fantastic! 😍“

4.7 Superb62 Reviews
Tk's Pizzeria Pizza • $
27 Liftbridge Ln E, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Sausage Mushroom and Onion Pizza
Half Cheese Half Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Slice of Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Mild Buffalo Wings
Chicken Wings
Pizza & Wings
Garlic Bread
Turkey Sub

“This is the best pizza in Western New York. I've been going there for 46 years and never been disappointed! Tony & Mike are amazing and I always look forward to the time w/ them. Prices are beyond reasonable.“

4.6 Superb68 Reviews
CompTin Pizza & Provisions Pizza • $
1276 Fairport Rd, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

You Part of the Club
Traditional Wings
Pepperoni Pizza
Pittsburgh Pie
Large Pizza

“8.2 on the Portnoy scale.“

4.5 Superb67 Reviews
Freddie's Wood Fired Pizzas Pizza Takeaway • $
186 Atlantic Avenue, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Ratatouille Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Carbonara Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Caprese Pizza
Sauce

“Best wood fired pizza in Rochester. All fresh ingredients artfully prepared by Freddie himself. It is a must try, you will be hooked. I know I am!! Definitely five ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

4.6 Superb34 Reviews
The Pizza Chef Pizza • $
650 Whitney Rd, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

New York-Style Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Steak & Cheese
Cheese Pizza
Sausage
A Pizza

“Kid-friendliness: We came here for some quick lunch after playing at “ladybugs play” in the same plaza. It was my son’s 4th bday. They pushed their small tables together for our family, and put on a show of tossing the pizza dough when they noticed my son was watching. One gentleman offered my 2 kids free ice cream once they finished their lunch since it was Niko’s birthday. Not to mention how DELICIOUS the pizza was. I’ve never noticed the flavor of the sauce on my pizza before, but theirs was so good that it was noticeable to a casual pizza eater. We will certainly be back!“

4.3 Superb63 Reviews
Mark's Pizzeria Pizza • $
7450 Pittsford Palmyra Rd, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Pizza
Large Pizza
Medium Pizza

“As a longtime satisfied customer of Mark’s in Fairport, I didn’t think I could be more pleased with their service, but I was wrong. Tonight I placed an order online for delivery. After an hour I called because it never takes that long for a delivery. It turns out I messed up and did the online order for pickup, rather than delivery. I drove to the store and was greeted by the manager who informed me she was making me a new pizza because she didn’t want me leaving with a cold pizza. When I told her it was my fault and that wasn’t necessary she insisted I was getting a fresh, hot pizza. I was blown away!! In an age of horrible customer service, this young lady decided to go above and beyond to satisfy a customer even though the mistake was clearly my fault! I have been a customer of Mark’s for quite some time and this just proved to me why! Their slogan is “we treat you like family” and, as it turns out, this is not just a slogan but reality! Kudos to this young lady for what she did for me. It will not be forgotten and I will continue to patronize Mark’s as I always have. Thank you so much for your kindness!“

4.3 Superb39 Reviews
Caraglios Pizza Pizza • $$
1345 Fairport Rd, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wing Pizza
Four Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Boneless Wings
Large Pizza
Buffalo Mild

“I have always loved Caraglios! I was very excited when I heard it was coming to Fairport and I have not been disappointed. Same great pizza (especially the country sweet chicken wing) and outstanding service! My family does the slice a day membership and we have gotten to know the people that work at the Fairport location. Everyone is so personable and thoughtful. They remember our daughter’s name and our typical order. Highly recommend!“

4.2 Good32 Reviews
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria Pizza • $
55 S Main St, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Super Slice & Wing Combo
Boneless Chicken Wings
Chicken Charlie Pizza
Salvatore's Supreme
Large Italian Sub
Chicken Fingers
Giant Calzone
Buffalo Wing
Meat Pizza
Pizza Sub

“On 7/11/25, 5th grade students from the Encompass Program ventured to Fairport , NY to learn about owning a business. Sarah Santiago met with us and spoke to our students/answered questions about the ins and outs of Salvatore’s Fairport. Salvatore’s donated delicious pizzas for our lunch. It was a wonderful day of learning and eating for our future entrepreneurs.“

4.1 Good55 Reviews
Clawson's Deli & Pizza Deli • $
1231 County Rd 21, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

The Original Breakfast Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fried Fish Sandwich
Meatball Sub
Large Pizzas
Cheese Pizza
Steak Sub

“First time going here because I was recommended by a friend. And dang I see why they recommended it. The breakfast pizza I ordered was absolutely perfect all the way to the crust. I could have eaten 3 of these easily. Great bang for your buck I will be recommending this place as much as I can. Great job and please keep up the great work. ????“

4.6 Superb56 Reviews
Vinny's Bakery & Deli LLC Bakery • $
1350 Fairport Rd, Fairport

“Vinny is awesome. What a true pleasure to speak to a man like him. I am SO glad that my wife, daughter and grandkids got to experience what was so much more available to guys like myself years ago. This place is a gem and the food was great. A true unexpected pleasure in this day. Check it out for yourself because good things like this don't last forever. Italian bread is fantastic btw.“

4.8 Superb33 Reviews
Joe's Brooklyn Pizza Perinton Pizza • $
6720 Pittsford Palmyra Rd, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Meat Lover's Medium Pizza 14
Side Garlic Romano
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Knots 3
Cheese Pizza
Specialty
Wings
Pie

“Pizza is fantastic and the people are even better. The staff have always engaged my kids when we pick up. My five year old got home and said “best day ever” and my 7 year old was raving about the pizza. It’s also a favorite of the parents.

Kid-friendliness: Staff was great with my 5 and 7 year old while picking up the pizza we ordered.“

3.7 Good46 Reviews
Compane Trattoria Italian • $$
25 Parce Ave, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Oatmeal Cookie Cheesecake
Chicken Parmigiana
Frothed Pmargaritao
High Street Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Veal Parmigiana
House Meatballs
Caesar Salad
Bolognese
Milanese

“fantastic dinner last night, the ravioli was the best I've ever had. Noah is a fantastic waiter and we certainly adore our Rachel.“

4.2 Good79 Reviews
Bocaccini's Italian Bistro Italian • $$
6720 Pittsford Palmyra Rd, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Papa Joe's Special Spaghettini Marinara Instead of Red Sauce One Meatball & One Sausage
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Butternut Squash Ravioli
Shrimp & Lobster Risotto
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
Salmon Fra Diavolo
Sicilian Calamari
Vegetable Lasagna
Eggplant Parmesan
Cabernet Sauvignon

“Fabulous food. I've been eating my way around the menu and delighted with every dish. My only complaint is the older woman bartender who won't give you eye contact. Wait up to 20 min.“

4 Good145 Reviews

You May Also Like