50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Garden City

“Awesome staff and excellent pizza!“

“BEST PIZZAREA IN NEW YORK HANDS DOWN“

“The best pizzeria! Whether you order from the counter or the kitchen, you will always enjoy your meal. The staff is amazing and friendly especially Vinny!“

“highly recommended this pizza point“

“Theres 1 worker there @ 8³⁰ that every time I go when he serves me is aggressively as if he's rushing me to go. Mind u I go there at least once a week during my break so im definitely a familiar. Other then that I love the pizza & the place .“

“They added a Lava Cake to their dessert menu… I’m in HEAVEN!!!!! I don’t even need the lasagna bolognese I always ask about (IYKYK) … nope KEEP THE LAVA CAKE ON THE MENU!!!!! I’ll order it every time I come in! (Which is like 2-3x a month.“

“Great pizza place. Loved the pizza“

“Jairo is amazing !!! He recommended drinks and food . He gave me a delicious Cosmo martinis which are hard to find good quality martinis but his was just perfect !!!!! Dennis the chef made the calamari which were fresh and the sauce was perfect .he came out afterwards to make sure I was happy with my appetizer and that everything was to part . He was very accommodating.“

“We celebrated my dad’s 80th bday in one of the igloos. We had such a nice time. My dad loved the unique experience and the food was absolutely delicious.“

“Great Food and Service.
I had the Genovese...Fresh Paccheri with Slow Cooked Veal in a White Wine & Peppercorn Sauce with Celery, Carrot
& Carmelized Onion. Amazing.

It is small dinning area, so reservations recommended.“

“I’ve lived in New York City my whole life. From Brooklyn, to Queens and even the Bronx. I’ve tried pizza from all the 5 boroughs and non are as good as Eddies. You get a high quality slice with great service. You don’t get service like this from anywhere these days. When you go into Eddies you go back to a simple time where ingredients are fresh, conversations are warm and welcoming and the pizza is hot and delicious. Don’t sleep on this spot. It’s worth the trip and is some of the best pizza you can find in all of New York and Long Island“

“Ordered for the first time last night, they were super accommodating since we called at 8:45 and they close at 9:00…. They made us 5 pies and I’m was so appreciative. They were so nice and even recommended one which I absolutely loved (with potatoes!) we can’t wait to go back but to eat there so we get the Pizza Hut out of the oven! Amazing owners and such a delight to have in valley steam!! The owner explained the ingredients and concept to my husband and his friend. They can’t back telling us so about it!“

“Me and my mother went to get some pizza yesterday (9/27/25) and we were welcome by the owner and he explained all the different flavors of the pizza and they all sound so good. While we were waiting, the owner gave us free cookies and he gave us an extra slice of pizza and when we ate the cheese and BBQ chicken pizza, I felt like my spirit was leaving my body. Make sure you go here and you will be loved and left in shock of the atmosphere and the love of the staff that will keep you coming back! HIGHLY RECOMMEND FOR YOU TO COME HERE WITH YOUR FRIENDS OR FAMILY.“

“Love this place. Been to it a couple of times and the pizza is amazing. The Garlic Knots Slider were good but not great and at $11 not worth it. The pizza though is incredible. Really good Sicilian speciality slices.

Had the cheese steak which was really good as well but I wish I didn't have to spend so much money to eat here.“

“La Pizzeria & Bagel in Valley Stream is a fantastic neighborhood spot! Their bagels are fresh and perfectly bakek. The pizza is always tasty, and they also serve excellent pasta dishes and hearty, flavorful soups that are perfect for a cozy meal. The variety on the menu means there’s something for everyone. The staff is friendly, and service is consistently fast and welcoming. A great go-to for breakfast, lunch, or dinner!“

“Great food and outstanding services. Highly recommended.“

“This is pizza to drive miles for!! 😋“

“Excellent restaurant! Food was delicious, compliments to the chef. Our server Carlos was great! Joe the owner was attentive and accommodating! Would highly recommend!“

“Everyone was friendly and casual. The waitress and owner took time to speak with us. The Margherita pizza and meatballs appetizer were good. The tomato sauce was excellent.“

“Really good pizza ! ordered the upside down Sicilian and it was perfect. ordered it well done. The bottom was crispy and the dough was perfect ! Really good pizza sauce ! Also had a plain slice and it was very good! Fried calamari were Very good !“

“They make the absolutely best Pizza 🍕 the GRAMMA PIZZA US JUST THE BEST!!!“

“Wanted some authentic NY pizza during my stay. They nailed it! Antipasto is amazing and they couldn’t have been nicer. Kind of want to move to NY just for the food 🤣“

“I recently went for dinner with a small group of- it was the first time for all of us. I didn't have high expectations, but was very pleased with our meal and the service.
The restaurant is on the small side (I suggest a reservation), but very attentive, and the bar area is very cute and modern. Our waitress was very attentive, and everything we ordered was delicious, including my spicy cucumber margarita. To start we shared the falafel platter, large enough to be shared, and the fire roasted eggplant in a green herb tahini sauce (I think that's what it was) - tender and delicious! I had the special brussel sprout Cesar salad w/ added grilled chicken, and others ordered the salmon and enjoyed it. We didn't order dessert, but I'll definitely try something sweet next time!“

“The Pizza here is some of the best on LongIsland“

“Gino's Pizzeria of Lynbrook is fantastic.
I had been going there since I was a young kid. The guys there are the best and treat all their regulars like family.
Back in 2015 I had to move abroad for work and when I returned back to the States I had to setttle in the Midwest.
After almost 10 years of not being able to visit Gino's one could say I missed it a lot.
Ass soon as I got back to NY on a family visit I made sure to stop there.
They remembered me the second I walked in and that speaks to the great level of how they treat their customers.
I can't say enough good things about them.
My absolute favorite place.
Their pizza is the best. Recommend their Cesar salad Pie as most places just don't get it right but Gino's Lynbrook gets it spot on.
Very traditional NY pizzeria from the atmosphere to the service not to mention their delicious menu options.

100% recommended.“

“Staff was incredible and the food was delish! Highly recommend! Did I tell you the drinks were awesome?!“

“This pizzeria has been here for a long time and that says something. I’ve been coming here for over 20 years and it’s still fire. I don’t live close by anymore but every time I come back I always find myself here first. 8.3“

“There pizza is so yummy. my son and daughter love it very much.“

“Amazing food! We order from them every week! I love their salad pizza and the fact that they have gluten free options makes it even better! Their minestrone soup is delicious as well! The food is always piping hot & ready, we never have to wait! Their staff is super friendly and always get our order right! Highly recommend Rustica!!! 🙂💗“

“Best food and pizza around!“

“After my wife and I were married in 1976, we lived for a time in an apartment building on East Superior Street, next door to Gino East's pizzeria, in Chicago's Streeterville neighborhood, steps from the Magnificent Mile. At least once a week, usually after we returned from our day's work, we had dinner at Gino East's. It was our introduction to one of the best pizzas in town. But that was then and this is now. I'm at Gino East's of Chicago in Los Angeles and I want to see how the West Coast version of Gino East's pizza compares to its original in Chicago. Located at 12924 Riverside Drive in Sherman Oaks, one of Los Angeles' most fashionable suburbs, it has been voted the best pizza for two years in a row by the Los Angeles Times, deep dish and thin crust. Open from 11:30 to 9 Sunday through Thursday and 11:30 to 10 on Friday and Saturday, this location was opened in 1969, three years after the flagship restaurant was launched at 162 East Superior in Chicago. To be sure I could enjoy the same kind of pizza that I have been enjoying since I was in high school in the 1950s, I opted for Gino East's "Build Your Own" offer, a 16-inch large thin crust pizza with chunky tomato sauce, Italian sausage and real aged mozzarella cheese. Just what the doctor ordered. I'm told that Gino's East of Chicago also makes a mean batch of spaghetti and meatballs. Next time.“

“My wife and I have ordered from Previti for several years now thru Door Dash. the food has always been excellent. The other day I had a call from Previti. It was the owner, Joe. He told me that my mother had wandered in after having her car bumper come completely loose on Marcus Ave. She had no phone, and was shaken up by the whole ordeal. Joe called me for her, and gave her a cup of hot tea. I went over, picked her up and got her home. Later my wife and I returned to pick up her car. We decided to eat dinner there and take advantage of the pasta night specials. The lasagna and the rigatoni with meat sauce were both excellent. Thank you Joe and staff for taking good care of my mother, and providing us with an excellent meal! All the best!“

“Best pizza in town.. highly recommended 👍🏼“

“The best thin crust margarita!“

“Food is of top quality , service is immediate and atmosphere is circa 1985 .Leo has been around forever entertaining kids with his puppet shows ( free of charge ) , place looks the same for the last 40 years but spotless clean , food is top quality , a reason as to why all the local schools order from pizza pious“

“I live down the block so I'm happy this is a quality pizza place. Their regular, square vodka and chicken bacon ranch slices are great and you get good value for your dollar. The chicken bacon ranch is the best i have ever had. I would have given this place 5 stars if they made the Buffalo chicken and bbq chicken slices like they do the chicken bacon ranch. Unfortunately, those are usually my go to slices but for some reason they take a very different approach than they do the chicken bacon ranch and it definitely doesn't work. I recommend giving this place a try especially if you live in the neighborhood.“

“Five stars without hesitation! This tandoori pizza brought the heat in all the right ways. Juicy chunks of smoky chicken, charred peppers, and just the right kick of spice layered over gooey cheese — pure perfection. It’s like my favorite tandoori platter decided to become pizza, and I fully support its career change.“

“Great Pizza Thanks Nick,John“

“Yes, there are gluten free items here that are marked on the menu HOWEVER I thankfully had a waitress that basically said that their is airborne flour everywhere and that cross contamination is almost guaranteed for anything baked in the oven with the pizza (for example their baked GF chicken Parm dish). I was so appreciative how clear she was, saying that the gluten free pasta is boiled separately though they still can't guarantee it is celiac-safe. I risked it and got a pasta dish and fortunately didn't get sick. I hope they can find a way to make truly Celiac safe gluten free foods because their GF pasta was phenomenal!“

“I’ve been going here since I was little and boy have they always delivered, like if I had to choose best pizza place this would be it 100% only gripes I got are that sometimes the pizza is different like more cheese less sauce little issues every blue moon. My favorite dish here is the spaghetti and meatballs and if I had to choose taste this would be my equivalent of heaven on earth. Overall would eat here as long as I live within a 1 hour distance.“

“Phenomenal pizza and friendly staff. Plus, they have Dr. Pepper and Gold Peak Tea. Can’t wait to return! 5 Stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“This is a great place with delicious food. The proprietor is very customer oriented, accommodating and flexible. Great place for eating in or take out with traditional Tasty Italian Food! Five Star Place!!!“

“OMG! Great Pizza!

Walking in felt like entering a scene from a 90s American movie，a classic Pizza restaurant! The décor had that warm, old-times vibe. The pizza was super fresh and delicious, and the salad was really crisp and refreshing.

Wonderful staffs! Lovely restaurant, definitely will comeback for more Pizza!“

“Love this place, always friendly people to welcome you in, All the food is Amazingly Delicious, take out or eating in. I tell all my friends about this place.“

“Just the experience to share with your kid and not go broke doing it“

“Just picked up 2 hot specials of The day. Portions are large, taste is on point! Thank you“

“I live in South Florida now but I still find myself dreaming about Gino’s Pizza..The absolute best!“

“Outstanding pizza and wings. Ice cold beer. Great atmosphere and service is top notch“

“I’ve been coming here for decades. I’m sitting here now as I write this review watching every single person who walks in the door be greeted by their first name. This is the place for fantastic food and genuine hospitality. They don’t make places like this anymore.
If I could give 6 stars I would.
I recommend the personal pizzas,
best I’ve ever had.“

“Very friendly. Food is great. Pizza is great. The price is right.“