7 Best Bakeries in Hicksville

Bread in Oven Bakery • $
13 W Marie St, Hicksville

Customers` Favorites

Tower Wedding Cake with Fresh
Fresh Flower Wedding Cake
Customized Birthday Cake
Customized Theme Cake
Gulab Jamun Pastries
Red Velvet Cup Cake
Butterscotch Pastry
Gulab Jamun Pastry
Dried Fruits Cake
Butter Cream Cake

“I had the pleasure of trying cakes from this bakery, and I was genuinely surprised by how delicious they were, especially considering they were eggless! I was introduced to this spot by a friend, and I’ll admit my expectations were low when I heard the cakes didn’t use eggs. But after one bite, I was completely won over. My absolute favorite is their butterscotch cake. It’s rich, flavorful, and perfectly moist. These cakes are so popular that slices often sell out quickly, so I highly recommend reserving ahead of time if you want to guarantee your pick.

Even their cookies are tasty, though I do think they’re a bit pricier for the quantity you get. Still, the cakes are definitely the star of the show and worth every penny.“

4.9 Superb79 Reviews
Celebrations In the Kitchen Bakery • $$
63 E Old Country Rd, Hicksville

“We celebrated our daughter's 6th bday virtually and we ordered the party boxes for all her friends. They had a blast decorating the cookies and they were delish! Thank you so much!“

4.9 Superb37 Reviews
Get Baked New York Bakery • $
642 S Broadway, Hicksville

“I visited Get Baked in Hicksville and was really impressed with the atmosphere, the friendly employees, and the fair prices. However, I was a bit disappointed with the Rainbow Cookie Cupcake. I was under the impression that the cupcakes would be filled, but it turned out to be a basic cupcake with just a rainbow cookie on top. While it was still tasty, it didn’t quite meet my expectations.“

4.7 Superb14 Reviews
New Hot Breads Fast Food • $
243 S Broadway, Hicksville

Customers` Favorites

Vegetarian Eggless Pastries
Panini Sandwich Non-Veg
Pineapple Pastry
Gobi Manchurian
Specialty Cakes
Bombay Sandwich
Eggless Cakes
Birthday Cake
Black Forest
Butterscotch

“Love their pastries, cakes and snacks. 5 stars.“

4.4 Superb81 Reviews
Punto Rojo Bakery Hicksville 2 Colombian • $
228 W Old Country Rd, Hicksville

Customers` Favorites

Calentado Desayuno Colombiano
Rice & Beans Arroz Y Frijol
Morcilla and Beef Empanada
Churrasco a La Barbacoa
Pollo Chicken Empanada
Chicharron and Maduros
Asopado De Mariscos
Calamres Fritos
Rice and Beans
Bandeja Paisa

“I was last Sunday and everything was good the attention very good and fast tank you“

4.1 Good99 Reviews
Bagel Boss Hicksville Bakery • $
432 S Oyster Bay Rd, Hicksville

Customers` Favorites

Lox and Cream Cheese with Red Onions
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Bagel with Butter
Blueberry Bagels
Cinnamon Raisin
Rainbow Bagel
Potato Salad
Tuna Salad
Cookies
Salads

“In my numerous trips to Bagel Boss, I have found the counter people to be kind, nice & helpful. The bagels are huge & fresh. Some bagels seem to lack flavor but more then make up for it in size freshness. I find some customers to be a problem with their ridiculous expectations!“

3.5 Good167 Reviews
San Eduardo Deli & Bakery Deli • $
40 Jerusalem Ave, Hicksville

“Deli San Eduardo means feeling at home, typical Latin American food, every day for those who love beans, rice, there is no shortage of them, they have bread made right there, their treatment is friendly and respectful, always a greeting, there is consumption in The place also takes away, the prices are within everyone's reach.

Parking: If you are going to buy food or consumption there it is fine otherwise you must have the parking sticker.

Kid-friendliness: Yes it can be consumed as a family

Wheelchair accessibility: If there is access at both doors“

3.9 Good29 Reviews