30 Best Pizza Restaurants near High Falls

“Expensive but good food….“

“I love this restaurant, it’s definitely one of my all time favorites. It has amazing flatbread pizza with all the gourmet toppings you can think AND they have a few dinner specials that are absolutely delicious. Lastly, everything is fresh, tasty and not overly priced. If you haven’t been here you are missing out.“

“Amazing food and service easily the best the the surrounding area“

“I go to Rino's for the amazing customer service - I go back to Rino's for the delicious food. While you're waitingon the0tk0p, check out the little Italian grocery section full of imported oils and vinegar and traditional ils school pasta shapes like orecchiette.“

“Delicious food, friendly staff and atmosphere. Highly recommended“

“Meatball subs are so good, if u like a lot of sauce, make sure u ask for it!
Pizza is always good!!

I was bummed when the girl told me the other day that baked ziti had meat sauce!
That was a flat out lie! I would have never gotten it.
So about 20 dollars for noodles and sauce oh and some cheese! I will keep five stars because this is just my review!“

“This restaurant is the best in town we order from them all the time never an issue . Always delicious food anything you try, big portions and nice staff. I highly recommend y’all try it out. Oh and that chocolate cake is to die for huge pieces too.“

“Beautiful grounds, food and wine were amazing. Highly recommend, best of all, the staff were all super nice. Can’t wait to go back.“

“The best pizza and garlic knots I've ever had! Huge slices, tons of toppings, the perfect crust and spectacular flavor! I live in another state and make sure to stop into Benny's every time I visit home again. I recommend this place to everyone, it's the absolute top of the list when it comes to real NY pizza. 10/10 must try!“

“The girls at the counter are a pleasure and the pizza delicious and if u haven’t tried the salad bar it’s a must !!“

“I've become something of an M.T. Wentz figure: my fame in the Hudson Valley food scene has grown to a point where I can no longer give my name for an order or reservation without raising some eyebrows. This, however, is not a problem at Ollie's. A true New York slice shop, they simply take your order and yell it back out at you 3 seconds before it's ready—piping hot. No time for names. Famous? Big whoop. Next in line (please). Those who are not from the area may consider this to be a lack of service or regard for the clientele. But in reality it is a form of hidden egalitarianism that can only be found where high velocity is the culture.“

“We have been ordering take out at the New Paltz location for years and always, always have had the best meals ever! We have eaten in the restaurant a few times too, and the staff was so nice and accommodating. But the best is just getting an absolutely tasty meal to eat at home after a busy day. The prices are reasonable and portions are huge! My husband and I highly recommend Pasqule's!“

“Cool atmosphere, good coffee and really tasty sandwiches!“

“Great food and a very friendly staff. Good selection of food and drinks. Great draft beer and generous portions of food.Prices are very reasonable also.“

“I always enjoy their food, absolutely hands down the best quesadilla's around!!! Friendly and affordable with an authentic atmosphere.“

“Amazing hosts and great food.“

“I absolutely love it here!! The food is so good it’s almost impossible to find something you don’t like. There is a very kind lady that works at the counter and is always fun to talk to. I will definitely be going here more often. 100% will be recommending this place to all my friends and family.“

“What a Joy to have this place on our way home to Kerhonkson.

We lucked out and landed on a Tuesday in which there is a special promotion for a pie. Not that you need one because the pies at GP are astronomical (and delicious).

I stopped by with my 3yr old and pregnant wife , and we didn't have to break the piggy bank to satisfy our cravings, which were insatiable.

I believe it was the owners who served us then his team mates who were all graceful and professional.

Tell you what, I think we'll stop by again.

Keep it up keep it real!“

“The girls at the counter are a pleasure and the pizza delicious and if u haven’t tried the salad bar it’s a must !!“

“Maria and her team are fantastic - amazing - wonderful. She is a consummate professional, easy to communicate with, and provides the most delicious, satisfying food and impeccable service. She helped pull together a custom dinner for 80+ starving rock climbers without skipping a beat. She predicted our hungry behavior better than I could!! Everyone raved about the food (pasta, salad, main dishes, gluten free pasta, cookies = delish!), and we can't wait to come back to New Paltz and work with her again in the future. THANK YOU AGAIN, MARIA! YOU ARE A ROCKSTAR!“

“Just stay in a motel near that spot ,so let's try 😜 Amazing bacon chess burger, delicious meat baked spaghetti,salads Everything is fresh,crispy and just melted in your mouth Staff is so friendly and smiles all the way Highly recommended 💯👊!“

“It is very nice place relaxing ,good pizza ,beer…“

“I have to go back another couple of three times at least until I can get to taste it all. Mid-week and it was packed. A bit too loud for conversation but I don't talk with my mouth full of fabulous fresh made gluten free pizza, thick chewy crunchy crust ( not the frozen one every other place uses) whipped ricotta cheese and fresh basil. The house well is stocked with good choices. One note is that because of the crowds frozen cocktails are pre-made so you can't pick your rum.

Dietary restrictions: Top choice for an artisan gluten free pizza ?“

“It was my first time here and what we had was very good. A few different kinds of slices (pepperoni, brocolli/bacon/cheese, and mushroom) and fried ravioli. Want to try the subs next time. Menu had a variety of pizzas, subs, and pastas. They also cater and have a family pizza deal.“

“Had the most delicious meal last night - the oven bread was steaming and so light and airy. The Caesar salad was perfect - I had a special with tortellini that was also my lunch and dinner today! Wonderful staff and a relaxed atmosphere. Truly a gem!!“

“I used to look forward to eating there. But the last two times I had the worst servers. One never came back to check after she dropped off my food. I had wanted a soda refill and another napkin, had to find her to get my check. Last night I came in and was told the kitchen was about to close so I needed to hurry up (I just sat down at about 9:25 pm). I ordered right away. An ice water and a coke and a meatball parm sub. I was lucky to get my soda with her attitude. No ice water was brought or acknowledged at all. I took a few bites of my food and she asked if I wanted a box. I was really irritated. If they told me to go only I would have been fine. But the way I was handled made me angry. I ate quickly and left. If I choose to get something again , it will be to go. Honestly, Caitlyn is the best server there. She is five stars. The others are not worth a dime.“

“We used to love this place. Until me and my wife are sitting at a table eating our pizza when a worker decides to clean the rugs an hour before closing. He shook the rug in the air next to our table got dirt and dust all over us and our food never going back.“

“I grew up in NYC and during my teenage years in the 60's discovered middle eastern cuisine. It was the choice for "fast & delicious meals" Now my discovery in Rosendale has presented me the delicious opportunity to learn the exceptional cuisine offered at The Garden House. everything I've eaten is mouth watering wonderful. The community of welcomeness is abundant each time you visit. Enjoy a 5 star meal.“

“Popped in after hair cut. Vinnie and Jeff were friendly, worked well together, got my order quickly, and enjoyed the delightful banter. Clean, well maintained, I’ll be back!“

“Great place to spend an afternoon with friends and pups! We thought the pizza was delicious and loved having the flights of cider. There’s a nice shaded pavilion where the dogs can hang too. Also a beautiful pond where we saw geese and a turtle! Would definitely recommend this place!“