16 Best Steakhouses near Island Park

“I placed a catering order and went to Island Park for pick up. I met, while there, Angie Chieffo. She and her staff were wonderful, helpful and in the Holiday spirit. Angie went above and beyond to assist me. I am a loyal customer and she is part of the reason why. Thanks again Angie!!!!“

“I’m just shy of 50 and this is my first time in LI while residing in NY my entire life. My gf and I came down from Saratoga last minute after our trip to Lauderdale was canceled. We thank Jimmy Hays, his awesome staff and friendly local regulars for their hospitality and overall friendliness. We sat at the bar, felt like I was home at my local favorite establishment. Hands down the best meal we had in town and time spent. I would come down for this experience again & again now that I know where to go! Joe Cox, Saratoga NY“

“The food was fresh and delicious ! The menu items were unique! The atmosphere was spacious and comfortable. The service was friendly and on point ! The staff seemed to be enthusiastic to serve us and have us try new things, took the time to explain our options and made confident recommendations. It was more than a great meal but an overall enjoyable experience I highly recommend it and can’t wait to go back with friends and family 😊“

“Unbelievable! Great food, great fun, and the best service! Can’t wait to go back!“

“Very friendly staff and great service food was amazing and very nice cocktails“

“We dined at the Majors Restaurant in East Meadow. Dinner was delicious. I have no complaints about that. Here is my issue. Little, but it’s the principle. My husband ordered a cup of coffee after our $158 Dinner. The coffee came and when he put milk in it, I noticed it was really dark. I tasted it. WOW it was burnt, old & muddy. I called the waiter over and asked for a new brewed cup of coffee. He came back with a cup from the SAME pot. Normally I would of just moved on & left it. But when the bill came we were charged $3.50. For 1 cup of burnt coffee? Sorry it was the principle. If you are going to charge your clients $3.50 for a cup of coffee, invest in a Keurig where every cup is fresh. You make a great margin per cup?“

“From NC and my boi Terrell suggested here. Food and ambience was absolutely incredible!! Will definitely come back!“

“Great service along with amazing food!“

“As always very good dinner 🥰“

“"An Exquisite Experience at PrimeHouse, Garden City" Recently, I had the pleasure of dining at PrimeHouse in Garden City, and it was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere captivated me with its beautiful decor - a perfect blend of elegance and comfort. The real stars of the evening, however, were our host and hostesses, Jaime and Nick. Their attentive service, warm smiles, and expert knowledge of the menu made our experience truly memorable. They went above and beyond to ensure our comfort, making us feel like VIPs throughout the night. Now, let’s talk about the food - it was divine! Every dish was a culinary masterpiece, bursting with flavors that tantalized my taste buds. The chefs at PrimeHouse clearly know their craft and take great pride in their creations. Another noteworthy aspect was the parking facility. It was conveniently located and spacious, making the start and end of our dining experience hassle-free. In conclusion, PrimeHouse in Garden City is a must-visit. Whether it’s for a special occasion or just a casual night out, it promises an exceptional dining experience with fabulous food, top-notch service, and a delightful ambiance. Hats off to Jaime and Nick for making our evening so special!“

“The food was very tasty! The service was outstanding. Likewise, the welcoming atmosphere was GREAT!!! Kudos to the Texas Roadhouse Restaurant!!!👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾“

“Love this place and their tasty food, will defo be back for more, a great experience.“

“Great place and nice food“

“From start to finish, everything at Prime Bistro was outstanding. The sushi was incredibly fresh and flavorful — honestly some of the best I’ve had in a long time. And the meal only got better from there, ending with a perfectly cooked tomahawk steak that was tender, juicy, and packed with flavor. The service was excellent and the atmosphere was warm and welcoming. Highly recommend this place whether you’re coming for sushi, steak, or both.“

“Visited Ruth's Chris on January 19, 2026 (the day before my birthday) for an early celebration with my wife—overall a good experience, but with some frustrations. The atmosphere was upscale and inviting, though very loud and crowded that evening, which made it feel a bit understaffed. We both enjoyed our meals; service was attentive and friendly, the hostess who sat us down noticed my upcoming birthday (likely from OpenTable) and asked whose it was. My wife pointed me out, and they treated us to a complimentary dessert, which was a nice touch and made it feel celebratory. However, our table was in a high-traffic area, so staff (servers, busboys) kept bumping my chair throughout the night, which was annoying and disrupted the meal. They apologized each time, which was appreciated, but it happened repeatedly.“

“I really wanted to be away from too many people. I don’t like crowds too much and my frame of mind was such that I just wanted to sit and eat and just be at ease before my flight. I have had no prior experience with this restaurant nor T5 at JFK to begin with. I was greeted almost instantly when arrived and was seated within a minute. I would say within 15 or so minutes, the food arrived and it tasted delicious. I ordered buffalo wings, fries and a Pepsi. Whilst seated, I looked online for reviews and found it to be surprising since most were negative. I had a brief chat with my server and she was receptive towards my positive feedback. You can see the initial hesitancy at first because she probably figured I wanted to complain but it was the opposite. Her body language warmed up to me and she actually stroked up a secondary conversation just before I left. Basically, you will get better service when it’s not so busy. When I went, the place was 90% empty. Go brave!“