50 Best Mexican Restaurants near Islip Terrace

“Exelente Servicio y deliciosa comida.!! Recomendado el 💯. Bendiciones.!“

“I ordered from this place thinking it would be a one-time thing, and I was definitely wrong. This spot has, by far, the best tacos, bowls, Nachos and burritos I’ve ever tasted. Everything was packed with care, and the service was fast and friendly when I went to pay.
They do not have a place to sit and eat since it's a food truck not sure if they do in the summer time

Tip: Paying cash is cheaper than using a credit card since the card fees are added to your order. They do take Mastercard visa and Amex“

“This is my first time ordering food from Fat Boys Burrito for my meetings (grilled chicken burritos, bang ban shrimp tacos, guacamole & chips). Their food is absolutely delicious. The variety of dishes offered, quality service and presentation is exceptional! I will definitely be ordering again. Thanks Tony and team!“

“excelente servicio...la comida riquísima....ambiente muy cálido...buena música. en fin todo es excelente“

“Right Coast Taqueria provided our lunch for our Teacher Appreciation week in Smithtown. The faculty raved about the food and presentation!! They accommodated food allergies. Great business to work with!!“

“I have been seeing such positive reviews about this place so my husband and I decided to finally try the place today! Absolutely amazing! The service was great from start to finish, the food was delicious. We arrived around 5:45 and it was pretty busy, definitely recommend making a reservation prior just to ensure a seat but we didn’t have to wait!
You can tell the owners & employees are serious about their food and their dedication to providing good food!

Started with Esquites- their Mexican street corn

Drinks: I had both mocktails Guava-Coconut Water Refresher and the Floral Breeze(will have picture ) ( currently pregnant but very much looking forward to their margaritas!)

My husband ordered a Moscow mule but received something similar to an old fashioned which was no big deal because he still enjoyed the drink.

Dinners Birria Taqueria and Carne Asada Taqueria

We opted out of desert tonight but will be getting it next time!“

“A five-star experience at The Green Gem in Smithtown. Everything tasted incredibly fresh and authentic, and you can see that every dish is made completely from scratch in front of you. The flavors stood out in every bite, especially the chicken and steak tacos, zucchini pupusa, and fajitas.

This is a wonderful family-owned spot with genuinely kind people The restaurant itself was very clean and well kept, they wiped the grill down each time they made a dish and use gloves. The portions were generous, and everything was so delicious that we left completely stuffed and I still have enough for lunch the next day. Prices were very reasonable for the quality and freshness of the food. Overall, it was an amazing experience, and I’m already looking forward to coming back. Thank you, Elmer for the great service and hospitality.“

“the Pico is always fresh and the service is great“

“What better way to christen the brand new hot tub than with quesidilllas and margaritas from Burrito Blvd.!“

“Never disappoints Great portions and staff Love the music and the atmosphere food comes out fast and hot love the decorations in the place overall a great experience“

“awesome menu items great service“

“This is the place To go for lunch / dinner. The food is always fresh and delicious regardless of the time I go. I stop here 3-5 days a week and it’s always consistently good. In addition to the great food, the staff is always warm and kind.“

“So authentic and great service! The worry dolls were an added bonus as I was there with my daughter. Perfect birthday, love the philanthropy also! Guacamole was the best I’ve ever had.“

“This is our go-to restaurant, what a gem. Delicious food, super friendly people, and Juan makes the best margaritas that I have ever had! We highly recommend this spot, make sure you try one of their specials.“

“This place is absolutely amazing!!!!! Jim the manager was such a nice guy and made me feel so welcomed. The food is absolutely delicious!!!!!! 10/10 recommend! The store is very clean and professional! All employees here deserve a pat on the back for making this experience so perfect! Thanks again!!“

“the food was good, but they need a better air filter system the smell of burning isn't appealing while you eat. the place was clean, the servers were great. it was just another version of taco bell mixed with chipotle. but this is just my VYI's keeping it real view,we enjoyed the bowls, plenty of food in each. we will go back next month to try their salad.“

“nice simple atmosphere food is great with multiple choices,,,just had fish tacos today big and delicious, have had taco bowl, chicken steak and beef tacos, chorizo quesadillas, ordered platter of mixed tacos for family get together gone in 5 minutes no kidding, staff nice knowledgeable, family owned...right next to benkerts bakery in centereach...help their family business by stopping by...i do on my way home from work“

“We ordered take out after seeing this place on social media everything was amazing I especially enjoyed the Birria egg rolls which had amazing crunch and packed with flavors, everyone inside greeted us with smiles as well great place plan to go again“

“Had the pleasure of eating at the Greenport location. Two of my HS girlfriends and myself on moderately busy on Sunday (1012/24) at about 5:30. A young waiter named Brian was our server. We first ordered drinks, mine was the margarita with the pomegranate swirl. So delicious!! Refreshing and frosty! We shared the Mexican Street corn and the three dips with chips, which were freshly made. So fabulous! So tasty. The salsa, guacamole and queso were just perfect, each different but delicious!! The corn was sweet and flavorful. I had three tacos in hard shells. Fried chicken, fried shrimp and the marinated steak. Each one was different and very fresh. My one friend, is a vegetarian and the other is gluten intolerant BUT! They each found many yummy choices! I’ve been trying to get to this restaurant for several years, and finally the planets aligned! Brian was well trained, patient and informative with a good humor. The interior is bright, festive and clean. So much food, I could not finish all of it. And!! the restroom was clean! You should be very proud of this business! We will be back! Thank you!!“

“Went here for the first time tonight. This place is unassuming. You might think to pass it by. But the food is excellent, Margaritas are wonderful! The staff is amazing and so caring! It has a long history in the community and has a huge following. If you know you know. Don't be scared - check it out. We did and we are happy 😁“

“the Pico is always fresh and the service is great“

“I found this after my midnight workout driving down DPA coming home from the gym. Little pricey(but what isnt) but all in all, the food was down right delicious. Then a week later, I got a craving for it again. Mix and match what you want in the wraps or bowl, LIttle of this , little of that, put that sauce here on the side. The hot salsa has a kick.“

“Best around, hands down.
Maria has put a lot of resources into the place to create the ultimate dining experience. The tapas nights are top notch. The gambas, black bean soup, beef nachos and fajitas are not to be beat by anyone. We stop regularly and are always delighted. Highly recommend. So many margarita variations we can't even count them all.“

“This place is absolutely amazing. I came in just to grab a quick bite to eat but everything looks so delicious.

I don't know what they call it but I tried a cactus leaf and it was delicious. It has such a flavor that is similar to I guess an artichoke but also very different at the exact same time.

I had two chicken tacos and one chorizo. I love the fact that they have a bar where you can add as much salsa and toppings as you want.

So delicious.

The place is so clean and spotless it's not even funny. Guys behind the counter are awesome and I already be back.“

“Some of their food is not the same and I noticed that it’s on certain days when they have the younger ones working in the kitchen. They need to have quality control when the more experienced cooks are not working..“

“Amazing food great service“

“Great place to celebrate & outdoor tables in summer to enjoy with your dogs…“

“The tacos, the nachos, the burritos, the quesadillas, this is the place you never knew you needed!! By the way they have more yummy choices, I just haven’t gotten through them yet!!“

“Friendly staff, great variety of food!🌮🌯“

“Every time I go to this restaurant, I am greeted warmly by staff that are genuinely happy. The food is always perfect and delicious and prepared the way I like it. The restaurant is always clean and the food is always fresh. I am looking forward to my next visit.“

“This place is a breath of fresh air for the area. Being a new HALAL option that is the equivalent of a premium style chipotle. The owners and employees are great while serving fresh and delicious products to guests. It’s become one of mine and my wife’s rotations through the week!“

“Some of the best food around dine in and takeout. I have been going here for years and the food is consistently fresh, portion size has not changed , and the sister and brother who own it are
very friendly. May I add the service is also fabulous. Highly recommend!!“

“Our go to Mexican restaurant. Authentic and fresh Mexican food. Drinks are amazing. Natural margaritas are perfect. Highly recommend for happy hour, Taco Tuesday specials. But good any time or day of the week for dinner or drinks. We love Claudia and Rosita. They are always welcoming and friendly. Service is great too!“

“Great local restaurant with a ton of options on the menu. The food was unanimously amazing, the service was pleasant, and the restaurant was clean and comfortable. My wife and I split the Bandeja Paisa platter and it was so much food we had a full serving left over to bring home. My toddler’s cheese quesadilla was delicious. Looking forwards to eating here again soon!“

“I've come here a few times . Every time the food is great . I've had huaraches , chicken tacos , baleadas , papusas , rice and beans , and avocado salad . The owner speaks English so it's easy to communicate what I want and he's friendly. The prices are good too ! I eat at a lot of latin food places to compare .“

“On busy nights when we want something quick, healthy, and satisfying, the CrossFit menu is a standout—chicken and shrimp always cooked to perfection, and the salsa and guacamole are always fresh and flavorful. The food is consistently excellent, and the service is just as reliable. Oscar, the owner, is exceptional—always attentive, efficient, kind, and genuinely committed to creating a great experience for every customer. We’re grateful to have a place like this in the neighborhood!“

“This place has quickly become one of our go-to spots. The food is seriously worth every penny. Everything tastes fresh, full of flavor, and the portions are solid. My boyfriend is from California and he’s pretty picky about Mexican food, but he says this is the closest he’s had to back home. That alone says a lot.

It’s the kind of spot you try once and then it just becomes part of your regular rotation. Definitely recommend if you’re craving something satisfying and legit.“

“los tacos de birria con su consome son lo mejor y si pides un agua fresca de tamarindo .. los mejores que e probado ...“

“Always fresh and delicious, a Bohemia gem for authenticity and quality food. Clean clean clean and underrated for this level of deliciousness.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
We hired Cochinita Porky Food Truck for our annual neighborhood Halloween parade and block party, and they did an amazing job! The service was fast, the food was made to order, super fresh, and everyone loved it. The kids especially enjoyed the playful pig-themed truck with its glowing LED eyes — such a fun touch! 🐷✨
I highly recommend them for any private event — delicious food, great people, and an awesome vibe!“

“Fun night. Great drinks. Fab food“

“We come here often for lunch. The buffalo and Vanessa burritos are our favs plus the quesadillas are the best around and huge. This review is specifically about catering order I placed over the weekend. We made a very last minute order for a taco party pack and Avocados went out of their way to accommodate. The food was great and large portions as always.“

“Great food. Centereach location is where I go frequently. Staff is great.“

“this was my second time there and enjoyed the food and the strawberry margarita. Their guacamole is the best ever! The lady's room was very bright and clean. The manager Manuel was gracious and pleasant. Looking forward to going there again“

“Son ricas las Tortas y los tacos 🌮, se los recomiendo 😋😋😋“

“Nice place and attendants“

“The food here is amazing, like actually some of the best tacos I’ve ever had. Just be warned that the online ordering system on their website is not connected in store, they will not receive your order and you will have to re-order in store. Also none of the employees speak English, but that’s pretty expected for anywhere with authentic delicious Mexican food!“

“very very good food. fast service. no heartburn...9.5 on my taco scale 👍“

“Checked them out today. I tried the steak taco...it was absolutely delicious ! Staff was friendly, restaurant is clean everything's was fresh . Definitely worth checking out“

“I just got done sobbing uncontrollably for 15 minutes because I realized I forgot half of my Pueblo Burrito in my purse. This place has me considering exposing my self to listeria so that I can tantalize my taste buds one more time 😭

On the real, Vallarta is not talked about enough. We love their chicken and steak platter, kids chicken quesadillas, nachos and OBVIOUSLY the Puebla Burrito. It’s so fresh and healthy.

Kelly in the front is the most lovely person to yap with and the guys in the back are always smiling. If you live further than 5 min away don’t even bother calling your food order in because it will get cold, they make it so fast.

Cuando estás allí, eres de la familia.

WE LOVE YOU VALLARTA 🫶“