9 Best Burger Restaurants in Ithaca

“Ithaca Ale House is a pub-style restaurant with a variety of beer and drink options, and a food menu that includes typical items such as burgers, wings, and salads. Standout dishes include the boneless wings with ale house sauce, which has just the right amount of spice and great flavor, and the crab cakes, which are made with high-quality crab and not filled with breading or fillers. The service is generally friendly, but can be slow when the restaurant gets busy. Some dishes, like the onion soup and calamari, may be hit or miss in terms of quality. The restaurant can get crowded in the evenings, and there have been reports of long wait times for food and slow service. Additionally, side orders such as asparagus can only be ordered with certain dishes, and requests for additional items may be denied.“

“Ithaca Beer Co. - Collegetown offers excellent food and beer options. The Taproom burger and Fried Chicken Sandwich are standouts, with the latter being praised as one of the best ever had. Other popular options include the Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich, Smashed Burger, and Pizzas. While some dishes, like the salad, may need improvement, the overall dining experience is enjoyable. Service can be slow at times and orders may not always be accurate. Despite some minor issues, the restaurant's excellent food and beer make it a great choice for visitors and locals alike.“

“Uncle Joe's Grill & Sports Bar is a hidden gem for football fans. The atmosphere is perfect for watching games while enjoying delicious burgers and wings. The homemade hot sauce gives the burgers an original taste. The bartender is friendly and makes great cocktail recommendations. Free pool adds to the fun, making it easy to spend a few hours here. It may not be high-end, but the food really hits the spot.“

“Ithaca Beer Co. offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere, with good vibes from the staff. Even during busy times like Cornell Graduation weekend, the service remains excellent and prompt. The food quality is consistent, and customers are greeted with a smile. The Ginger Beer is particularly impressive, leaving a fantastic tingle on the tongue, making it a perfect match for rye whiskey. A great place for enjoying brewery beer and delicious meals.“

“Applebee's Grill + Bar offers a mixed dining experience. While some guests have reported long wait times for drinks and issues with food quality, others have enjoyed their meals. The Garlic Steak Skillet was a highlight, with tender steak and flavorful garlic butter. However, some dishes may have drawbacks, such as dry chicken or underwhelming salads. The restaurant's layout and decor vary by location, but most have wheelchair-accessible parking and entrances. With a variety of options available, including delivery through DoorDash, Applebee's Grill + Bar caters to different tastes and needs.“

“Five Guys offers tasty burgers, fresh ingredients, and great milkshakes. The prices, however, are on the high side, with some customers feeling it's not reasonably priced. The burgers have thin patties, but the vegetables are fresh. The fries can be hit or miss, with some being soggy or cold. Despite the high prices, the food is hot and fresh, with the added bonus of complimentary peanuts. Overall, the quality of the food is good, but the high prices may deter some customers from returning.“

“Far and away the best BBQ in the area“

“D.P. Dough is a restaurant that is open until 3am, offering delivery service. The delivery times are often faster than expected and the drivers are known to be friendly. The taste of the food is acceptable, but some may be disappointed with the amount of sauce on their meal. The calzones are a popular choice and are said to have a perfect first bite. However, some may find that the rest of the calzone doesn't live up to the initial taste. D.P. Dough is not fine dining, but rather utilitarian fare. It is best enjoyed as "drunk food" and should not be compared to other nearby pizza places. The marinara sauce is noted to be a bit too sweet. It is distinct in that it delivers to your location. The "speed zone" calzone with ranch is a recommended order.“

“Jack's Grill offers a welcoming atmosphere, perfect for date nights or group gatherings. The service is fast, friendly, and kind, with staff going the extra mile to ensure a great experience. The food is well-priced and generous in portion size, with some customers raving about the quality. While some may find the burger patty size or milkshake quantity lacking, overall, Jack's Grill is a great value for the money, making it a popular spot to stop in while in Ithaca.“