23 Best Pizza Restaurants in Ithaca

“Have never had a bad meal here. The pizza is always delicious with fresh toppings and you can build your own with whatever you want on it for, no additional charge unless it’s a specialty topping. Then tonight, I tried the Cannoli pie for the 1st time… it was incredible… the crust was sooo good! We will continue to support🤩“

“Thanks. Guys There. Pizza. Is. Os. Good“

“We both really enjoyed the pizza. Love the crispy crust too! Toppings were fantastic! We will definitely need to come back! We'll spread the word!!!“

“excellent food good people“

“Everything about Sal's is simply the best! We make trips up from Corning just to make a stop here. They have the best gluten free pizza around and their garbage wings are delicious! They always are friendly and make you feel welcomed. After a few visits they remember you and make you feel like family.“

“Top notch service and amazing food. I’ve been working a construction job for over a year now, across the street from here and we all go for lunch often. Kamal specifically always helps us get our lunch very fast and affordable. Highly recommend“

“My food did not come out how I had expected. My waitress (Molly) was very fast to fix it, she went to get her manager (Erika) so I could ask some questions about the steak being changed from what they previously serve, she said yes. I told her what I wanted and she made sure that I got it. The attention to detail she has is amazing and if my business was big enough that I needed a manager I would have tried to snag her. She is the type of manger that business owners look for. She helps bus tables to save time to get more people seated. I see that she is an asset to the way that Ciao is run!! She deserves to be recognized!“

“great pizza, my sister n I loved it“

“My boyfriend bought a piece of pizza at Press Bay Alley today from Adelina’s truck. I had already eaten lunch but couldn’t resist taking bite after bite of his pizza. The contrast of crunch and warm softness was perfect. The sauces, textures and flavors were fresh, thoughtfully balanced and paired, and the best way I can put it, is that you can taste the intention in this food. It is so hard to come by food that has this kind of presence. If you are going to eat some pizza, this is it. Bravo 💛.“

“I have been buying gas and and occasional pizza slice for years and have always been happy. Last night I ordered a whole cheese pizza planning to put my own anchovies on it. I was supper happy with the quality of the pizza and more than amazed at the price of $8 for a large pie. This is half the price of most other local pizza shops and equal to the quality. This is our "go to" place for take away pizza from now on.“

“Las pizzas más ricas que he probado!“

“I was visiting Ithaca from out of town and stopped by More Than Pizza – and I’m so glad I did! The staff was incredibly welcoming and made me feel right at home. Their kindness and hospitality truly stood out. On top of that, the food was amazing – fresh, delicious, and made with care. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this place is a must-visit. Highly recommend!“

“You know what? I’ve been by this place since I moved to NY 7 years ago. It looks like a little shack, kind of unappealing, sorry just first look. But I decided to place an order and when I got there, the Steelers fan was so polite(who would have thought) and it was so fresh and hot. It got it back to my work and it was amazing. I couldn’t believe that little shack had such good pizza and wings!!! Thanks guys!

Parking: Go into the drive thru entrance and there is parking or just roll right up to the window!“

“Papa John's is good but honestly starting to think speedway is better tasting, their cheese tastes fresh and flavorful. bought both tonight and speedway is by far better“

“Late night dinner option was prepared beautifully on a thin crust, white mushroom pizza, perfectly done with the cranberry goat cheese, spinach salad that paired superbly together.Thank you to whoever created this meal for me last night as it was probably the best pizza I’ve ever had. Highly recommend!

Vegetarian options: White mushroom pizza and goat cheese cranberry salad!“

“Ordered a supreme last night..it was amazing!!! Will definitely be frequenting this place☺️“

“Fabulous food, huge portions, reasonably priced, and terrific service!“

“It's a good store in many ways, but I have some complaints. One is that they keep rearranging things and they do not use a logical placement (like all kinds of cookies together, not spread about). Secondly, I want to comment on milk containers, and don't know how to make a fresh post. Here's the comment: The caps on all "Pure Pak" containers are Very Hard To Open. The problem is a catch built into the cap, probably some middle manager's idea to increase security. Well it's a disaster for older people or anyone with weak hands. We have to use pliers or a nutcracker. Ridiculous. Open your milk with pliers? Absurd! It's milk, or Almond milk. Even kids should be able to open the container.“

“Awesome food, fast service and great prices!!! Highly recommend!!! 5 stars!!!“

“I had the lemon artichoke pasta . It was excellent along with the service !“

“This is a wonderful place to eat, have some excellent drinks, and socialize.“

“This place is not to be missed. Best food found at any brewery! Great variety of food without being too complicated. Everything is sourced locally. Something for vegetarians and meat eaters. The roast beef sandwich is off the hook. Tender as butter. Pizza is perfectly thin and chewy with a generous amount of toppings. Not soggy just… perfect. The drink menu is wonderful. Something for everyone and the best in its class. From the multifaceted root beer, to the effervescent ginger beer to a broad selection of various styles of beer, including a sour and specialty barrel aged limited editions, this place has it all. Not into beer? that’s ok because they hv creative cocktails and a crisp dry easily drank cider as well. The ambiance is chill and creative. There’s bar space or tables to suit ur mood. When the weather is warmer they hv a patio that is large, inviting and nicely styled. Pups are welcome outside too! Looking forward to trivia night on Wed and working my way thru the menu. Haven’t been this impressed with a menu and its implications in a long time. The folks who work at IBC are so kind, patient, well informed and enthusiastic. Kudos to the Sunday gang Evan, Amanda, Jim(Bo) and of course chef Joe! Great customer service on all levels. Don’t pass up Ithaca Beer Co!“