Irish Restaurants near Jamaica, NY

“Just a great neighborhood pub.“

“Great experience with their indoor dining. Friendly Staff especially Elias whose is very accommodating and helpful. Food is also great especially their family pizza,salads and Fred Calamari. My family and I keeps on coming back into the Cafe almost daily and without hesitation I highly recommend this place..“

“Amazing place.Excellent Food. Highly recommend. 2 drink min.“

“Had my husband’s surprise party this weekend. My family has had parties their in the past and Monahan’s continues to live up to their excellent reputation. The servers were so friendly, professional and engaging with our family…their personalities are perfect for their jobs….thank you so much. The food was outstanding….first time we had the stuffed mushroom and they were amazing. All our appetizers, The London broil, turkey and pasta salad were just perfect. My guests were very happy. My family continues to highly recommend Monahan’s. Thank you so much Jeff 😀“

“This restaurant has been in Whitestone for over 38 years and it’s a secret Gem the stuffed veal chop is enormous and it’s awesome the staff is really nice and the marinated steak is the best if in Whitestone it’s worth the trip“

“Love the food but upset to see none of staff wearing masks, as well as many of the customers. What's the reason for that?“

“Shepherd's pie is terrific. As is mostly everything on the menu“

“High expectations, but not impressed with this visit. Wednesday early dinner , 7/23/25, 5pm.
No issue with availability and service, very attentive.
Chicken dish with sauce ok, but asparagus flimsy and green bean sized while mashed potatoes served ice cream scoop and lacking in flavor.
Long awaited favorite of mine, fish and chips.
Fish better than most in area, still lacking in wow factor while the (chips) were a flimsy mess , no crisp or seasoning.
As to beer, Stella was fine but Blue Moon dark and flat.
Better luck next time.“

“I got chocolate chips pancake and turkey egg cheese with home fries. Sandwich was good, they added tomato sauce with mayo, so it all blend in together. The pancake was little disappointing as I had to eat it dry because didn’t provide any syrup. But it was soft and fresh. Would order here again.“

“New menu...OMG!...and must try!...the ruben!...the best we EVER had!...the chicken curry half and half...the most unique warm flavor that makes you want more!...the staff?...the most attentive caring warm humans!“

“Classic Irish pub and a neighborhood staple, with a homey atmosphere, great service and solidly delicious pub standards. We had the beef sliders, mini shepherds pie, onion rings and buffalo wings- all served quickly and with excellent service. We came on a night that was absolutely slammed due to a concert in Forest Hills Stadium being cancelled. The servers here handled the rush with grace and speed, and kept everyone happy with attentive service.“

“Las hamburguesas Woodside exquisitas, bien servidas y con ganas de comerse dos... Muy buen servicio además... Ah, y para completar, cerveza...“

“Great group good food and great drinks.“

“The nicest staff you ever will meet . Real neighborly feel whether you live in area or travel a half hour like I do . Great value for the many of us on a budget . Much cheaper night out than a night at the Diner and a lot more fun“

“Good friends with good bands!“

“This is one of my favorite place to go. Eileen is very awesome as is the rest of the staff. This is a true gem for a service worker like myself. Monday is my Friday and my friends will walk over here with me and let me get a proper pint or three. Life ain’t so bad when you can sit here for an evening.“

“Found this place doing an internet search and didn’t know what to expect. Friendly local bar and staff, wide range of comfort food on the menu, and Smithwicks on draft. A very pleasant experience!“

“The greatest neighborhood bar in NY City. It’s a place “Where Everyone Knows Your Name.” Yes that is a reference to Cheers 🤣“

“Great local joint Recommend if you want to do shots and watch the game“

“Great food great customer service“

“Our group had a wonderful experience at Sullivan’s Quay. Delicious food, cocktails and great service. Thank you Brian and crew! We will be back!💕“

“We were looking for a bar with good prices and relaxing atmosphere for some time with friends. This place did the trick.Breege was a friendly and good bartender. Our first time but the pours were good as were the prices. If we're ever in the area we will try it again.“

“Been there a few times. I must say food is fantastic!!! The fish tacos and the southwestern chicken sandwich is a must try. They have different specials everyday. Friendly atmosphere, service is very attentive. Love trivia nights and live music on Saturdays. So far is my favorite place to go with friends and family. Great spot for lunch, dinner and weekend brunch. Highly recommended!!“

“Went there for company presentation so only had some of there appetizers. The chicken fingers mozzarella sticks and spring rolls. All were very tasty and the portion was great. All were served with tasty sauce. The staff was very friendly and helpful. Other people that were there were raving about the foods that they had. The only downfall is parking around there.“