50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Jefferson Valley Yorktown

“Their chicken parm & meatball wedges are FANTASTIC! A must to try!!!!!!“

“I really enjoyed the food it was really amazing ?. The atmosphere was really great. The only thing that was a bit off was that it took an incredibly long amount of time for us to actually get our food. We got there at 6:15 and we didn't actually get our dinner until 8 and by that point I was beyond hungry because our party was so big the appetizers were not for a group that size. That being said the portion size of the food was HUGE! Definitely priced right ?. Everyone loved their food. Everyone had leftovers! I'm pretty sure if my friends made reservations EARLIER, possibly we would have had 2 waiters instead of just the one. If you have a big party, make reservations at least a week in advance. We were a party of 15 and they actually forgot one of my friends food and she sat there waiting for 5 minutes until they came over to put cheese on her ziti and she had no Ziti ?. They quickly recovered and got her a huge bowl of food but her meal was pretty simple, it didn't even have meat in it. The party of 15 I think was just too much. The other people dining looked like the service was pretty normal. Just ours too a while.“

“Amazing pizza loved it. I usually give my dog my pizza crust but this was too good to share!“

“Relaxed atmosphere with dog friendly outdoor seating!!!! Fresh ingredients are used and it shows. Great food and service!! What a wonderful find in this quaint town!!!! If you are in this town, this is a must stop!!!!!“

“Maria's pizza the best in town!!“

“Try the eggplant parm wedge! We stopped in to pick up lunch, the owner is so nice and the food is delicious!!“

“This restaurant is obviously chef driven Food is on point. Everything on the menu is good never had a bad meal here. Specials are off the charts. Must try.“

“Katonah's finest pizzeria. Outstanding quality. Pizza's are amazing, salads are excellent and filled with flavor. The owner is on site and a gentleman. Superlative welcoming service. The only pizzeria in Katonah that should be Michelin rated. A taste of Arthur avenue in Katonah. Highly recommend!“

“Best eggplant parmesan you'll ever eat! Delicious pizza, made to order! A fantastic family owned business! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“We just got dinners from Gerard’s for the first time. Definitely will be going back! The food was excellent, large portions and reasonably priced. Very, very good!“

“We grew up in NY. We moved to Lancaster, Pennsylvania. We have never found pizza that we could eat here and enjoy. (I've had pizza at Frank Pepe's in CT- I'm spoiled.) We were visiting family in Mount Kisco and stopped in for a pie to take back home with us. Best decision EVER! Wood fired- crunchy crust that held up to our toppings- sausage and mushrooms. Pizza was tangy, good cheese cover, and the crust just snapped when eaten. You made us very happy and we will come back again when we are in the area. I only wish that I could transport a clone to our area. Thanks for the fine food and the memories. #5!!“

“Wonderful food and staff. Our favorite restaurant by far!!“

“incredible food, incredible staff. my best friend brought me here 9 years ago when I went home to visit. I came back to visit this week, ate here twice and brought rice balls home from vacation. awesome awesome awesome place!!! ♥️“

“I ordered the shrimp scampi and the mixed vegetables. The food was dynamic and the service was impeccable. A hidden gem in katonah. The place was clean. My first time coming to this establishment and I’m glad I did. I will be back. My food was so good I left no crumbs behind lol. Happy eating“

“My family visited from New Mexico for vacation and decided to stop by a pizza place. We happened to locate Sinapi’s and I am glad we did. It’s the best pizza we have ever had. If we are ever in the area again we will definitely be back.“

“Always great food, never disappointed. Delivery is quick and friendly. Everyone who works there is so sweet.“

“Excellent food Competitive prices And, the nicest people!“

“Had the best Chicken Bacon Ranch Roll ever. The dough was perfect, the chicken was tasty and the melted cheese mixed with the ranch just put it over the top. Well done. Can’t wait to come back for another one.“

“SO happy your are here! You were always my fave back in Yonkers and tonight's first pie from your new digs was EXCELLENT! even my grouchy hate everyone's pizza hubby loved it! THANK YOU FOR COMING NORTH! See you soon for that Pesto Bianco!“

“Buono! Best Traditional Italian Cuisine North of NYC!!! Every take-out order from pizzas, appetizers and complete entrees has been consistently delicious! Best Grandma’s Pizza to Eggplant Rollatini ever!!!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“We are so grateful that we stopped by Sal's Pizza and Pasta in Somer's, NY. After enjoying a couple of delicious slices of Nonna's Pizza. we took home a menu, knowing that we would be back in the near future to sample more items from Sal's. If you find yourself anywhere near Somers, NY, definitely stop by Sal's Pizza and Pasta. You will not be disappointed.“

“OMG! Living in Florida for 3 1/2 years eating crappy pizza I was never happier to eat a piece of heaven! Chicken Francesè (or however it’s spelt) was so good. But then we had a piece of chicken with vodka sauce pizza and that was awesome! Just visiting the area for awhile so I know where I’ll be eating while we’re here!“

“loved the Pistachio cake from Luigi’s in Carmel so much that I ordered one for my mother’s 96th birthday. I was in Florida and couldn’t partake but my sister picked it up in Carmel and my mom, sister and family were able to enjoy it. There were 7 people at dinner and due to the size and height of the cake, you can see they barely made a dent (however it was completely gone within 2 days). Everyone was absolutely crazy about it and everyone sent me pictures and called to thank me. It’s a shame to even call it a cake because you naturally think of something you buy in a bakery. This is a whole different world. This cake is exquisite. The flavor is outstanding, it is extremely moist, it has a ton of filling and frosting but not that sickeningly sweet kind – this is all top notch ingredients and completely unique. I felt awful because I know I didn’t give Luigi’s much notice and I know his wife worked 14 hours the previous day baking. But I didn’t feel so guilty that it stopped me from ordering it and they were so gracious about helping me. As you can see in the pictures, the attention to detail, the edible flowers, the beauty of the cake made it a birthday present in and of itself. I just cannot thank Luigi and his awesome wife enough for helping to make my mom’s 96th birthday special.“

“We brought the whole family for my sons 14th birthday and it was perfect. You cannot beat this pizza locally and it’s amazing fresh out of the oven. The rigatoni Ragusa was unbelievable. The kids had their ice cream at the end and it was perfect. The owners hands on service is what I remember from restaurants as a kid. I almost forgot, the music is great. We’ll be back.“

“look at the size of this slice of cake. 🥲 it is beautiful and just as delicious! i needed to try it before diving into the pizza because come on.. cake. i always like what i get from mario’s and was not disappointed with our door dash order. hooray pizza! hooray huge slices of chocolate cake! i feel like bruce from matilda right now.“

“Great friendly staff. Panini was awesome“

“I can not say enough good things about Mike and Joe's! The staff is friendly and efficient, they learn their customers and always greet you warmly! They are quick, often delivering faster than expected and the food is always great! If something is wrong they are happy and quick about making it right and they treat their customers so well and generously! I order delivery often and recently ordered catering last minute! Not only were they on time , the food was DELICIOUS, and they gave a sweet something extra! Mike and Joe's always goes the extra mile they are my favourite pizza place now and always! Thank you guys for absolutely everything and being so hardworking and friendly every single day! You guys are wonderful! I'll forever be a Mike and Joe's regular ! 💞“

“This joint is all about no-frills dining; they even charge extra for napkins and mark up one-dollar Arizona drinks to two bucks. The evening shift operator oozes an arrogant kind of charm, but one thing remains consistently good—the pizza. It's always deliciously greasy, folded up neatly into a paper bag. They don't skimp on quality, using top-notch ingredients and embodying that classic Italian flair blended with New York charm. These two brothers have been making pizza here day and night for close to 50 years. If you grew up in Northern Westchester, you know Napolis pizza, and you know these two legends.“

“Went here 4 days in a row due to my kids saying it was the best pizza they had. I was not surprised due to I believe was the owner took so much pride in serving customers at 1130 in the morning saying "Fresh hot and ready". Definitely will return and will negate any other local shops.“

“Amazing food, staff, and environment!“

“I love Yorktown Pizza and Pasta not just because the food is delicious, but because the family owned business treats you as their own. I recently ordered Stromboli to bring to a party- everyone loved them and there wasn’t a bite left. Their pizza is excellent as well as their catered food. No need to worry when you get your food from them.“

“Delivery order of tomato soup and peppers and egg here we’re outstanding
Delivery person Norberto is a pleasure. Goes above and beyond Always

Wheelchair accessibility: No problem getting in out. They are glad to help if needed“

“The pizza was amazing, crust cooked to perfection and a great team making it all happen. We had a few slices of the Chicken Bacon Ranch, a meat pie, and the pepperoni and cheese rolls. Definitely a must visit for all of the out of towners coming in for the World Ninja League championships(and for everyone else who loves pizza too!)“

“The pizza here is honestly some of the best pizza in the area... Their mushroom pizza is my favorite (they saute them in garlic first! Not just raw shrooms on a pizza). They've made me a pizza roll from scratch with spinach and mushrooms, and today they also made my husband and I fish and shrimp burritos. Every visit has been excellent. My parents love their heros too. Everything is phenomenal! The service is amazing, so friendly and happy to make something off the menu for you. Will be here all the time!“

“They really stepped up at my Nephews Graduation party .
Everything was excellent.

Parking: Free parking at location

Kid-friendliness: Very kud friendly menu

Wheelchair accessibility: They are very wheel chair accessible.
Mother in law is in a chair. It was very easy to get her in and out of the place.“

“FULL DISCLOSURE: Have eaten solely Pizza at this establishment on countless occasions. That being said, the plain cheese pizza is the "ONLY" style that mimicks New York City taste and quality in the Northern Westchester area PERIOD!“

“Just left a crazy Thursday night at IL Forno. What a fun and enjoyable evening we had. We walked in with no reservations and the manager snuck us right in and we even got to the listen to an amazing singer. We have been here a few times, this was by far the most fun we had. Everyone was laughing. The staff which seems to be plenty was having a good time. The manager and Owners kept walking around and making sure all was good and everyone was happy. Thank you for restoring our fun Thursday evening with no COVID fears.“

“I loved my chicken cutlet sandwich. It was made well and yummy!!“

“Let's now discuss the pizza, which is the true star of the show. Tutto Pizza offers a variety of delectable alternatives, all of which are meticulously prepared. Each pizza is a true work of art, from the traditional Margherita, which displays the ideal mix of acidic tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella, and aromatic basil, to their creative gourmet combinations.A special note should be made of their crust, which is the prefect combination of chewy and crispy and provides as the excellent backdrop for the delectable toppings. Whether you like a fluffy, thick crust or one that is thin and crispy, Tutto Pizza has you covered.“

“Great pizza and food. The staff is always friendly and so nice . The grandma is so amazing“

“Hi ordered the chicken monalisa last week! It was so good!! plus I got a salad and pasta for under $ 30.00. I am going to try different entrees from D'Talia !! Bravo... fabulous meal!! '“

“I love the atmosphere here and the food is even better! I am happy with whatever food I try there, have it be their specialty pizzas or any of their gourmet dinners. Everything is great!“

“We had so much fun having Mobile Pie Truck for our daughter’s Sweet 16. Delicious pies and salads. They kept our guests happy all night. Great job guys! Grazie Mille!“

“I like the pizza, and I would probably choose it over most of the pizza in this area cuz it's closest to New York style slice. They consistently undercook the garlic on their garlic knots, so their garlic knots have this unfortunate, intense acidic taste of raw garlic to them“

“Went here for a slice of pizza on Monday November 6th, before heading to a funeral that was nearby. Went with my parents. They had quite a few pizzas and rolls available. I had a slice of BBQ Chicken pizza, my mom had white pizza with a spinach roll, and i forget what my dad had. i enjoyed my pizza, and liked the slice. Was also greeted right away, and everyone seemed very nice. Reasonable price too.“

“We recently held a 40th birthday party at Four Brothers. They were great! John was very helpful during the planning process. On The day of the event the entire staff was helpful and friendly. They were very accommodating of our needs. The food was excellent. We had choices of NY strip, Salmon, and chicken parm. Hearing from all of our guests, all food choices were excellent. We highly recommend this establishment for your next party. It’s also a great spot to go for a meal any day.“

“Mostly order take out/delivery!I LOVE the ladies who answer the phone on Friday evenings they always get my large order (for our recreation program) right!The pizza is delish! …and we’re addicted to the house dressing! Please send recipe ?!!!!“

“Greets you with a smile.
Great service..... awesome food
They make different pizza then others
A must stop by experience

Parking: Easy parking...... just park

Kid-friendliness: Control your kids and it's kid friendly

Wheelchair accessibility: Small wheel chair ramps“

“Always had very good food here and Excellent service …“