50 Best Delis near Mamaroneck

“Biggest and best sandwiches ever You get a lot for your $“

“i come here whenever i am in town and crave it when i am away. the breakfast potatoes are addictive! one of my fave NY delis

Parking: theres a small lot on either side of the pizzeria or deli for run in and out and a couple spots up front

Kid-friendliness: this spot is across from a highschool and down the street from a middleschool - so they cater to teens and is pretty packed with them during the school season/day“

“I started eating there about a week ago and the food is amazing. the service is great and the staff is friendly. great place“

“Cosmos Delicatessen - A Gem in Mamaroneck

252 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

I recently had the pleasure of experiencing Cosmos Delicatessen, and let me tell you—it’s a true gem. My first encounter there was rather unconventional. Four days ago, I found myself sitting in their outdoor seating area, casually indulging in Dunkin' coffee and donuts. Not exactly polite, I know, but the owner was all smiles and didn’t mind at all—a testament to the warm and welcoming vibe of this place.

The very next day, I decided to make amends by diving into their offerings. I grabbed a breakfast sandwich that was absolutely phenomenal—perfectly crafted, flavorful, and satisfying. I also picked up some Italian danishes to bring home for friends in Maryland, which turned out to be a massive hit.

The day after that, Terry swung by to grab some candy gifts for our Crisfield neighbors, and once again, Cosmos delivered. Their selection of Italian treats and gifts is second to none, showcasing everything from authentic deli fare to unique, high-quality goodies you won’t find elsewhere.

Beyond the fantastic food and products, the staff deserves a special mention. They’re friendly, attentive, and make every visit a pleasure. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite, stocking up on treats, or looking for the perfect gift, Cosmos Delicatessen is an absolute must-visit. This place embodies great food, great people, and a true love for their craft. Can’t wait to stop by again!

Mike and Terry Davidson“

“The best, unique bread anywhere in New York. Simply yummy!!!“

“Best deli in Mamaroneck hands down. The sandwiches or sengwiches as I like to call them are phenomenal. The prepared food is freakin delicious. The folks working there know your order before you make it. Super friendly and they make you want to come back many times per week. They’re the best. If you haven’t tried it, try it because you’re missing out.“

“Having sage as my local deli for most of my life, has spoiled me for when I have to go to other places. I love to be able to walk in and no matter what I order it will be an impressive sandwich. And it will be prepared exactly the way I want it with never a mistake or inaccuracy. Everybody that works there is friendly, if you've been in there more than once they will more than likely remember you the next time. Just a fantastic local deli.“

“It's always a great experience going in the the food is terrific 5 stars is an insult they need ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I'm going back tomorrow..

Parking: It's North ave so it's just about being patient to park.“

“First time but not the last. Hope they don’t run out of chicken cutlet next time“

“Deliciosos la variedad de tacos que tienes... !!! me encantaron!!!“

“I was passing through town, I never go to Tuckahoe. My wife and I were starving. We ordered chicken cutlet on a roll. The sandwich was huge and the chicken was flavorful. It's refreshing to still have a deli that sells quality sandwiches at a fair price. I will be making my way back.“

“Gregarious service, great coffee and food and an adorable location“

“Literally stumbled upon this place reading the Greenwich Magazine at work bored, and found this hidden gem. Truly the definition of a hidden gem. The food is delicious, the service is speedy, and the variety of breakfast plates, sandwiches, lunch salads, sandwiches is just above and beyond. Every craving I could possibly have is satisfied here and the price tag is what kept me! In this area, it’s hard finding quality food, with taste all for under $20. At Makerie? You absolutely can. Keep up the amazing work ladies! You gained a new regular! <3“

“Great sandwiches staff very friendly“

“WOW! I have not been in the area for some time but was today and needed coffee and lunch after a sad morning at a friend's funeral. Thought! Oh yea- that good deli in Chester Hts! Well - much to my surprise new owner and better than ever! The MOST delicious caprese sandwich I have EVER had, good coffee and the most delightful fellow taking care of me. I guess it was the wonderful proprietor who could not have been more delightful or welcoming. I wanted to go back in after having half my sandwich to tell him WOW and find out what the balsamic he used was. He also treated me to a chocolate cookie that was yummy - I was so tired I didn't go but made a point of noting the name so I could call and/or write a review! And I see some friends of mine are also in agreement, Nick DiNardo! Molto Bello! YUMMM!!!“

“The owner(scott) is what keeps people coming back. Just today while I waited Scott:

1. Gave back 20 dollars when a kid had overpaid thinking he paid 40 instead of 60.
2. A mom came in and paid for her order because her son had come in earlier that morning and picked up food without any cash.
3. Told two long time customers no charge - the deli accidently made the sandwhiches on rolls instead of heros so no charge. He had to force them to leave without paying.

This was all within 10 minutes. Hope this place stays in business for the next 100 years. The food is great, and they should do an article on him and this place.“

“always friendly. everything delicious and fresh“

“I just bought their Pickled Veggies in a Jaw today and oh man are they good, perfect balance of Flavor and Heat! in one Jar, Carrots, Cucumber, Cocktail Tomato, Celery, Onion (at least, haven't finished it yet)....DEFINATELY Reccomend!“

“Cannot say enough, thank you Mike. It was a sad occasion , a repast for a loved one. The sandwiches (Italian/ American/ eggplant) were delicious. Lots of meat, fresh cheese, fresh bread. Got lots of compliments.. But most of all thank you for the compassion and the genuine concern you’ve shown to me in getting everything ready. God Bless you.“

“Great food 😋 and good service“

“A nice variety of breakfast sandwiches other beverages and coffee. Stores is clean. Food is prepared while.
And staff is friendly.

Parking: Parking lot has space available. Not sure how many cars but, I've never had an Issue with parking.“

“Best deli sandwiches I've tried so far outside of NYC. That being said, there was a bit of a delay with my pickup since I used their actual website and not one of the delivery apps. Sounded like they had forgotten to check it, I imagine the apps get way more traffic. A bit annoying but they quickly made it on the spot and apologized.Anyways, we ordered a pastrami and Italian sandwich. The pastrami sandwich was 4.5/5, a good amount of meat, nice crispy edges, but maybe a hair too salty on some bites. Paired it with some home made spicy mayo and it brought it to 5/5. Definitely getting this again.The Italian was solid and provided loads of meat. We enjoyed it but personally would have liked a tad more oil and vinegar. We gave this a 4/5.Both sandwiches are so packed that they can easily be split up into 2 pieces (maybe even 3 depending on who's eating it). So great option for leftovers.Recommend coming here if you're in the neighborhood looking for a great sub.“

“The set-up, their presentation, their cleanliness, friendliness, and over all experience was beyond my expectations! I’ll definitely be going back on every visit! And next time I’ll be taking pictures! Thank you so much for your kindness!

Vegetarian options: They have something for everyone

Kid-friendliness: I had my daughter and nephew and he offered a lollipop to keep them calm!“

“Muy buena atención comida deliciosa“

“I've lived in Dobbs for a few years and just popped into Ardsley Fresh Market for the first time yesterday and I have been missing out! great little store with good prices and great food. Deli meat was sliced to PERFECTION!! Highly recommend 🤗“

“They deserve more than 5⭐️ Excellent !! Food is exceptional, best I’ve had !! Highly recommend!! Service was great !! Thank you !! ... (Kim)“

“Great mozzarella bread cheese sausages salads. Owners are wonderful cheerful. Neighbors stopover and great coffee smiles abound“

“Amazing, great tasting food....restaurant quality! Ordered catering for our Easter celebration and everything from BelleFair Kitchen was just perfect! Easy to order, great delivery service and again delicious food! Will definitely use again and highly recommend!“

“Excellent food, large portions, friendly staff. Ingredients are fresh, food served fast and hot! Eat in or take out!“

“Buon Amici DelicatessenBuon Amici Deli is a family owned business with over 20 years of experience providing quality product and exceptional customer service to their valued clients.I was introduced to Buon Amici in 2016 through a friend named Peter. The food is always freshly made with high quality ingredients and the food is very delicious. ?830 Scarsdale Ave,Scarsdale, NY 10583Westchester County, New York#googlelocalguidetfisher13? @googlelocalguidetfisher13@buon_amici238?Follow me for more on Instagram at:@googlelocalguidetfisher13“

“Great NY Deli atmosphere with a great kitchen and staff who not only work as a family Unit but you can tell they are a Familia unit who cares about their food and the community who intake it. Making an impact in growing Yonkers through Local Businesses the Odell - Nepperhan corner is building nice in recent years“

“The place is nice! The parking is street parking though. The food is delicious! I had chicken sorrento which was amazingly good. Great servers too! The owner is a great guy, got to meet him.... this was the 2nd time I was there, I recommend Amici's if you enjoy Italian food. It's a restaurant, not a deli.“

“If you are a connoisseur of eating sandwiches, pasta, other excellent dishes, and homemade mozzarella cheese, then this is the #1 deli for you in life, let alone in Greenwich. The Cos Cob Crusher is incredible, I ask for mine with extra cheese, a little balsamic vinegar and toasted. If you have an issue with something you ordered, tell Orlando before you leave so that he can fix the confusion. Orlando is the man and one of the best business owners in the area! I’ve been coming here for almost 25 years.“

“Sal has sold out and gone up North but the workers like Shorty have stayed on with the new owners, prices have gone up, but the grill is still pumping out great hot eats, but stay away from the fries and deep fried stuff as the oil often looks like motor oil, at least walk over to the back and observe the color before you think about the fries, otherwise it's a great place for a hot or cold sandwich and a drink“

“BEC was perfect, and excellent customer service“

“Delicious lunch and even better service! Stopped in for a quick bite to eat and everyone who worked their was so nice. The person who made my sandwich was giving me suggestions of what went well with different things and his suggestions were spot on! He went so far as made me try a spicy croquette and was awesome!!I will be back!“

“Love Joe’s Deli. They make great food and at all times of the day. Their coffee is always a hit and the cookies are baked fresh daily.I love their breakfast platters and their sandwiches are never a disappointment. Can be pricey but worth the price of good food and great service with a smile.“

“Excellent! The Best! I have been ordering from Barino's for years. However, this most recent order was OUTSTANDING! All of the guests absolutely LOVED the Danny Boy sandwich. Days later and I'm still hearing how delicious the Danny Boy was! The chicken parmigiana was the BEST chicken parmigiana I've ever had for a catered event. The chicken was tender and there was a generous amount of sauce and cheese. Plenty of fresh dinner rolls, pickles, salads. I highly recommend choosing Barino's Market for your next event!“

“Delicious heroes made with care. Great service. Nice owners“

“Good morning, everyone. I never used to go there, but my sister and nieces told me how they love how they made their sandwiches. I've been going there every since.

Dietary restrictions: Unsure, but they do have a menu for those who are vegetarian

Kid-friendliness: Yes, I would say a lot of teenagers and parents I would see there“

“Friendly staff! Delicious baked goods and classic Colombian roast coffee. Can’t wait to try lunch!“

“Love this place! The ribeye is phenomenal and decently priced! I also tried their tuna salad and it was delicious, tastes homemade. Their mozzarella and prosciutto is great too. Would absolutely recommend and I’m coming back. So happy I stopped in here!“

“Their Pierogi, Kielbasa and Saurkraut!! They have so much more too!! I come up from Tennessee for these. Been doing it for years. They are Great People!“

“The food is always fresh and hot. There omelets and home fries are delicious as they are full of flavor and you can tell they use fresh ingredients. There french fries are delicious I didn't need any ketchup. The quality of the food is great as well as the portions. I find the staff to be very friendly. This is a terrific place to get delicious food.“

“I have to give this breakfast a 5-star review. I was golfing at Harbor Links and decided to go to the diner, but it was closed at 6:00 am. This deli was a few store fronts away. I had the best Spanish/Western breakfast omelet I have eaten in a very long time. First of all, the omelet was not greasy, the vegetables were fresh, and it was a 3-egg omelet. The side of potatoes were boiled to perfection, lightly seasoned and pan fried. If you live in Port Washington this is the place to go for a terrific egg breakfast plus the coffee was fabulous!!! I will be back to eat here before my tee times!! Kudos to a great kitchen staff !!“

“� Me encantan los tacos que me preparan de nopales asados queso fresco, cilantro cebolla picadita y aguacate �, y las quesadillas de champiñones ��“

“I liked dealing with this store as a result of their good treatment and distinguished service. Speed. Trust good prices. I thank the team at this store. I did not expect that my phone would be returned and repaired in such an excellent manner. They saved me a lot of money and time. I thank you with all my heart. I will always be your customer and I will not look for another place. Keep creating more“

“Clean and friendly environment with awesome food to boot.“