Caterers near Middle Island

Spring Lake Catering Ent. Caterers • $$
30 E Bartlett Rd, Middle Island

“I love this course. The staff is so genuine and real. They treat people with great respect and have patience for the little ones learning about the game. My son’s first 9 holes there and it was special for us and I truly think it was special for the staff as well. I am hoping that my shoulder pain gets manageable soon so I can play 18 holes there. Thank you guys for being so great…“

5 Superb4 Reviews
Mac's Countryside Deli & Catering Deli • $
61 Half Mile Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Egg Whites Avocado Turkey Bacon Whole Wheat w Dash of Hot Sauce
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Cutlet
Honey BBQ
Roast Beef
Chef
Wrap
Hero

“What’s great about this place?So far, everything!!!We have ordered all kinds of food from Mac’s from his signature sandwiches, to wraps and hero’s. Never ever disappointed.Just to give you an example of their commitment to quality food, they make and fry their chicken cutlets on the spot, never microwaved, always tender, fresh and not over bread.Best sandwiches around“

4.3 Superb35 Reviews
The State Room Gastropubs • $$$
67 W Main St, Patchogue - 8.98 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cocktail Hour
Beef Tartare
Gulf Shrimp
Veg Pasta
Bolognese
Dessert
Risotto

“5/5! I cannot recommend the state room ENOUGH! I just had my daughter's baptism lunch this past weekend and the food, ambiance, service, environment were all 10/10! Julian was an amazing hostess who catered all of our needs from beginning to end, even offering custom napkin colors, helping us run stuff from car to venue, providing easels... she made the event absolutely seamless. I cannot wait to host a party here again. All of our friends and family were also raving about the food and how lovely the day was! We cannot thank you enough State Room!!!“

4.8 Superb81 Reviews
Bellport Country Club - Weddings & Special Events Caterers • $$
40 S Country Rd, Bellport - 8.96 miles

“Attended a great wedding there. All around excellent food and service.“

4.9 Superb30 Reviews
The Meadow Club Caterers • $$
1147 NY-112, Port Jefferson Station - 5.77 miles

“I don’t know where to begin… I worked with Zoli to plan for son’s christening and from the beginning everything seemed so perfect. They have an amazing package that was going to make this christening amazing. Well the day came and it was more than I could have asked for. The food, drinks, music etc was just so perfect and the Matra’d couldn’t have been more accommodating! I would have any type of party here again!!! Thank you for making my son’s special day amazing!!!“

4.6 Superb52 Reviews
Old Dock Grill Caterers • $
52 Old Dock Rd, Yaphank - 4.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Custom Egg Sandwiches
French Fries

“Every time I come here I wish I lived closer! I come here occasionally for lunch when I visit customers in this area and it’s one of the best delis I’ve ever been to. There is a big menu with a lot of great choices and creative sandwiches and the food has been excellent every time I’ve come here!On top of that, this place is like the Cheers of delis. There must be a lot of local businesses and the “regulars” come in and the deli workers all know them by name and know their orders and it has a real nice family and friendly feel to it. Today I forgot to ask for my sandwich to be hot so I asked the guy behind the counter to microwave it and he instead took it to the grill in the back because he didn’t want to ruin a good sandwich by microwaving it. The service and people here are awesome! It really makes me wish I could come here more, but I totally enjoy it when I do!!“

4.6 Superb38 Reviews
Chubs Meats Caterers • $$
2598 NY-112, Medford - 5.37 miles

“Bought the Italian stuffed pork chops last night.. I should’ve taken a picture but trust me they were huge. They were amazing in the oven for about an hour they were tender delicious with some grilled veggies. These guys just get it Super quality worth every penny Bravo thank you guys“

4.4 Superb39 Reviews
Bella Maria Pizza • $
1844 NY-112, Coram - 3.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crabmeat Stuffed Mushrooms
Linguine with Clam Sauce
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Chicken Sorrentino
Chicken Marsala
Grandma Pizza
Caesar Salad
Garlic Knots
Greek Salad
Cheesecake

“The food is delicious. It quckly became my go-to for a freshly made meal.Dietary restrictions: They always accommodate my diet needs. The foods I usually order aren't listed but delicious. I've dined in, got deliveries, as well as take out. You will not be disappointed.“

4.3 Superb56 Reviews
Up in Smoke BBQ Inc. Caterers •
415 N Country Rd, St James - 5.22 miles

“Definitely 5-star service. I hired Up in Smoke for a family reunion in my back yard. All my pre-event dealings were with Jeff. He was so easy to work with. Willing to accommodate anything I requested. And since this was my first time using them I had tons of questions along the way. Jeff always got back to me immediately!! The menu had more than enough options to choose from and he even added chicken nuggets and fries since we had a ton of little kids. Worked with me on the pricing. Very fair. We had Alex and Bryan as our grilled and they worked no-stop for the entire time. Cleanup left not a trace. And I had tons of leftovers so plenty of food. Everyone was raving about the food! I highly recommend and would use them again in a heartbeat!! (Jeff also recommended wait staff who are not affiliated with them but have worked together often and they were great, too!) First time I’ve hosted a party where I was totally relaxed and got to visit with all the guests and enjoy myself.“

4.6 Superb18 Reviews
Tanglewood Catering Caterers •
917 Lincoln Ave Ste 1-16 Suite 1, Holbrook - 10.56 miles

“This weekend, Nick and his crew catered my sons graduation party. The food was beyond expectations. Nick kept us in the loop at each step! His crew was polite and worked hard. I will use them for every future party. Thank you for making this day beyond perfect!“

5 Superb9 Reviews
Long Island Luau Caterers • $$
33 Ridge Haven Dr, Ridge - 3.52 miles

“I highly recommend them.“

5 Superb8 Reviews
Majestic Gardens Caterers • $$$
420 Rte 25A, Rocky Point - 4.26 miles

“From the beginning to the end of planning our wedding Demetrios and Olympia were so kind and always answered my questions right away. The atmosphere is breathtaking, staff amazing and food incredible! Our guests had nothing but kind words to say about the whole evening. Our wedding day went so smoothly and they took care of absolutely everything, literally nothing went wrong! I would recommend this place to anyone for any kind of event.“

4.3 Superb30 Reviews
The Bread Palace Bakery & Cafe Caterers • $
750 Horseblock Road, Farmingville - 5.92 miles

“We decided to grab a quick breakfast. They have a full service menu and everything was delicious.Not pictured below or the crepe and The Omelette that we ordered because I forgot to take pictures and a few cool pictures from around the place to eatWe ordered the veggie omelette, and my daughter ordered it without the spinach. The eggs were cooked perfectly and we hopped for more onions but it was still great.My son ordered a Nutella crepe. Out of all the crepe places we've gone to he said this one wasn't his favorite.Vikki ordered a "bebe"it's a Portuguese role with ham and cheese on it. They butter the roles and it was really good.We ordered "galão" . It's a Portuguese latte for a American pallet. It was so good.... And wasn't bitter at all.“

4.1 Good41 Reviews
Broadway Market American • $$
643 Broadway, Rocky Point - 4.7 miles

“I hosted my 30th birthday party there for about 50 people and they were simply amazing!Not only did they help us pull off a surprise baby announcement and gender reveal, they helped my now fiancé pull off the biggest surprise of all a proposal in their beautiful outdoor area!The prices per person were the best around for what was included. The food was great. They created a beautiful cake and the staff was outstanding I cannot rave enough about them or this night. They truly went above and beyond.If you’re looking for a place to have your next party look no further.“

4.1 Good32 Reviews
Cow Palace II Caterers • $$
457 Rte 25A, Rocky Point - 4.37 miles

“I moved out to Shirley 8 years ago and am thrilled I found Cow Palace, they never disappoint! Their prices are reasonable, the products are fresh and high quality. I've been ordering their Holiday packages for the last few years, they include everything from appetizer to desert, very reasonably priced. Give them a try you'll be please!!“

4 Good40 Reviews
Villa Lombardi's Caterers • $$
877 Main St, Holbrook - 8.61 miles

“Photographing weddings at Villa Lombardi's is a dream! The warm, family atmosphere combined with delicious Italian cuisine creates the perfect setting for capturing unforgettable moments. Highly recommended for couples seeking a cozy yet elegant venue.“

3.8 Good58 Reviews