50 Best Coffee Shops near Middle Island

“Good, reliable food! Speedy drive-thru.“

“the coffee was delicious“

“Came Valentines Day 2026. Got a Red Velvet Cake Iced Latte. it was the "Flavor of the Month"“

“Tend Coffee is The Best you really taste the difference. They have a Great Product that you can Trust in the Quality of the Ingredients.“

“Decided to take a stroll through my old home town today & discovered Brewport. I’ve been sick of the big chain coffee places and I was very glad I found this place. The coffee was delicious and the owner & staff were so friendly. A bonus was that they serve a really good vegan/gluten free banana bread!! I live locally and will be back!“

“Very relaxing cozy tea room, delicious deserts and finger sandwiches, many teas to choose“

“We absolutely love everything about coho! Rob, the owner, makes you feel at home. He has created a warm , fun, and relaxed atmosphere. I wouldn’t go anywhere else.“

“Great gifts treats beauty products clothing jewelry more. Love this store!!“

“Wonderful people/wonderful coffee!“

“Decided to take a stroll through my old home town today & discovered Brewport. I’ve been sick of the big chain coffee places and I was very glad I found this place. The coffee was delicious and the owner & staff were so friendly. A bonus was that they serve a really good vegan/gluten free banana bread!! I live locally and will be back!“

“The best Starbucks on the island of course! :p“

“Love going here and Roger is just the nicest guy!“

“Best tea you will ever try 😋 and the most amazing staff“

“This lovely group of humans literally hung on to my order and offered to remake my drink when I wasn't gong to be able to make my pick up on time. They're always so friendly and genuinely kind. Seriously all the love to the Wading River Starbucks crew.“

“Cool vibe good food great music!“

“Perfect private party room for your event!“

“The Terryville Fire Department and it’s employees want to thank the Setauket Starbucks for the generous gift of coffee and pastries. God bless your staff & God bless America. 🇺🇸☕️“

“Amazing fast service! Ramses made my drink and was super friendly! :)“

“Great people, service, and prices. I get my CO2 tank filled here for my brewing and I couldn't be happier.“

“solid stuff. best breakfast going“

“We love Brekkys. The best Acai Bowls! The Super Goat Toast is so yummy. Love getting a delicious Ronnie too! Owner Marty is super nice with a great staff. Place is also super cute.“

“I've been to Toast, Port Jefferson Ststion, 3 x already and each time am so glad to bring friends to enjoy their first Toast dining experience. Everyone I've brought raved about the food & service and are looking forward to returning.“

“cute wee diner..friendly staff“

“It's nice to see other variety versus Duncan in the area. I'm glad TM is making a move and in the United States I have a high quality product. Prices are a little bit higher than would be expected but the donuts are definitely larger flavors are basic.“

“I stopped by for a quick treat and ended up loving the crepe I ordered. It was perfectly thin and soft, with just the right balance of sweetness. The filling tasted fresh and the toppings weren’t overdone — every bite was warm, light, and really satisfying.“

“Went here for the first time tonight. This place is unassuming. You might think to pass it by. But the food is excellent, Margaritas are wonderful! The staff is amazing and so caring! It has a long history in the community and has a huge following. If you know you know. Don't be scared - check it out. We did and we are happy 😁“

“this D&D is the best the girls know me by what I buy took care of me for 5 years while I babtsat my grandkids“

“good coffee and plus they let my friend bring her parakeet in a cage come in“

“Always a pleasure. What happened to putting name on cups?“

“I used to go there every day. That was until they stopped making pineapple mango smoothies. I contacted DD numerous times about continuing making them but didn’t get anywhere No answer“

“Accidentally posted this on the OTHER Selden Starbucks. Sorry.
--------
Morning drive through, sometimes slow, but hey, lots of people in line.

Shout out to Lance who is there almost every day and always remembers my coffee order (I don't use the app) so I don't even have to say it anymore. Thanks Lance!“

“Love Yaroa, hate driving to the city. The best Yaroa wasn’t in the city though, it’s a 15 min drive from me at bueno deli 2 🩷 just like they make them in the DR :)
Also noticed they carry a lot of Dominican products I can’t find at other stores! So glad to have found this place while door dashing“

“Love Dunkin Donuts Iced Caramel Latte is my favorite. My family love too �“

“While traveling for my son’s baseball tournament in Yaphank, NY my family and friends stumbled upon this gem of a restaurant!! Everything from the food to the staff is incredible!! I highly recommend this place and so did everyone else we went with (we brought 15 people with us). Everyone cleaned their plate and these are not small portions! The food is extremely fresh and there is a great sense of pride in their product. We loved our experience here and we will absolutely return when we come back in August!!“

“Great coffee great service fast in and out no fuss no muss... free Wifi and the atmosphere is great. Thank you guys“

“Such an original menu with authentic Polish, Hungarian, and Ukrainian dishes. The pork ribs served with dumplings were my favorite, so tender and tasty. The staff is very friendly and attentive. The ambience is festive and inviting. We just had a great experience and will sure return for more.“

“Coffee of course. Best in the County!“

“All I can say honestly is that this store is very clean & very nice People can’t wait for the Deli department to open, the Owner is very friendly and so is the help, his other location is amazing just down near the beach before 7-11 and they do breakfast, lunch and have a full line of products, like I stated very clean & very friendly.“

“The establishment itself is nice.
My only issue is the signage from the street.
Had I not been up the street when I opened the app to place an order I’d have no clue this place was here.

Even knowing that it was here, I couldn’t see any signage clearly (coming from the North) until I was less than a 100ft from the entrance.“

“Nice staff coffee excellent. So festive in the shop! Did not eat. Donuts looked fresh and very festive too!“

“I love dunkin and I always want to try new drinks, however having life-threatening allergies always held me back due to people getting annoyed having to do things more carefully to avoid cross contamination. George at the medford dunkin let me read the ingredients on the banana cold foam so i didnt have to worry and even used a sealed fork to stir it so i didnt have to worry about cross contamination with almond milk with the general stirring spoon! He did all of this with a smile and I was able to enjoy this delicious drink without worry! It’s so rare to find people so accommodating and willing to go the extra mile for someone with allergies but I am so glad he did and I will definitely be back! I’m so glad my allergies were met with such a positive and understanding reaction to what some would call a burden of an order! It may not seem like a big deal to most people, but as a teen its so hard to be taken seriously sometimes or treated with respect and kindness over rude and disrespectfulness so i am so glad it was George who took and made my order!“

“One word: Delicious! It’s so hard to find good local places that offer yummy healthy options and they hit the mark!“

“This Dunkin’ is very efficient! I visited on a Saturday afternoon and it was super quick and smooth drive thru order. I got a strawberry donut, an avocado toast and a small chocolate shake. Everything was great and it was quick! The parking lot is def another issue as the shopping strip itself is awkward but I had a great experience.“

“I had a great experience at this Starbucks thanks to a cashier named Tyler. I was taking some time to decide on my order, and he remained incredibly patient and kind the entire time. When my order was accidentally charged to my PayPal account by mistake, Tyler immediately acknowledged the error, voided the transaction, and generously gave me the order free of charge. His customer service not only stood out, it truly reflected the kind of heart he has. It’s rare to come across someone so genuine and attentive. Shoutout to Tyler for going above and beyond! I hope he gets the acknowledgment he deserves, having someone like him on your team is such a reflection to your business and it’s truly appreciated“

“The employees were really sweet and nice. Just wish the actual store was bigger.“

“What a nice place. We come here very often and the employees are always pleasant and helpful, especially Jennifer. They're in a great location at the East Wind Shoppes... go have fun and stop in here. I highly recommend it“

“I am writing this review to combat the rude customers I encounter almost every time I enter this Tim's and gas station. The coffee is wonderful and the staff are SO FRIENDLY! Yes, sometimes there is a small line, but there is no need for customers to be so harsh to the staff. Clean, great coffee and donuts, and kind staff!!!“

“Not the worst Dunkin', but it seems to be understaffed as there was only one employee there when I went. On top of that, they only have agave straws, which were off putting because I thought the specs on them meant that they were dirty.“