48 Best Italian Restaurants near Miller Place

“We have dined at Orto several times and it never disappoints. One of our favorite restaurants on all of Long Island. Food is always fantastic and the service and atmosphere are exceptional. Highly recommend trying this hidden gem.“

“My wife and I went in to give this place a try and were very pleasantly surprised. The service was very good, the restaurant is neat and clean. The FOOD is exceptional. We have been back a few times and we are always trying different meals with the same result… absolutely delicious.“

“The food here is great and the people are amazing. My husband and I had our wedding catered by CP Lamannos and I can’t even begin to tell you about the compliments we received. Michelle and her staff are the best!!! Please don’t take my word for it come down to the restaurant and try it for yourself.“

“I’m glad I stopped in here. I had a regular slice and it was excellent!! So i ordered a chicken parmigiana hero to go. The hero is excellent. My partner got a Sicilian slice and he loved it. The hero and slice of was so good that I really am looking forward to going to dinner or getting some stuff to go again. The owner talked to me and was a really nice man. Place has a great vibe for sure.“

“The BEST pizza in the world!“

“Excellent food and staff was awesome!“

“I can not believe that this restaurant has been here on Main Street in Port Jefferson Village for over 20 years and I never ate there!!! This is my new Favorite place to eat. The food was exceptional and good size portions. The pita bread they put out on the table was so delicious I could have made that my meal. The service was extremely attentive and so personable. The Owner came around greeting everyone and made us feel like we were all family having dinner together. I am looking forward to my next visit.“

“Staff and food were amazing. High recommended“

“My family bought me here for Mother’s Day and it most definitely did not disappoint.“

“My boyfriend & I popped in for a beer today before heading back to the city. We met Jocelyn. Salt of the earth. Very sweet. The place is avert relaxed atmosphere. It was a wonderful experience.

Thank you!
Walter R Fairbanks“

“Delicious food from start to finish. Wonderful service (we had Gina but all others were great as well) and Friday night they had a singer and had the whole restaurant singing together. Comfy intimate spot that I will definitely return to.“

“Love the food. Service and atmosphere.“

“Wow! We were visiting from the city, and our first visit was fantastic! We sat at the bar and ordered the shrimp tagliatelle, which was absolutely delicious, and the margaritas were just as good (wish they were on HH 😌).

A special thank you to the chef for thoughtfully splitting the pasta for my partner and me—it was a nice touch. Taylor and Joe took wonderful care of us and made the experience even better.

We also loved that the restaurant is family-owned and genuinely seems to care about its staff. You can really feel the warm, welcoming atmosphere. We’re looking forward to our next visit.“

“Happened upon this restaurant while visiting Port Jefferson. And glad we did. Got here early enough that we could get a table right away. Steve took great care of us without being overbearing. We started off with the stuffed mushrooms, which were so freaking good. For main course my husband got the Chicken & Sausage Scarpiello, and I had the Veal Scallopini - both were delicious. We finished off sharing the Rainbow Cookie Cheesecake. This exceeded my expectations. Everything was so good that my husband wants to go back tomorrow!“

“My new favorite place in Port Jeff! Food is delicious, staff are great!! I used to manage an Italian restaurant in Manhattan, I tend to scrutinize restaurants, 2 thumbs up for Pasta Pasta, say it again!!! 😋 🍽 🍷“

“I absolutely Love eating at this restaurant. It is always THE BEST whether you are having pizza, soup, or a meal. The Garlic Knots are AMAZING. They are so soft and TASTY!!!“

“Thank for my roast beef and mashed potato and my buffalo blue pizzas 🍕 yesterday, my husband was so happy I bought his two favorites back to Pennsylvania for him! They travel great and always delicious 😋“

“BEST FOODS EVERY!!! YUMMY YUM YUM!!“

“Sole Mio donated an incredible meal to the Ronald McDonald Room at Stony Brook University Hospital while our daughter was there. The meal included a wonderful chicken Parmesan and a pasta with vodka sauce that was especially good. We were very thankful for their kind donation and hope to visit in person in the future.“

“Great place with great staff. I recommend!“

“This was an online delivery. Great job by everyone. Full portions of entre, soup and salad. A lot of to go orders from other places cheap out on portions but this was possibly more than would get in restaurant. They even gave utensils, packets of croutons, grated cheese, salad dressing and even the andes candies treats. I highly endorse 😃😃“

“Pizza and calzones are always burnt, effecting the taste. Even when you ask the staff to cook it lightly, they still burn them. Calzones have way too much mozzarella cheese, and not enough ricotta cheese. Burnt is the norm here. Staff are friendly.“

“Great Italian restaurant in Rocky Point“

“We love their vodka margarita pizza (if you haven’t it’s a must have). So we decided to have them cater our daughter’s birthday dinner. The catering packages were affordable, good selection, plenty of food and delicious. Everyone enjoyed their food and the pizza. They also delivered which was a huge plus. Thanks so much!! Definitely will be ordering again. Shout out to Autumn who was so helpful, easy to place an order with and pleasant.“

“They catered our party and the food was fabulous. Their meatballs are soft and the best we’ve tasted. The trays were filled to the top. The chicken parm, chicken francaise, and pasta dishes were great. Hero was great too. I was a little hesitant hiring them only because I had never used them before. I decided to use them because we had gone there for dinner a few times and loved the meatballs and other dishes (chicken bruschetta for one) and their homemade dipping sauce for their bread. I could be happy with the dipping sauce and bread alone, delicious! We will definitely use them again to cater. They delivered and were right on time.“

“Finally made it to Mozzafiato about two months ago. We have been back many times since. I get a different slice every time. Delicious. By far our favorite pizza place for specialty slices!“

“ive been looking for a good wood fired pizza place for a while and now ive found it , i went there on friday and got a margarita pizza and a calzone , both were super yum and made with fresh ingredients but the calzone was out of this world and i will be coming back with my wife for lunch“

“this has become my new favorite pizza place, and while I probably shouldn't I've eaten here almost every day last week. their slices and pies are always fresh, delicious and inventive. they even make the kid slices cool which is a huge plus.“

“Tonight we had Gino’s Pizza Truck at our school carnival event and they were absolutely a HUGE hit ! Pizza was delicious and families were so happy! The staff were so kind and everyone raved ! Thank you for adding to our carnival event. We will definitely be booking them for future events !“

“i usually order take out , tonight we dined in. I think the waitress was new , I had to ask twice for a water n twice ordered soda only got one the waitress didn't come back , busy chatting with another customer. ate 1/2 my meal without the 2nd soda. waitress didn't remember mi ordered it . my tip reflected her service.“

“I have ordered from Goomba Johnny's many times and have never been nothing more than satisfied. I usually order the 2 pie deal, granny pies are phenomenal. Will be a customer for many more orders! Thank you.“

“Picked up Three pies two hero’s the price is great. we ordered three different types deep dish. Thin. Crust and regular pie with meatballs five stars the meat balls really made the pie.“

“Best Sicilian slice around“

“Their food is delicious...great service in a relaxed casual atmosphere..will definitely be back..❤️“

“Amazing food and service. So cute!“

“The food is always delicious and they never let me down when I have catered they go above and beyond and some of the best chicken franchese I’ve ever had“

“Amazing! The Pupusas, carne asada tacos and the horchata was the best and freshest I’ve had. Will be a frequent flier here!“

“I love the Pastaria! I have been going there for a long long time. It's super cute, they have good service, and its a sweet spot in my heart for their contributions to our community. We love you, Pastaria!“

“romantic awosome amazing atmosphare just looking like a wow“

“I mistakenly placed a catering order with Victor not realizing it was the wrong Luigi’s restaurant in a different state! Victor was kind and told me not to worry and I don’t owe a dime. Thank you!!!“

“I was frantic trying to plan a last minute party … they were amazing with helping us with everything ! I got a trey of chicken franchise a salad and the meatball sliders and it was absolutely amazing ! The portions were great the taste was great and the price was great ! Highly recommend them to “

“18+ Years of Ordering Several Delicious Pizzas , Pastas and Heros — Staff is Always Amazing , Atmosphere is Comforting and Food Top Shelf — They also Welcome in Our Special Needs Children for Work Related Growth Learning in Their Own Neighborhood !!!!!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Café Amici in Selden is a gem! From the warm greeting at the door to the attentive staff and fresh bread service, everything feels welcoming. The appetizers were delicious, but the highlight was the Trojan entrée — huge portions, amazing flavor, and beautifully presented. If you still have room, the desserts are worth it too. Prices are great for the quality, and meeting Joe, the owner, made the experience even more special. Highly recommend!“

“Enjoyed a wonderful Italian dinner, and I have to say it exceeded my expectations from start to finish! #1 Sunday sauce! \n\nI ordered the Eggplant Parmesan, and it was absolutely outstanding — perfectly breaded, layered with just the right amount of sauce and cheese, and baked to perfection. Every bite was full of flavor and felt homemade, just like authentic Italian comfort food should.\n\nThe service was equally impressive. Our server, Mikayla, was attentive, friendly, and incredibly efficient! She had many tables and everyone left with smiles on their faces. She checked on us at the perfect times, and made the entire dining experience feel warm and welcoming.“

“Great food and great staff!!!“

“Last night was our 3rd time ordering from them. 2 times we did pick up and last night due to weather we did delivery! All 3 times we were blown away with the quality of food, taste and customer service we received! Amazing food and taste delicious. Everyone who works there is awesome and this is definitely our go to pizza place for now on! Thank you all“

“Great pizza spot next to the play pace Lil Steps . Super convenient, good pizza and excellent staff . The young girl working this evening (7/16) was very sweet , helpful and accommodating . My son is 3 years old and he loved it too. They cut his pizza perfectly for him. We will be back for sure .“