27 Best Ice Cream Shops near Mohegan Lake

“I came in the other day to buy a last minute birthday cake for my mother. This sweet young lady named Gianna was there and wrote happy birthday mom in the neatest handwriting. She even added cute balloons! the customer service is amazing and the cake was even better!“

“The perfect neighborhood scoop shop! Great variety, and the staff was so kind and great with kids. Portions are generous and the flavors taste fresh and authentic. We’ll be making this our sweet-treat stop next time we come around.“

“It’s an exciting and fun place.“

“How could you NOT recommend The Blue Pig? 10/5 stars“

“Great service and ice cream!“

“My family and I went in and this place is such a gem. I had the dulce de leche paleta and it tasted like the perfect caramel bar, we also ordered cotton candy, coconut and strawberry ice cream. Super nice staff, excellent spot in town. Go get some ice cream or paleta (popsicles!!)“

“You may be thinking that all Carvel locations are alike, but they're not. I have visited many Carvel locations in many states, and this one (fortunately my "home" Carvel store) is the best. The soft ice cream is consistently dense and smooth, never runny, and they have a large selections of hard ice creams and sherbets, all of which are delicious. Portion sizes are generous. The staff is friendly and helpful. Never disappointed with anything from this place.“

“Such a nice local ice cream shop! Loved the variety on the menu and they even had a frozen dog treats. Flavors and quality of the ice cream are great. Today I had a coconut Kit Kat that was excellent but they also had some vegan/nondairy options that looked tasty. The outdoor area is nice to sit at and dog-friendly. Also appreciate that this is woman and LGBTQ+ owned.“

“Wednesday is Sundae. BOGO“

“After bike ride meal. Place is packed with bikers on good weather weekends though many just getting Powerade.“

“Been looking for a frozen yogurt place and this fit the bill. It’s a big clean looking place, plenty of seating. Lots of flavors to choose from. So far I’ve tried the strawberry cheesecake ( so-so) and raspberry pomegranate. Both quite tasty. The selection of toppings is outstanding, although some items like the peanut butter cups and brownies were stale. Fruit was fresh.
Defiantly a place to go back to and try other flavors.“

“Delicious ice cream. Excellent menu choices. There’s no place like King Kone!“

“Friendly staff. Made me the new rainbow cookie shake and it’s a 10/10.“

“Lots of flavors to try, good ice cream and games to occupy the children. Nice quiet Main Street to sit outside.“

“I literally can't recommend this place enough! we stayed in cold spring for 4 nights and got food here everyday haha! we tried pretty much everything and EVERYTHING was delicious! freshly cooked, with love! the staff are super friendly and welcoming too. absolutely 5 stars!“

“I went to that place I loved the service and the food was very delicious I recommend it“

“Love the milk shakes here. Just a quality fun place that makes you smile. Enjoy.“

“Excellent ice cream and italian ice. This place has the added benefit of making any ice cream flavor you want into a milk shake. I chose mint chocolate, and the milk shake was outstanding, one of the best I've had. Tons of chocolate chips were left at the bottom of my shake, which were delicious as well. The teen worker behind the counter was very sweet and working hard seemingly by herself. We would definitely come back here again. NOTE: this place is cash only.“

“The unicorn ice is amazing!“

“No better place to reward yourself after a vigorous bike ride on the North County Trail way. Where else can one get Cooke Monster flavored ice cream and the best smoothies in Westchester County? A super friendly staff adds to the fun.“

“Our favorite Carvel by far! The staff is wonderful, always helpful, patient and very accommodating to special requests! The service is great! The store is very clean and they serve quality ice cream and beautifully decorated cakes (they can make pretty much make any design/style you want). Another plus- convenient hours and location. The best ice cream shop around!“

“This is absolutely the best Carvel. Dana & Sal are awesome proprietors.“

“Pictures don’t do justice to how well made these waffles are.
They taste as good as my favorite waffle spot in Brussels 🇧🇪
The smiles behind the waffle maker were just as good as a toppings! I do recommend for your next private or corporate event!“

“Was impressed with the quality of danishes, been here a couple weeks in a row, and they seem to be on top of things, so far its been very consistent.“

“Burger were great, the staff was courteous 👍“

“The ice cream is good but the manager was rude. I went in with 5 people and I was paying on my own and when they ask whose next it was my turn . When I got to the counter she stated I was with the other woman. I explained I am paying my own so I would be next. She said I had to wait til they were done as I was part of that group . So needless to say by the time I received my order I had to take it to go as my friends were done with their ice cream . The young woman who helped me was very nice but the manager/owner needs lessons in customer service.“

“I had the best experience ordering my cake from here. Everything was smooth and staff was very responsive and helpful with all my questions.I’m extremely happy with the quality, service, and punctuality. I will definitely be ordering again.“