Gigi's Montauk
$$$$ • SeafoodAbout Gigi's Montauk
Gigi's Montauk Reviews
61 ratings
Share your opinion about Gigi's Montauk
Charred octopus was the best we've had over 20 years. Pepper tuna & halibut were perfect. Dining al fresco, the sound of the surf & lights of distant ships for a view? Terrific.
First time dining at Gurneys. Special occasion. My birthday. 66! My 35 year old son took me. We expected the greatest experience at GiGi's. Nope! Waiter Sammy and Staff so not friendly. I had to ask his name. No small talk or smiles. Food was delicious. Had to keep asking for water. But a terrible experience. Sadly.
The best in the State!
Hours
| Monday | 7AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 7AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 7AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 7AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 7AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 7AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 7AM - 9PM |
Gigi’s Montauk at Gurney’s offers a wonderful dining experience with a relaxed and beautiful outdoor setting, perfect for enjoying Montauk’s summer atmosphere. The restaurant is known for its exceptional seafood and delicious dishes, such as the charred octopus, pepper tuna, halibut, lobster pasta with uni butter, and the beet salad with goat cheese. The fried rice is a standout side that many find memorable. Desserts like strawberry cheesecake provide a sweet finish, complemented by refreshing drinks including Montauk Summer Ale and well-crafted cocktails.
Service at Gigi’s varies; some guests have praised the attentive and caring staff, highlighting a level of hospitality that makes the experience special. One reviewer noted exemplary service, quick resolution of issues, and a genuine sense of being looked after. Conversely, others felt service was less friendly or lacked small talk, though the quality of food remained high. Staff members have been recognized for their professionalism and hospitality, making diners feel comfortable, even with young children in tow.
The views add to the appeal, with the sound of the surf and distant ships creating a terrific backdrop for al fresco dining. Many guests describe the experience as memorable, thanks to the combination of fresh, high-quality ingredients, beautiful scenery, and attentive service that elevates the meal into a special occasion. Overall, Gigi’s Montauk is highly recommended for those seeking good food, great views, and a relaxed yet refined atmosphere. It’s a spot that consistently leaves visitors eager to return.