8 Best Pizza Restaurants near Narrowsburg

“Excellent cocktails, food and service. We dined indoors, so I can’t speak to the patio, but the ambiance and vibe were great on the inside. If you’re in a group, I recommend sharing different pizzas because they’re all so uniquely delicious.“

“This is good pizza especially for the area. Thin but not too thin, crispy underneath, nice flavor in the sauce and cheese. I was pleasantly surprised. I would have no complaints if i was served this back in North Jersey. A few people commented on the guys attitude. He wasnt rude but at the same time im not there to make friends. Keep making me the same good pie and ill keep paying for it.“

“My first time at Baker's and it definitely won't be my last. The food was absolutely delicious! Service was outstanding and we received our appetizers quickly and they were hot and scrumptious as were our main courses. Love it!“

“My Mom and I ate here last night. The food was amazing had a Reuben Rider which is turkey, swiss cheese and pickled red cabbage on toasted rye had a side of thousand Island dressing. Really enjoyed it it was something different. Mom had a grilled hamburger and mashed potatoes. Great food great choices I recommend everybody try it. Will be going back.Vegetarian options: There are many options but they will work with you Just ask for an option of food your looking for.Parking: Lot's of parking either side of the buildingKid-friendliness: Good food optionsWheelchair accessibility: There is a big beautiful ramp in the back. An a very nice ramp in the front. Easy access.“

“Traveling through this area with family and was lucky to find this restaurant. The place was packed but all the workers hustled and were on top of everything AND friendly. My baked ziti was perfect...my sister insists it was "the best gluten free pizza" she ever had. 10 out of 10 for Il Castello!“

“Love this place. Great people work here and you are sure to find something you'll like. I got 2 innertubes to go down the deleware river for very cheap and they still are in great condition. It's a convenience store gas station and the only one around for atleast 20 min.“

“The food tasted pretty good. My only complaint is how expensive it was for a “large” Stromboli. $30 for it and it’s not very big at all. I remember getting Stromboli from Peppinos in callicoon and how it was a giant “U” shape so I was expecting something a little similar. It wasn’t enough to feed our family (2 adults and 3 toddlers)“

“Best pizza around. When my family comes up from Florida, they Make a special trip to pick up a few pizzas. My personal favorite is the Bacon Pizza.Service is wonderful. You may have a long wait, especially if you don't order ahead...which is fine, because that is a testament to the delicious food!And, what could be better than a pizza place? I love the new location, and especially enjoy the outward appearance of a cabin! They do have a nice dining area, but we've always done takeout. This is a family owned business, and they are just really great people.“