16 Best American Restaurants near New Baltimore

“First time here and I would def come back again. Service initially was a little slow getting our drink order, but improved throughout our visit, perhaps short staffed. However, overall an excellent place to come to. The atmosphere and food were excellent.“

“Indescribable. All I can say is best meal ever. Everyone should get a chance, just hope another Chef steps up and follows in Damon’s path and continues the legacy of food that he has been able to put out. Would hate to see this experience, talent & knowledge be lost.“

“The Food is Always Spot On and the Service is Superb. Sauteed Scallops are Off The Chain. Best in the County“

“I have never had food I didn't love. The soups are amazing, all of them. It is a favorite for the locals but after going there just a couple of times they remember my preferences. Staff is great, friendly, efficient, top notch. The crowd is friendly and lively.“

“My family has had some of our best nights here. Zachary, my son absolutely loves Jeffrey that’s here! I haven’t met a single person that wouldn’t go out of their way to accommodate. This by far is one of our favorite home town go to places!! Try em out you won’t be disappointed 🤟🏻🫶“

“Welcomed our soaked and sorry asses in with open arms. Treated us like we were family. Could not have completed our cycling trip without you! Stephanie & Bill, thank you soo much for your hospitality - much appreciated! Excellent food and service. Such a cool spot with 110 years of history. Highly recommend stopping in!“

“My favorite is the Chicken Parm...more than I can finish in one serving. I also love their Black and Blue Salad... with their Blue cheese dressing! I've never been disappointed with the food at Main Street! Hope you stop in for a very reasonable priced meal. Enjoy! 💕🌹🌻🥗🍝♥️“

“I always enjoy my food when I order from here! Always a great experience with Maria and Nikki! Always so nice and accommodating, I served tables for 10 + years at a lot of high end restaurants and they are an awesome example of how service should be, However everytime I order something on Sunday evenings the blonde girl and the brunette girl that work there both have terrible attitudes like they both absolutely hate their jobs, I never see either one of them smile , or take any kind of personal approach to their customers at all, which in my opinion as a someone who worked as a server for so long might result in less tips or even a negative vibe between the server and their table… last night I ordered 2 orders of French fries and asked for some plastic silver wear , the brunette girl looked at me and said! “I guess but I don’t really see why” … maybe because I’m a regular paying customer .. but maybe that’s just me… and another time I placed an order with one of the girls , and asked for my total, and had me wait on the phone for over 5 mins for my total while she stopped and ran her food… something that takes 30 secs took 5 mins…in my personal opinion as a server those two ladies show a big lack of professionalism, I do not recommend Sunday nights when these two girls work! But I absolutely love this place when it’s any other day of the week“

“Our first time in and we are so happy we chose to stop! The pork chop dinner was fantastic!! Our waitress, Breadan, was awesome! She made our experience perfect! We wouldn't change anything about our visit ❤️ -Richard and Jeannie (see, I have to spell my name for everyone too 🙃)“

“Great bagels, super fresh pastries and excellent coffee. This is our go-to breakfast treat.“

“I had an absolutely fantastic reasonably priced lunch today. Way more than I could eat., Burger was cooked perfect, toppings were fresh and delicious. The service was friendly, fast and efficient ! So glad we decided to look around before we ate.“

“I went for my birthday lunch. Everything was delicious! Best CALAMARI and our waiter Josh was the best! we all enjoyed our meals...so good!“

“Love this place! I enjoy DJ here.“

“Went here for dinner before show at MacHaydn Theatre. Waitress Nicole was very friendly and attentive. Got a senior special which comes with soup and dessert. I had pot roast with fries. Very tasty soup. Roast beef was a little well done for my taste but it was flavorful. For dessert I had the bread pudding again a little overcooked but was tasty. Would definitely go back. $25 with the tip.“

“Love their Food .. love the atmosphere. Max the people there“

“I was delivering in the area and ordered some food here. I was a little hesitant because of the rating, usually a restaurant in a small town gets great ratings for good food or slammed for bad food. I tried a slice of pizza, wings and fries. The delivery was very fast, driver very kind (he called to say he arrived instead of beating on my truck).

I must say that everything I had was top quality, still hot and priced well. Again I thought for a pizza restaurant they deserved 5 stars!“