Citarella

Bakery

Hours:
2135 Broadway, New York
(212) 874-0383

Citarella Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
3.4 (31)
Restaurantji Rating

This is the original and oldest Citarella, est. 1912. When this store went up, the street it was built on still had cobblestones. So that’s pretty extraordinary. For surviving so long and bringing a piece of New York’s past into the present, for that alone it merits 4 stars. Fairway next door is also the original and oldest Fairway, est. 1933.Citarella loses 1 star for its exorbitant pricing. Although it isn’t uniformly overpriced. On certain products it can be entirely...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

This place is one of my favorite grocery stores! ? Citarella on the UWS ? has everything you need - fruit ?, vegetables ?, fresh meat ?, cheese ?, canned goods ?, cakes ?, drinks ?, snacks ?, salads ?, and so much more! Staff ?‍? is super friendly and professional and service is quick! ⏲️ It's so fun walking ? around and exploring ? the fully stacked shelves. I wish I came here more often!

Restaurantji Rating

A wonderfully run store especially on hectic shopping days like Thanksgiving! Special shout out to Frank who was extremely friendly and helpful today. Thankful to have Citarella in the neighborhood!

More Reviews(64)

Ratings

Hours

Monday 8AM - 8PM
Tuesday 8AM - 8PM
Wednesday 8AM - 8PM
Thursday 8AM - 8PM
Friday 8AM - 8PM
Saturday 8AM - 8PM
Sunday 8AM - 8PM
Updated on: