Potbelly

$ • Sandwich Shops, Fast Food, Salad

Hours:
46 W 56th St, New York
(646) 289-4210

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites

Potbelly Sandwich Shop Reviews

3 (34)
We ordered via Uber Eats so can't comment on management cause it arrived in reasonable time. The food, however, was gross. There was something seriously wrong with the chicken pot pie soup- my boyfriend literally spat it out and was worried that he swallowed some lol. My sandwich tasted okay, but 3 bites in my lips started stinging, which has never happened before???? I stopped eating and rinsed them with water and it went away....it was just a turkey sandwich lmfao so not spicy...read full review
"Them belly full but we're hungry"(Bob Marley)If you're hungry and want to fill your belly at a reasonable price, you best scoot over to Potbelly Sandwich Shop.They have 28 different sandwiches, plus soups, sides and salads. The sandwiches are ordered "Subway" style, where you slide down the ordering line to add extras, and the hot sandwiches go through a conveyor belt broiler thingy to toast them up Quizno's style.I went with an Italian (Salami, capicola, pepperoni, mortadella,...read full review

The food overall is great and the service is improving. I wasn't impressed with the service in the past but continued to come because it was close to my work and I enjoyed the food regardless but the staff is getting much better. I don't know everyones names but Crystal and the two young gentleman who look to be in their 20s are great.

More Reviews(141)

Ratings

View all photos

Hours

Monday 10AM - 8PM
Tuesday 10AM - 8PM
Wednesday 10AM - 8PM
Thursday 10AM - 8PM
Friday 10AM - 8PM
Saturday 10AM - 7PM
Sunday 10AM - 7PM
Updated on: