Sicily Osteria

$$ • Italian, Pizza

Menu Order Online Reserve

About Sicily Osteria

Sicily Osteria is a cozy and charming restaurant that offers a pleasant atmosphere for its guests. The bright and beautiful space is located away from the busy theatre district, with lovely outdoor seating. The food has been praised as outstanding overall, with highlights including the sausage pasta, cacao e Pepe, and tortelloni pomodoro. Customers also enjoy the croquettes, vegetarian meatballs, and fettuccini al funghi. The service is excellent, attentive, and very friendly, with waitstaff going above and beyond. This restaurant is a good choice for those wanting authentic Italian dishes and homemade pasta in mid-town Manhattan. Customers describe the restaurant as feeling like dining in a rustic Sicilian home, with lots of brick and a lively atmosphere. The menu offers a good amount of choices, and the food is consistently praised as fantastic and true authentic Italian, with dishes like lasagna, pasta with mushrooms and truffle sauce, pasta Norma, and chicken Parmesan receiving high marks.