6 Best Italian Restaurants near Newfane

“Pizza is phenomenal! Went outside my comfort zone tonight and tried the baked haddock...it was microwaved fish, rubbery, and hard. It was stuck on the plate and so hot it needed to sit 10+ minutes before it was edible. I think they ultimately never made my order as my husband got a pizza and they brought his out at least 10 minutes before mine. 😳 You're safe if you stick with Pizza! 🍕“

“Party of three and two of the three enjoyed their meals. the lasagna noodles were piled on top of each other 5 thickness with nothing in between. never again will I order.“

“Went in tonight to get a family deal. The staff hand downs did another amazing job. whoever answered the phone and was on counter staff today was 10/10 AMAZING!!!! I am very picky but NEVER do I ever have a problem when going here or ordering! Scott Brown and the staff are amazing!!! Even when scott is not there the staff is super!! They were all working super hard tonight and it is always such a positive time, never rude, orders are never wrong and the food is ALWAYS cooked and packaged the way we ask!!! Scott Brown we just wanted to pass that along to just reinsure you that you my friend are doing an“

“Spring Lake Winery was such an AMAZING experience!! I planned our wedding from Michigan and they were with me every step of the way. I cannot express how positive my experience was and how amazingly helpful the staff has been the entire time! They are literally the most responsive business I have ever worked with -- from emails to phone calls to answering every little tiny question I had, they were always so willing to help and offer input and make our wedding absolutely perfect. On our wedding day we had the NICEST catering staff and literally the most amazing bartenders. My husband and I are absolutely thrilled with our experience, and even though I'm all the way in Michigan, I have recommended them nonstop and had so many good things to say! I appreciate Spring Lake SO much for helping to make our day perfect!“

“we eat there on occasion, never a bad meal. We went last night for Valentine's day, we both had the eggplant Parm and it was wonderful. Always great service“

“This place is hidden in the little plaza. There was not enough signage, so I passed it more than once without notice. I ordered personal pan pizzas for the first time, and they were very good. Perfect for my family because everyone likes different toppings. So everyone got their own toppings. This was great. They offer the personal pan pizza $2 on Tuesday. Great way to taste the product.
I was surprised how good it was. It was filling too.“