9 Best American Restaurants near Pawling

“Amazing evening went to see the Soul Cruisers r&b oldies. There 12 piece band with numerous singers were fantastic. I danced all night long!
The drinks were strong & reasonable priced we had a great time! Will catch their show in Del Ray FL.“

“Great food, nice people and lovely atmosphere.“

“Favorite place to go on the weekend with my friends. The food is great and the staff is always awesome. Henry runs a great spot.“

“A wonderful, cozy restaurant with a nice menu of choices. The staff was welcoming, the atmosphere is warm & inviting, and the food was excellent.

The crab cake app was well prepared, lots of flavor, well balanced, and the salads were fresh with crisp vegetables.

The stuffed trout & fish n' chips were great; delicate, flaky fish and the seasonal vegetables that came with em were garden fresh and full of flavor as well.

The desserts we ordered were the chocolate mousse cake & the bread pudding. Cake was rich and chocolatey; a bit more mousse than cake, but that was great by me. And the bread pudding was perfect in texture, flavor, and size for price.

Great experience start to finish, our server Colleen was amazing, and thank you for a wonderful meal.“

“Although I'm giving it five stars, this is really a message of this disappointment and anger!

I won't ruin star status because of a situation, so for that I'm still going to get five stars throughout, but I called 10 times in a matter of 30 minutes. 16 of those minutes I was put on hold. So somebody answer the phone and then put me on hold for 16 minutes and nobody answered the phone back.

I'm only putting this out there because if this was anybody else they would have given them 1, 2, or 3 stars. It's one thing not to answer it's another thing to have me on hold for 16 minutes.

Other than that, the atmosphere inside is great, the food is great, and the service is great. Great food, but just really hurt on being put on hold for 16 minutes and nobody thought about coming back. I'm sure it's an accident, but just saying“

“Absolutely wonderful experience at our first time at Rebellion tonight! From the vibe and atmosphere, to the most amazing drinks by Dorian at the bar and the incredible, elevated food (Bronzino & NY Strip to be specific) and just an absolute amazing experience overall. A must visit! 5 🌟 all the way!!“

“the best of the best! the food is consistently incredible. the service is always top notch, and the atmosphere is second to none. the perfect place to go for either a quick lunch, a really nice dinner or to go see live music and kickback with a few cocktails....look no further!“

“Moved to the area in July '25. I stop in at least once a week if not more since. Everything from breakfast to dinner and dessert. Everything has been great! Food, drink and staff are all great.“

“The food is AMAZING. Better than what you’d expect for bar food. The in house ranch is worth a mention by itself. It’s so good you’ll put it on everything. The fries are bomb. Wings great. Kids loved their tenders. Will be coming back again when in the area. We didn’t dine in. Took the food to go.“