22 Best American Restaurants near New Milford

“Always great food and friendly people! Micayla is great!“

“The diner is nice. The food is above average. Not the best diner, food ever had, but not the worst either. The week staff was very helpful and friendly. Overall, a positive experience. Take a look at that lox and bagel sandwich! It was amazing!“

“Johana's Restaurant: The saying is keep it simple, stupid. Well, Johana's does it amazingly well. Their menu is straightforward and uncomplicated, focusing on classic dishes made with high-quality ingredients. From their perfectly seasoned food to their cheese steak, every dish at Johana's Restaurant is executed with precision and care. The result is a dining experience that is consistently delicious and satisfying.“

“Had a delicious dinner at The Iron Rail on Saturday evening. Service was excellent. Almost all the tables were full so I suggest reservations. Highly recommended!!!“

“First time visiting GoodEats and we enjoyed our evening. Our daughter still raves about the Mac n’ Cheese and we will be back for sure! While the service took a while given it was a Friday evening and it was busy, the food and drinks did not disappoint. We enjoyed their tiger shrimp appetizer, tripple fried potatoes (yum), a lovely Waldorf-like salad and delicious burger with their works. Overall great meal but a bit pricey!“

“Amazing food, always fresh, large portions and friendly atmosphere.“

“Love the Batman interior!“

“My girls and I stumbled upon this place and OMG!!!! The food is fantastic, everything we ate was super fresh and delish. How did we not know about this place???? My kids are saying it’s their favorite restaurant and now want to come back for their birthday dinner. The atmosphere is perfect and the staff is soooooo friendly. Our waitress Charlie was excellent, personality on point, I wanna throw her in the take home bag as well hahaha. We had to ask to speak to the manager to tell them how much we love it and he comped our desert! 5 stars all the way!!!! Can we move here so it’s closer lol. Thank you guys ?“

“The whole experience was very nice. It was a beautiful day in a lovely setting. Wait, staff was very friendly and the food was delicious. I can hardly wait to go back.“

“This local establishment is open for dinner only. It’s decidedly local with an eclectic menu, excellent service in an atmosphere that focuses on local and regional information relating to the inn and the surrounding area.

We went with the NY strip and the baked cod. The strip was cooked to order and came out melt in your mouth good. The cod was lovely with the stuffing being rich but not too overpowering.

We completely enjoyed our meal at this location. I am sure you will as well.“

“Had a great time! the staff and diners all made my daughter's 21st birthday a great one! Thank you!“

“Manager very nice. Staff hard workers. Nice atmosphere“

“Good food. Good staff. Cold beer“

“To start with, I love the thick menu! I love that they give the back stories on the local products/farms they use. And the plethora of options make certain that both my husband and I can find something we like no matter what we're in the mood for. It's also nice to go to a restaurant that has more than the same 6 things everybody else has and to know those items are made with locally sourced products. I can end with a cupcake made from scratch which also supports another small business instead of something premade from the same manufacturer everyone sources their desserts from. It's a win for me!“

“Great ambience sitting outside near the beautiful waterfall stream! The food is absolutely delectable!“

“Very nicely done inside and the food and drinks were very good. Definitely will be going back. Short Rib was very good, the eggplant was very good we also had the mushroom crostini and antipasto. The tri color cake was so delicious too.“

“It's a quaint little convenience store that sells everything and delicious Bridgewater chocolate.“

“Best Deli / EATERY in town. This place is a hidden GEM ! Everything here is freshly made and the staff are very friendly. It’s hard to find good delis these days in Connecticut but this is the place ! The new owner comes from a long years of experience in the kitchen industry and they are very knowledgeable in what you want to eat. No such thing as language barrier, it’s all about communication and how detailed you are with how you want your order to be made.

Best place in TOWN !“

“The food is AMAZING. Better than what you’d expect for bar food. The in house ranch is worth a mention by itself. It’s so good you’ll put it on everything. The fries are bomb. Wings great. Kids loved their tenders. Will be coming back again when in the area. We didn’t dine in. Took the food to go.“

“Just had a great lunch! Nice people, really good food.“

“Food was awesome. I had the prime rib and my husband had the crab cakes!“