23 Best Sandwich Shops near Penfield

“Best thing to come out of Jersey since Springsteen! The aroma alone is enough to set your salivary glands on fire. I had the Big Kahuna, my wife (very picky) had tuna. Both were excellent. The ingredients were first rate, the sandwiches prepared perfectly, by the most friendly folks ever. Great food, great service, and a great value. I give them five big stars, and my future business.“

“Some of the absolute best subs I have ever had in my life! my favorites (all made to order) include: 1. Their December sub of the month, a turkey, stuffing, gravy, and cheese sandwich (opted for no cranberry sauce) 2. the biggest bacon egg and cheese I have ever eaten, and the best. lord have mercy, I am a sucker for crispy bacon and my God they delivered 3. Top notch cheesesteaks packed with meat. they do not skimp on portions! In addition to their delicious food, DiPisa also has some of the nicest staff you will ever encounter in any eatery. Buncha great people in there. Prices are EXCELLENT for the quality and size of the sandwiches too.“

“This place... is special. I just had a fantastic meal and got a chance to chat with one of the partners and someone else working there. I wish I got their names, because they made me feel like I knew them forever and they were just wonderful. anyone should make it a point to head down there, try whatever they recommend, and have a chat!“

“I laughed I cried I stuffed my face. Great Sub, Delicious“

“Fresh, healthy food and friendly people!“

“Always fantastic. Love the hot sauce. It travels all the ways to Massachusetts!“

“Innovative way of preparing yummy sandwiches with the choice of bed of greens. And people who work there are friendly and patient!“

“I enjoy the subs here at Jersey Mike’s. The sub is consistent with plenty of taste and plenty of options. My usual is the Chicken Philly. Will, who I think is the General Manager, is fantastic. Always friendly, has memorized my Chicken Philly and calls me by name when I come in. I love that he has made the effort to know his customers. If you’re in the area stop in and grab a sub!“

“It was absolutely amazing 👏🏿 😍. This visit was the first time. My mother and I were here on for our lunch date. We both enjoyed it very much. It was the first visit for us both. I had the #17 Philly cheese steak it was absolutely amazing 👏🏿 😍. I had to let them know that after we ate. The customer service was out of this world. Everyone was pokute and friendly. We will definitely return here. I hope all locations are the same.“

“Today we picked up 4 jumbo sub platters for a funeral from the Amiel’s in Victor! Thank you so much! They were delicious as always. We are very thankful for taking such great care with our order!“

“Thanks to the Webster crew for the sandwich made with “lots of love”! 🙂“

“Again, this place was recommended by a friend from the area. When I walked in with a couple at the same time, they ordered with the cashier and I ordered at the kiosk. The kiosk was easy to manage. The staff wasn't friendly at all. No smiles or thank you. I also noticed some tables were dirty and an associate was in a booth watching something on her phone. I don't think she was on break because everything she had no customers she would do that.“

“I drive 50 minutes to come get the best subs around ! A little pricy but so delicious! Always have friendly crew working ❤️“

“💗 incredible food, thank you!“

“Irondequoit location) my first time ever at Jersey Mike's not only the food was better than I expected but the Staffing they had there was unbelievably friendly and welcoming, definitely will go there again“

“Give Alexis Haynes a raise! No I do not know her, but I am a former sales manager and I would hire her in a heartbeat. GC did not want to run for an online order so I made the order in the store. She handles it with expert care and provided excellent customer service. I left feeling like she took care of me and I forgot the frustration I felt at not being able to place my order online. Very nice job! Her customer service is exactly what it should be and I see you!!!! Great job and keep up the good work!“

“Great service & great subs!!! Love the food. Highly recommend.“

“We went on 8/14/25. I tried the Abruzzi. Roasted pork, sharp provolone, broccoli rabe. But I had them throw on the roasted red peppers, which normally come on the Nellie. This is usually served as a cold sub but I asked them if they would toast the entire thing. I couldn't wait to get home. When I unwrapped that bad boy, the 1st thing I noticed when I bit into it, was the warm, toasty crunch of that bread. Then I got the porky goodness of the meat. Followed by the ever so slightly garlicky flavor of the broccoli rabe. And then the sweetness of those roasted peppers. I read some negative reviews right before we came here. Almost didn't come here because of them. All I can say guys, is I am so glad we decided to try Primo Hoagies for ourselves. Oh yeah, my partner got the Italian Diablo. He loved it, as well. I couldn't decide when I first walked in. I figured I'd get something different next time I come. But I am pretty much in love with that Abruzzi!! 💟“

“I just ate the best Dam sub EVER. Whoever is making the subs today is an expert!!!

As of February 2025 Henrietta Jimmy Johns is Freaky slow. They now use a service that delivers in 50 minutes or more. This change has removed them from my top places to order lunch from.“

“Absolutely amazing subs and the customer service is excellent as well 🥰“

“Great tasting food!!!! lots of options to choose from.“

“This place makes the #1 best subs hands down! Awesome bread, meat of choice is loaded, and plenty of dressings to choose from. I highly recommend this place to all my friends and family. Ya gotta try it! 💜“

“Lance and Becky are a great team at my local sub shop. Lance puts the sub together quick and Becky is kind and respectful. I haven’t seen a cashier counter “serve” me by offering suggestions to enhance my meal. Great job! I’ll be back.“