9 Best Italian Restaurants near Port Byron

“Passing through the area, grabbed pizza to jump back on T-way, and was terrific. Large with sausage, pepper, onions, mushrooms, and pepperoni...and all-in 15 minutes.....great experience.“

“The restaurant made three dishes for take out for my mother’s 80th birthday on Father’s Day and they all were excellent! Mom, Dad, and the rest of the family very much enjoyed the food and salad! Thank you and I would highly recommend Lasca’s!“

“Always great service and great food! This place takes me back to Little Italy, NYC.“

“I had such a wonderful time at Curley’s, and much of that was thanks to my bartender, Lexy. From the very start, she was friendly, always attentive without being overbearing, and she ensured every detail was perfect. It’s clear she genuinely cares about making sure everyone has a great experience. The food was absolutely delicious, fresh, flavorful, and served quickly. The drinks matched the same high quality, perfectly crafted with special seasonal options, and are definitely a must-try if you’re visiting. But what truly made it special was the lively, fun atmosphere, especially the little gnomes hidden around the place. They brought a charming, playful vibe to the setting; all in all, great service, tasty food, wonderful drinks, and a really cool vibe. I can’t wait to come back!“

“ordered pizza and a sub there yesterday it was delicious. I moved out of state and recently came back this is the best pizza place around .you won't be disappointed“

“Ordered for the 1st time (1/17/2026). Amazing service, great price and garlic bread w/cheese and meatlovers pizza - amazing!!!!“

“Our absolute favorite place for dinner, for a million years!???. Love everything on the menu, love all the people who work there and make it work, Bernie’s creativity in the kitchen, the atmosphere, the friendly folks who frequent the bar…….. what else do you want to know?“

“Awesome food, great price, excellent staff . Had everything I favored/craved one of the best experiences I've had at weedsport ninos. Will definitely dine again.“

“The Sunset hosted a baby shower brunch. They were very accommodating. We received many compliments and everything turned out perfectly! Such a beautiful space and the food was delicious!“