50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Port Jefferson Station

“I have been loving Colosseo pizza since jr High school. Thats over 40 plus years and somehow they have not drop a notch in greatness. In todays time, there are so many critics of pizza being so widely loved, but these guys are a Long Island staple.

Inside, its very clean and moves quick in all respects be take-out, by the slice or sit down in their back dining room. Nothing super fancy but your coming for their great pizza!“

“Great food and great staff!!!“

“Last night was our 3rd time ordering from them. 2 times we did pick up and last night due to weather we did delivery! All 3 times we were blown away with the quality of food, taste and customer service we received! Amazing food and taste delicious. Everyone who works there is awesome and this is definitely our go to pizza place for now on! Thank you all“

“New ownership is doing a great job updating the place. Great staff!“

“Vincent and his team are top notch. Could not have asked for a better experience! The food was incredible and my guests were excited and super pleased. The interactions from Vincent and his staff made the party rock. Highly recommend for your next gathering, you won't be disappointed.“

“I recently catered a baby shower from here and the guests were raving about the food. So delicious! The process was seamless, staff amazing - I couldn’t have been more pleased! Highly recommend St. James Pizza & Pasta!“

“Simply the best pizza on Long Island!!!!“

“All I'll say is.. Mama Mia !!“

“Just had some amazing slices! 2 Grandma slices, 1 Chicken Marsala slice and 1 regular. Great taste and crust was cooked perfectly. Definitely recommend“

“We had a catered party yesterday, with several recommendations to use Tony's Pizza. The food was delivered and set up for us. It was piping hot, had very generous portions, and most importantly delicious! Luigi was super friendly at the pizzeria, and great to work with for the follow-up. Thank you guys, for helping my son's 21st birthday be a huge success! The Sitler Family.“

“Amazing every time!! Your pizza is like a piece of GOLD!! Thank you for keeping it fresh!“

“Baked clams were so fresh and fulfilling. They have a full clam in each half shell for starters but the stuffing and sauce was so original and flavorful I can't wait to get another batch. The chicken Francese dinner was a beautiful thing as well. I highly suggest Sal Anthony's if you are looking for some authentic Italian/Sicilian food. Fresh bread and wonderful fresh salad with the works as well and a nice balsamic. Pricing was fair as well. I could go on but I'll let you decide. Get in there you won't regret it.“

“Delicious pizza!! Highly recommend to anyone who loves a good slice! Nelson and his staff make amazing food! Great service and always very friendly! May God continue to bless your business!!“

“Just Made the pizza from the Pizza Kit for The Harding Avenue Elementary School fundraiser, and it was delicious.“

“Every good service and great food“

“Local pizza joint with 1980 prices! Food is good, people are nice, happy to support our small businesses in the neighborhood!“

“The absolute best !!! Catered food for my son’s graduation party 7/26 never disappoints!! Eggplant parm ,tortellini Alfredo , chicken parm , chicken Marsala all gone !!! Should have ordered more everyone was raving!! Bravo !!“

“We LOVE Alfie's. Food and service are always OUTSTANDING!“

“We often stop in for delicious Italian food, a pizza lunch and/or dinner. For my mother in laws 100th we decided to cater dinner at home. Most who know us know how we love to cook, and eat, but it sure was terrific to spend time together, relax & enjoy, with limited clean up.
Food was delicious. Eggplant parm, Penne a la vodka, Chicken Marsala, yummy garlic knots, pasta with escarole & beans, fabulous!
When they found out we were celebrating mom's 100th they sent best wishes and complimentary cookies to have with our espresso & desserts.
Food delivered was warm and fresh. On time. Driver helped us set up.
Thank you Victor, Sal & O Sole Mio.“

“Had a wonderful lunch with three friends today. Great food and service. Such a wonderful surprise will certainly make it a go to place. Thanks for a great lunch.“

“The BEST pizza in the world!“

“Awesome pizza! Friendly staff, quick service, affordable and delicious! Tony's Wife“

“Amazing Pizza! Nice and crispy and delicious. This will be our new go to spot! 🍕“

“Thank you for the spinach pinwheels, garlic knots, pepperoni knots, and vegetables with sausages. Your hospitality were great.“

“My favorite local pizza place! Pizza is always cooked perfectly and never had an issue here. Their sauce is delicious and it goes great with a calzone or garlic knot. The staff treats you like family and cares about the quality of their food. Will be coming back for years!“

“Nino's Pizzeria is more than just a place to grab a slice; it's a cornerstone of our community. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with the comforting aroma of freshly baked dough and simmering tomato sauce, a scent that instantly feels like home. But it's not just the delicious food that keeps me coming back. It's the warm, welcoming atmosphere, the friendly faces behind the counter, and the sense of connection that makes Nino's a truly special place.“

“Visiting from South Carolina to celebrate my daughter‘s, sweet 16 and Bella Roma welcome our party of 20 to celebrate!! Their food and service was absolutely amazing!! Gabriella has got to be the best server we have ever had! Top notch service and hospitality!!she took care of our every need with a smile the entire time!! Thank you Bella Roma we will be back!!“

“I came in there over the summer with my wife and my grandson, Gerald. We were greeted by a young lady by the name of Brooke. Let me tell ya, she was a wonderful waitress to mi familia y yo! She brightened up out dinner experience and made the whole restaurant glow with positivity. I have never experienced such amazing service in my 73 years of life. I especially want to thank her for being nice to my grandson. he has severe autism and she was just a doll! She even sang him happy birthday (he was turnin 7). I tell ya what, if I hadn't lost so much money to these darn taxes, I would've left a $100 tip for this sweet girl. PLEASE give miss Brooke a nice raise. And give her my best wishes. Hugs & Kisses, -Rupert, Gerald and family <3“

“Dinner tonight. Amazing white pizza…cheesy and garlicky! Also ordered a pizza with crispy eggplant and added 1/2 hot peppers. The owner is very accommodating. He will basically put together whatever you’re in the mood for. We will definitely be back! 🍕“

“We love their vodka margarita pizza (if you haven’t it’s a must have). So we decided to have them cater our daughter’s birthday dinner. The catering packages were affordable, good selection, plenty of food and delicious. Everyone enjoyed their food and the pizza. They also delivered which was a huge plus. Thanks so much!! Definitely will be ordering again. Shout out to Autumn who was so helpful, easy to place an order with and pleasant.“

“One of our favorite pizzerias. Love all the options. Pizzas and salads are the best around!“

“I just found great pizza in Suffolk County 8.4 had the Roman style. Unbelievable and white slice absolutely amazing with a grilled chicken Caesar slice the wife loved it keep doing what you doing and thank you.. see you soon!!!“

“My absolute favorite pizza place! My best friend and I love it here. We love their cheese pizza and their caesar salad is to die for. Workers and atmosphere is nice for a pizza place but we really just love the pizza! Even better than in nyc! Always come here whenever I have a pizza craving! Definitely recommend.“

“Sept 2025: 5 star review. sat down inside and was treated perfectly. It was three of us. The waitress was so nice. The food was absolutely perfect. The garlic knots were the best knots I’ve ever had. Cheesy and garlicky perfection. Would order these every single day. Ordered 16” Paulie’s pie with pepperoni. It did not come out burnt. The taste was perfect!!! Also order buffalo and garlic parm wings. The buffalo sauce was out of this world. The garlic parm was average but still tasty.
I have to say I would return.

August 2025: was a 4 star review. Ordered online and did a pick up. Pizza tasted yummy but lots of the pizza was burnt from the coal fired oven. We couldn’t eat the crust. Otherwise, great flavor“

“Everything AMAZING in one word!“

“amazing pizza alot of variety so nice the owners and staff who work there they always remember me and i love their rice balls and now calzone their desserts are amazing too make sure to try them and all their specials you can also get points for reward this is the best pizza place in neighborhood love it“

“I stopped at Lorenzos Pizza for the 1st time today. The pizza is fantastic and gets the full 5 stars.The middleaged gentleman working counter, however should get 1 million stars.Someone in my car got sick as we pulled up to park, and left a little mess infront of the store, and may need urgent care.I went in and told him what was happening, and asked if he had a bucket, so I can clean it.He did not blink an eye, and insisted I take care of my matters, and he would clean it.He offered me towels, napkins, whatever I needed.His only concern, was for me to attend to ourself, and he would do the rest.I travel to St. James 2x per week for the unforseeable future, and I will be stopping in for lunch frequently.SIR, I didnt get your name, but I cant thank you enough.You are a model of what every human should be like.Thank you“

“I have ordered from Goomba Johnny's many times and have never been nothing more than satisfied. I usually order the 2 pie deal, granny pies are phenomenal. Will be a customer for many more orders! Thank you.“

“Second time I had Sicilian pizza and salad delivered. One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had on Long Island. I am definitely going to visit them to see what else they have to offer. Their salad was delicious too, and their dressing was outstanding.“

“Great food. Great experience overall. 👍🏼“

“We have been going to Via Pizza for years (like, more than 20!). It is a small family owned place and always produces delicious NY style (real deal!) pizza and other Italian dishes. We have never had a bad meal here and they are pleasant and helpful always. Highly recommend!!“

“Have been getting pizza from here for over 15 years - best pizza around! They also give so much back to our local community, especially our schools.“

“Meatballs-tasted almost identical to when my Italian, childhood best friend’s grandma would slow simmer them ALL day long every Sunday!! The grilled chicken in the Greek salad was very moist and soft. Loved their 6 slice pizza too-great cheese and perfect amount of sauce that’s way less acidic than other local pizza, maybe partially because they use less sauce. Staff were very kind too. Highly recommend.“

“Both round and square.“

“Great food! vegan options!!! I always eat vegan when I go out due to an allergy. everything was delicious and I ate safely. thanks! I'll be visiting again!“

“Best Sicilian slice around“

“Stopped in today for the first time. We just happened to be in the area. The place is spotless and all the employees were extremely nice. We had a couple specialty slices that were amazing. Loaded with chicken, cheese and everything else that makes for a perfect afternoon meal. Even though I’ll need to pass by 3-4 places along the way I’m gonna make it a point to go there again and again.“

“Stopped in on my lunch break while working in the area, got 2 slices with Pepperoni & added fresh Garlic $12 total A bit pricey BUT Amazing crust, & Delicious ingredients, Best Pizza I ever had hands down! Would & have recommended to coworkers.“

“Had a bad cold and it was a rainy Monday so I was grateful to find Brook House open. Ordered a chicken caesar salad to take home and the staff kindly threw in some potato/leek soup to help cure me. All delicious and the kindness will not be forgotten.“

“horrible orange pizza with clowns outside avoid at all costs“