20 Best Sandwich Shops near Port Jefferson Station

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Sandwich Shops near Port Jefferson Station.

Showing 20 of 20 restaurants

  • Jersey Mike's Subs 4600 Nesconset Highway Ste c, Port Jefferson Station Sandwich Shop · $

    1 Jersey Mike's Subs

    4.0 Good 162 Reviews

    4600 Nesconset Highway Ste c, Port Jefferson Station

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Portabella Chicken Cheese Steak
    • Jersey Mike's Famous Philly
    • Chicken Philly Cheese Steak
    • Chipotle Cheese Steak

    “Thank you Jersey Mike's for toasting my cold sandwich for me because as a pregnant lady I was craving this for months and couldn't eat cold cuts until I saw that it can be toasted for people like me. You made my whole day! WOO!! Italian sub, Mike's way. The besssstttttt”

  • Chubs Burgers Burritos and Heroes 625 Horseblock Road, Farmingville Wraps · $

    2 Chubs Burgers Burritos and Heroes

    4.1 Good 216 Reviews

    625 Horseblock Road, Farmingville · 6.36 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Uncle Rons Philly Cheese
    • All American Sandwich
    • Hey Darnold Burrito
    • Chicken Balsamico

    “They have quite an array of sandwiches, burgers, and burritos and every one of them is delicious!! Their salads are excellent as well !”

  • Subway 400F Horseblock Road, Farmingville Sandwich Shop · $

    3 Subway

    4.2 Good 56 Reviews

    400F Horseblock Road, Farmingville · 6.23 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “Frank the owner runs the best subway I've ever been 2 period.”

  • Charleys Cheesesteaks 313 Smith Haven Mall VC02, Lake Grove Cheesesteaks · $

    4 Charleys Cheesesteaks

    3.9 Good 69 Reviews

    313 Smith Haven Mall VC02, Lake Grove · 6.11 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Watermelon Strawberry Lemonade
    • Philly Cheesesteak
    • Cheese Fries

    “I work in the mall for 4+ years and I think Charlie’s the best place to eat compared to other options. A beautiful worker, Sonny, has been there what feels like everyday. Every time I go she always has amazing energy and slides an extra sauce! She goes out of her way to make someone’s day. They always have good deals and an expansive menu, def recommend on a shopping trip!”

  • Subway - Islandia - 54406 1714 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia Fast Food · $

    5 Subway - Islandia - 54406

    4.2 Good 36 Reviews

    1714 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia · 10.83 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “Excellent ,I have an autistic son that will only eat Subway. This is the second time we been there this week. It was Closing when we got there today. and he saw us at the door and opened it up and made a sandwich for my son you don’t know how much I appreciated that thank you”

  • Subway 1080 North Country Road, Stony Brook Sandwich Shop · $

    6 Subway

    3.8 Good 91 Reviews

    1080 North Country Road, Stony Brook · 4.27 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Subway Club

    “The meal was an absolute delight. Each dish was exquisitely prepared, offering a symphony of flavors that danced on the palate. It was evident that every ingredient was meticulously sourced at the peak of its freshness, from the crisp, garden-picked vegetables to the succulent, high-quality proteins.”

  • Jersey Mike's Subs 1113 NY-25A, Stony Brook Sandwich Shop · $

    7 Jersey Mike's Subs

    3.9 Good 60 Reviews

    1113 NY-25A, Stony Brook · 4.35 miles

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chicken Philly Cheese Steak
    • Ham and Provolone
    • Sub

    “Jersey Mikes has impressed me. I always thought that they were just a worse subway till I tried it out for the first time. The staff-Aidan and Ezekial- were very nice and what suprised me was that they were only in highschool! For highschoolers they were very respectful and made wonderful food. The #17 is by far my favorite sub.”

  • Subway 600-07 Portion Road, Ronkonkoma Sandwich Shop · $

    8 Subway

    3.6 Good 93 Reviews

    600-07 Portion Road, Ronkonkoma · 6.86 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Meatball Marinara Melt Footlong Melt
    • Subway Club Footlong Regular Sub
    • Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki
    • White Chip Macadamia Nut

    “Subway is a reliable choice for quick and customizable meals. With a wide variety of fresh ingredients and options, their sandwiches are always satisfying. The service is efficient, making it a go-to spot for a delicious and convenient bite.”

  • Subway 346 NY-25A Ste 68, Rocky Point Sandwich Shop · $

    9 Subway

    3.7 Good 53 Reviews

    346 NY-25A Ste 68, Rocky Point · 5.58 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “Great place if you want amazing food and a clean place to sit and get food always clean and neat ! Great prices , and employees are always nice and always remember who you are , if u come in a lot they even remember you’re order I will be coming again !”

  • Subway Roth Cafe, 600 Circle Road, Stony Brook Sandwich Shop · $

    10 Subway

    4.0 Good 24 Reviews

    Roth Cafe, 600 Circle Road, Stony Brook · 4.12 miles

    • Delivery

    “Convenient location in a small strip mall off major roadway, easy in and out access. Well established. Keeps up with corporation "specials", has good foot traffic. Ingredients are fresh but the "fresh baked bread" sometimes is not "right out of the oven" and can get a little hard after being "toasted."”

  • Subway 402 Medford Avenue, Patchogue Sandwich Shop · $

    11 Subway

    3.5 Good 95 Reviews

    402 Medford Avenue, Patchogue · 10.1 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Meatball Marinara
    • Rotisserie

    “Get lunch here every Saturday after work. Everyone is always very welcoming as soon as you walk in. I look forward to Mat making my sandwich if he's working. Everyone else is great, but the kid knows what's up. Always fresh and never an issue. ??”

  • Jersey Mike's Subs 601-24 Portion Road, Lake Ronkonkoma Sandwich Shop · $

    12 Jersey Mike's Subs

    3.5 Good 82 Reviews

    601-24 Portion Road, Lake Ronkonkoma · 6.87 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Big Kahuna Chicken Cheese Steak
    • Jersey Mike's Famous Philly
    • Club Supreme
    • Sandwich

    “The Stickball sandwich is phenomenal. I always add turkey to it. The combo of provolone, salami, ham and turkey ooff ahh. My only gripe is the price for added turkey $6 😂! The place is clean and the smell of bacon cooking as you walk in is amazing.”

  • Jersey Mike's Subs 357 NY-25A, Rocky Point Sandwich Shop · $

    13 Jersey Mike's Subs

    3.5 Good 62 Reviews

    357 NY-25A, Rocky Point · 5.63 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Big Kahuna Cheese Steak
    • Sandwich

    “So excited to try what everyone is all a buzz in Rocky Point. Jersey Mike’s Subs is for dinner tonight. It was delicious and now a family favorite !!”

  • Jersey Mike's Subs 280A Middle Country Road, Selden Sandwich Shop · $

    14 Jersey Mike's Subs

    3.4 Good 168 Reviews

    280A Middle Country Road, Selden · 4.21 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chicken Philly Cheese Steak
    • Turkey and Provolone
    • Ham and Provolone
    • Sandwich

    “I went there today for the 1st time. I had to try them. I'm so glad I did. I got the Tuna fish hero. OMG! It's so delicious! I definitely recommend them. Generous portions on the sandwiches! I'm very picky about my tuna fish, their's is really very good! I'm sure everything else is too.”

  • Jimmy John's 691 NY-25A Unit 27, Miller Place Sandwich Shop

    15 Jimmy John's

    3.9 Good 14 Reviews

    691 NY-25A Unit 27, Miller Place · 3.92 miles

    • Delivery

    “I visited this store because I remembered the store from my childhood while visiting Florida. Some of the same things are still available plus a few newer selections. I had the Club Tuna which I enjoyed very much. I also had Pesto Pasta Salad which was quite unique in flavor. Service was quick and efficient. The only problem I had with this place was the pricing. The above order plus a pickle was about $27.. Pricing above local competition.”

  • Subway 451 NY-25A, Miller Place Sandwich Shop · $

    16 Subway

    3.4 Good 68 Reviews

    451 NY-25A, Miller Place · 3.47 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Steak Egg & Cheese Wrap
    • Veggie Delite for Kids
    • The Hotshot Italiano
    • Baked Lay's Original

    “I frequent this Subway both as a customer and as a delivery driver, so I'm here pretty often. The staff is always friendly, but I especially want to give a shoutout to Vani. She's always welcoming, works hard, and keeps things running smoothly no matter how busy it gets. It's people like her that keep me coming back. Great job!”

  • Subway - Bohemia - 36166 3460 Veterans Memorial Highway Ste 4 & 5, Bohemia Sandwich Shop · $

    17 Subway - Bohemia - 36166

    3.3 Good 88 Reviews

    3460 Veterans Memorial Highway Ste 4 & 5, Bohemia · 10.41 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Turkey Cali Club Footlong Regular Sub
    • Oven Roasted Turkey
    • Veggie Patty
    • Cookies

    “By far my favorite Subway on Long Island. Clean restaurant, with professional and friendly staff…and TASTY FOOD. As someone who is constantly traveling Long Island for work, I can honestly say that this Subway goes the extra mile. I’ve catered from here before, and other Subway’s barely put any meat on their sandwiches…THIS ONE DOES. This is how Subway should be. Check out this location next time for lunch, and I promise you will be happy!”

  • Charleys Cheesesteaks 161 Centereach Mall, Centereach Cheesesteaks · $

    18 Charleys Cheesesteaks

    3.2 Average 43 Reviews

    161 Centereach Mall, Centereach · 4.69 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chicken Teriyaki Cheesesteak Boxed Meal
    • Old School Cheesesteak
    • Philly Cheesesteak
    • Mozzarella Sticks

    “Stopped in for a sub, fell in love with the environment. What a cool place, the manager is the sweetest person. He let my son get behind the counter and make a couple subs for customers! That little bone head kept getting the orders wrong so the business probably lost a lot of money due to refunds, but those were the best 5 hours of my kids life. Sorry about breaking the soda machine I really didn’t know about pushing all of the buttons at once.”

  • Subway 2350 Nesconset Hwy Store Suite 50, Stony Brook Sandwich Shop · $

    19 Subway

    3.2 Average 70 Reviews

    2350 Nesconset Hwy Store Suite 50, Stony Brook · 5.14 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Subway Club Footlong Pro Double Protein
    • Tuna Footlong Pro Double Protein
    • Veggie Delite

    “The Stony Brook Subway is by far the cleanest Subway location I’ve ever been to. It’s spotless, well-organized, and everything is always fresh and well-stocked. What truly sets this location apart is the woman who runs it—a hardworking, attentive Hispanic manager who clearly takes immense pride in her work. She’s so professional and welcoming that I honestly thought she was the owner. Her attention to detail and commitment to quality are unmatched.”

  • Subway 173 B Smithtown Boulevard, Nesconset Sandwich Shop · $

    20 Subway

    3.1 Average 70 Reviews

    173 B Smithtown Boulevard, Nesconset · 8.36 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Roast Beef Footlong Pro Double Protein

    “I visit this Subway regularly. I have never had any issues with service or food quality. Friendly staff clean restaurant and good amount of seating. I've noticed over the years that it may have changed ownership a couple of times but still no issues and was a seamless transition. I would recommend this location to others as one of the better stores as I have been to a few which do not stack up as well. It is a convenient location in a strip mall with plenty of other shopping nearby. Vegetarian options: Plenty of vegetables here. More than one person could want. The combinations are endless limited only by your imagination. Parking: Parking is reasonable. Being tucked in a strip mall makes parking abundant. Handicap accessible parking is available too.”

Sandwich Shops Nearby

You May Also Like

  • Buffalo Wild Wings Go and Jimmy John's Now Share a Roof in Florida

    Buffalo Wild Wings Go and Jimmy John's Now Share a Roof in Florida

    Floridians north of Sarasota can order chicken wings and a sub sandwich at the same counter. Quality Foods Restaurant Group opened the first co-branded Buffalo Wild Wings Go and Jimmy John's on Aug. 18 at 5241 69th St. E in Palmetto. The franchisee runs three other Buffalo Wild Wings in Florida and chose fast-growing Manatee County for its game-day calendar, from high school football to Pirates spring training.