“Great little mom & pop eatery in Red Creek, NY. They have ice cream in the summer and pizza/food menu year round. I was pleasantly surprised by how good the food was on my first visit. So good, we went back the next night too. Fried zucchini was good, wings was good and my bf loved the Chicken cordon bleu. Check them out!“
“We are some what new to wolcott and we have ordered a few times and we’re never disappointed but last night we ordered a couple deep dishes and man were they amazing it is really hard finding a great deep dish. You could tell the pizza was made with love ❤️ we will for sure be ordering again you have a new long time customer thank youFor the amazing pizza ?“
“The customer service is THE WORST ANYWHERE.I've ordered every week for two years. More than 3k in business in two years.Perhaps you should ask why I ask for Josh specifically. It's because Josh, is the only employee that remembers the entire order, and he is the only employee who doesn't have an attitude and act like taking my order is a huge hassle.Every time we order we have to deal with some huffing and puffing or some other kind of drama from the entire team (EXCEPT JOSH) starting with the owner and trickling down.Food is fantastic.“
“We are new to Central New York, and The Cottage Inn is one of the very few "local" places with great selections, great food & the best service. Make sure you make reservations or you may have a wait, this is the local hot spot and is packed full on Friday & Saturday nights.We have tried many of the specials, and the seafood platter & prime rib are our favorites. There's also a great selection of adult beverages with a great "pub-like" atmosphere at the bar, and more than enough selections of dessert for that after dinner treat.You won't go wrong choosing The Cottage Inn for your next quiet dinner for two, or fill a table for 12, this place can accommodate all size groups.But call ahead, or you may wait for an open table... we recommend waiting if needed, you won't be disappointed.“