50 Best Seafood Restaurants near Rye

“Food was very good once our server took our order. I was there with my spouse and my 83 year-old mom and felt totally invisible: our server took the orders of a table next to us that was seated 10 minutes after we were. Didn't feel great.“

“It really just doesn't get any better“

“Cristian the waiter is amazing…the food and drinks were great!!!“

“I went to a family friend’s 70th birthday party they hosted in the Atlantic ballroom. The space was modern and very clean. The food was DELICIOUS!!! And the workers, Yiselle, Estrellita, and Shorty (blonde) made the event so memorable! They paid attention to every detail, whether it was filling our water cups, collecting unused plates and of course they did it all with a warm smile. They were kind, funny and very welcoming. I had a wonderful time! Thank you Yiselle, Estrellita and shorty!!!“

“You won't find a better seafood restaurant on Long Island and you can include the Jersey Shore. Just go down the menu ..... All Fantastic!!! Don't forget to hear the Specials for the Evening. "Over the Top" Dining Experience. You're will LOVE IT !!“

“The best around service is grestaff is friendly. Food is out of this world. Highly recommended“

“Fresh tasting seafood with excellent service in a warm and welcoming environment.“

“Amazing first time experience at this great restaurant!! Food outstanding, service over the top and ambience and space amazing!! It’s been a long time since we had such a great first experience at a restaurant. Everyone should check this place out, will Be sooo fun and delicious!! Steak over the top!! 🥩🍷“

“I attended a surprise party this Saturday evening. The cuisine was preselected, waiter service was excellent, should receive raises. The table arrangement was very poor. The party was downstairs in one of the private rooms. We were 25 people at one very long table, basically the length of the room, which made it difficult for guests to get around the seated persons at the head of the table on either side. Having two tables would have been a better arrangement, but one long table was not conducive for conversation since we were so far from the other end of the table. The food; not many complaints, I really didn’t have a problem. I didn’t have a lot of food, but it was delicious. The dessert, sorry not very good. Those Famous Crepes(palacinkes) sorry not that great. A lot of crepe and not a lot of filling. The dish was served with fruit, unfortunately this fruit was not in season, so the watermelon although it added color to the dish, upon tasting it, left much to be desired. Why not serve fruit that is in season? No offense to my party hosts who selected my menu for the evening, it didn’t lend itself to the 5 Star Reputation of Dubrovnik’s. I would like to make reservations and splurge on a dinner on my own, I have a feeling I would LOVE the experience! Btw, another plus was the parking!“

“Very good service. Food was very flavorful and had an overall great experience.“

“We had a wonderful meal there - all four entrees were excellent, the service was perfect, and the price is very reasonable. I wasn't expecting such a tasty meal!“

“I've been visiting Johnny's for over 30+years. Today I went for a lobster roll which replaced the shrimp roll. last year this lobster was so delicious 😋 couldn't wait till the summer. unfortunately, I was highly disappointed. it is not longer on a garlic bun and now served on a plain hot dog bun :( also flavorless! last yr price was $24 and now up to $28 with no flavor and blah bun. please bring back the recipe from years before. thanks“

“The food was delicious and many entrees to choose from we were a group of six“

“We hosted our wedding rehearsal dinner here and it was such a wonderful experience from start to finish! Danny was absolutely fantastic to work with—he was incredibly helpful, communicative, kind, and accommodating throughout the entire planning process. He made everything feel easy and stress-free, which meant so much to us during such a busy time.
The waitstaff was also wonderful—friendly, attentive, and welcoming—and the food was absolutely amazing. Our guests had a great time, and we couldn’t have asked for a better place to celebrate such a special occasion and kick off our wedding weekend.

A huge thank you to Danny and the entire Two25 team for helping make our rehearsal dinner so memorable. We highly recommend Two25 for any event!“

“I visited Donjito in White Plains for the first time, and I was pleasantly impressed! The food was absolutely amazing—fresh, flavorful, and beautifully prepared. It was a wonderful first experience, and I’m definitely looking forward to coming back and trying more of their dishes. Highly recommended!“

“Love this place! Went to lunch- they have $15 (11-3) menu with lots to choose from, $5 beers and $2 oysters. Everything was great. I had the flounder fillet sandwich, comes slaw and chips. Totally recommend it. Also, great views of the LI Sound.“

“I first visited this restaurant when they opened in 2016. A decade later, I happened to be visiting the area and stopped off here for lunch with my boyfriend. I can honestly say this place hasn't lost their touch.
The restaurant is dark and cozy with a fireplace in the back, making it a perfect spot for a romantic dinner or nice lunch. The servers are all well-versed in the menu items and oyster selection. The restaurant usually has some great specials that are always worth trying out.
This visit was somewhat brief so we only got mains. The special of the day was swordfish. They offer the option to choose your prep style so we each got the swordfish; I tried the lemon butter sauce and my boyfriend got the red pepper sauce. Both were perfectly prepared and delicious. We also shared a side of the grilled asparagus which was perfectly cooked.
A solid 10/10. Highly recommended for any foodies as this place also has some fantastic non-seafood options.“

“Fabulous! My favorite restaurant I’ve been to since moving here 6 months ago!“

“The service is great. Everyone is very nice and the food was delicious. Will be returning again. Thank you so much.“

“The best food going back again .⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Lenny's Steakhouse is always fantastic! The food is consistently excellent, the steaks are cooked perfectly, and the service never disappoints. The staff is welcoming, attentive, and makes every visit feel special. You can always count on a great meal, a wonderful atmosphere, and an all-around exceptional experience. One of our favorite places—we look forward to coming back every time. Highly recommend!“

“Great atmosphere and food !🍱“

“First time dinning- first off the pita with cheese and grilled green peppers is an amazing start to the meal. I had an aperol spritz also great to start. For apps we had oysters- was really good but would love if they would add a mignonette. For my main course though the red snapper was FANTASTIC. And the chicken martini was also fantastic. We didn't stay for dessert but will certainly be back, the service was very kind and attentive. The ambiance was nice with the view of the fountain.“

“we ordered 2 orders of fried catfish, 1 with sweet potatoe fries and 1 with Mac&cheese, and also a side of collards. everything was made FRESH. crispy and delicious fish & fries, super cheesey Mac and the collards we're great! not the first or the last time I will order from here. reasonably priced for fish around here.“

“Excellent drinks, food and service“

“Great location in a lively, redeveloped section of Stamford. We had an event with a fixed price menu and each course was amazingly good. Come hungry, because they give you a lot of food. Apps, salad, pasta and main courses were all wonderful. Great service and a great view of the harbor. Not sure if it is open to the public, but if it is, check it out.“

“What an incredible dining experience at The Silent Sea in City Island, Bronx! From the location to the atmosphere and, of course, the food, everything was outstanding!

The restaurant is perfectly situated right at the entrance to City Island, and having parking available in the back is a huge plus, especially in this area. The atmosphere alone deserves an 11 out of 10!

We started with several appetizers, and every single one was delicious. The Greek fries were hands down the best fries I’ve ever had! The tuna tartare was incredibly fresh, the fried calamari was cooked to perfection, and the fried sardines were absolutely delicious.

For dinner, we ordered the lobster and the baked branzino. Both dishes were exceptional, not only in flavor but also in presentation. You can tell that attention is given to every detail.

Overall, a fantastic experience from beginning to end. Great atmosphere, amazing food, and a beautiful setting. I highly recommend visiting The Silent Sea! Definitely a place worth coming back to!“

“Got my lobster roll before they close for the season. No problem about The hot sun the afternoon was extremely blustery. I’ve always loved this place even though it is pricey for a clam shack.“

“very good food . definitely recommend it“

“Nice spot for brunch. Waiter was attentive, menu had great selections, food was tasty. Pancakes, salmon eggs Benedict, chicken wrap and burger were liked by all. Lava cake and gelato was really good as well.“

“Great place!! Food was delicious and the service was top notch!! Highly recommend it!!“

“Great NY Pizza. We have fresh pie, Excellent“

“This was one of the worst dining experiences I've ever had. Things were screwed up from beginning to end with absolutely no sense of apology or remorse. We had a 630 reservation, showed up on time, but we weren't seated until almost 7pm. The waiter came to our table for the first time at 720pm. We had researched the menu ahead of time to make sure there were kid friendly options, but since it was Mother's Day, they were operating with a different menu which is totally fine. We asked the waiter if they had any kid friendly food that wasn't on the menu and he said no and that all we can get is what's listed on the menu, so we went ahead and ordered. About 20 mins after we ordered, we saw that the kids at the table next to us were eating chicken fingers and french fries, so we asked the waiter why he didn't tell us about that option. He said that we didn't ask and he got a bit of an attitude about it. Luckily he was able to change our order and the kids got chicken tenders. We waited patiently for an incredibly long time for our food to come out, and at about 830, I got up and asked the waiter for an ETA on the food and he again gave me an attitude like I was ruining his night and he said "soon". The food came out about 2 minutes later, so we were hopefully going to get on with our evening. Upon further inspection, the chicken tenders that they delivered to my daughter were RAW. Not just slightly under cooked, completely raw, pink, cold chicken. We called the waiter over again and he again had an attitude when we sent the food back. Again, not even a hint of an apology to be found. When the chicken came back out, it was completely burnt, but we decided it wasn't worth the time to talk to the waiter about it again. At this point we had been at the restaurant for 2 hours with a 5 and 8 year old kid, so we just wanted to be done and get out. Again, at no point during this experience did a single person offer an apology or even show an ounce of remorse for how terrible the service was. They ruined my wife and mother-in-law's Mother's Day dinner and they should be ashamed to call themselves a restaurant. We are a local family, but we will never go back there again. I will also make it a point to tell everyone I know that Caffe Regatta is a terrible restaurant.“

“Great food, service and atmosphere. Service is like the “good old days” and the Portuguese dishes are very traditional, love them. Also love all the beautiful murals throughout the restaurant.“

“Peruvian House is awesome. The food is delicious, the staff is super welcoming, and everything tastes fresh. Their ceviche and lomo saltado are must‑tries. It’s one of those places you go once and immediately want to go back.“

“The food & the service are both amazing.“

“Love Villa Italia! The food is always delicious. Highly recommend the chicken milanese and sitting outdoors when the weather permits.“

“Food was delicious as usual. Waitress was very sweet :)“

“Great raw clams and great price. Steamers , dogs and burgers and fried seafood. BYOB , great place to stop for a quick bite and yearning for raw clams . Nothing fancy but it’s not supposed to be and for what it is it is 5 stars and 2 👍👍 thumbs up!“

“First time trying their breakfast dishes here and I ordered mashed plantain called mangu with pickled onions, chicharron/fried pork and fried mozzarella cheese. I also tried the fruit orange drink with milk forgot the names. Will come back to try their lunch options. Only thing I hate about going here is the difficulty finding a parking spot. Not easy lol“

“One of our favorite local restaurants. All 4 of us thoroughly enjoyed our meals. From appetizers to main entrees to desserts! Mid week price fix meals. Well worth it! The staff , bartender and waitress couldn't have been nicer! Great food, great service!“

“This place is perfection! Just steps from Stamford Center for the Arts' Palace Theatre, it's perfect for dinner and a show, drinks, etc. The good is always fresh, vibrant & delicious. Respectful of dietary choices/restrictions. Gorgeous hotels on either side. Seriously perfect!“

“good food nice atmosphere.geart music.“

“Great seafood in a fantastic location.“

“Prices were reasonable! Food was served quick and was delicious! Valet parking. Staff was pleasant.“

“Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I recently visited Peters Steakhouse and had a fantastic experience. It's clear that this is a family-owned and operated business—the atmosphere is incredibly welcoming, and you can really feel the personal care they put into everything. We ordered the porterhouse for two, ordered three sides, along with the fried calamari and Caesar salad to start. Everything was delicious, and I was especially impressed by the portion sizes—they are very generous! It's the perfect spot if you're looking for a hearty meal in a friendly, local setting. Highly recommended!“

“Guillermo and Mike were very attentive and friendly. This is such a nice and cozy restaurant with a warm vibe. The linguini and clams were great. The dessert of a twist on coffee cake was delicious. The bread roll was fluffy and fresh. Looking forward to coming back.“

“The seafood is fresh and tasty! The staff is attentive and the owner is very friendly! Great atmosphere“

“This place is 100% the best seafood! If your seafood lover is helpful to yourself, please dine here!“