Restaurants near Schuyler Lake

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”

“Soooo good! Best in the area!”

“What a great spot for a meal! The food was delicious and the atmosphere is fun and cheery, especially on a rainy day.”

“We live about 30 minutes from Cooperstown and we’re feeling a bit cooped up due to the cold weather so we decided to go for a drive. We ended up in Cooperstown and, omg, the cutest town ever. As a Baltimore girl and an O’s fan, it was so cool just to walk around a bit. We saw the Double Day Cafe and went there for lunch. Honestly, I think we were just expecting the usual pub food touristy mediocre place (you know what I mean) But no. This place was SOOOO FREAKING GOOD! I had the veggie burger, it was really cool to see an old school homemade veggie burger on the menu. It was delish! And the avocado on top was perfection. How? I don’t know but it was. Also, the macaroni salad was the best I’ve had in a long time. Kind of smoky-ish flavor? So good My friend had a burger. He loved it It hit the spot. Our server, a young woman with glasses and light brown hair (I know, I’m horrible, I can’t believe I didn’t get her name) was awesome. Easy breezy, doing her thing, attentive to everyone, and just all around super cool. Made our day!”

“It’s a great place with indoor and outdoor seating. Great selection of wines l’iCal and other places of NY. Friendliest staff along with Rick, the owner! Have a glass or a tasting!”

“Fantastic drinks!! Staff is awesome!! Hope to get back again!!!”

“We live near DC and we traveled to Cooperstown mostly to visit the baseball HOF and, boy were we fortunate to find Toscana's! It was our anniversary night so we had planned on dining at another place that turned out to be closed for the season. We really feel blessed & so thankful that we came across this little gem instead! The service, the food and the lovely ambience were top-notch! Patrick was our greeter/server and he was just so personable and efficient. Like other reviewers, we didn't have a reservation but Patrick welcomed us as tho we did. As business picked up there was no change in his excellent service. Shout out to the classy soundtrack playing throughout our dinner too. Sinatra, Louis Armstrong, Dean Martin...it was all there floating in the background, never interfering with our conversation. The food was SO good too beginning with the artisan bread & oil that was warm and tasty. I had the salmon with mashed potatoes and steamed broccoli. It was superb. My hubby had the baked haddock also with mashed potatoes and broccoli and he loved it. We had pistachio cake for dessert with espresso which topped off our meal perfectly. I wish we lived closer...but next time we are anywhere near beautiful Cooperstown, we'll head over to Toscana's for another great dining experience.”

“Had dinner last night with friends that have not been there before. They loved the food! I had the best veggie burger in town!”

“TOP SHELF!!!”

“$35 for 3 people- two omelettes, a bagel sausage egg Sammy and coffees. It was DELISH! Best bagel sandwich I’ve had. Quick service. The oat milk chai latte was yummy!”

“A cute little tourist spot for all ages. We enjoyed the tasting room and well priced flights. Mix and match your flight of cider, wine, and harder spirits. It’s nice to try before you buy and the women serving the flights were very personable and funny.

The store is huge and a lot of options for souvenirs and gifts. Buy your duck feed inside where you can get a bit more and in a container rather than the 25cent machines outside.

Snack bar looked interesting but not many real food options. We did get cider donuts to go that were amazing. Just wish this place was open past 6, especially on a Saturday!”

“Excellent food. Noisy dining room.”

“I needed food catered for a gathering at my mother's home after her funeral. Being from Long Island, I was not familiar with restaurants in this area. How lucky I was to walk into Brickhouse Pizzeria. Mike was so helpful when it came to planning a menu on such short notice. We ordered large trays of chicken Parm, meatballs, sausage and peppers, garlic knots, salad, pizza and a platter of wraps. I couldn't tell you which was my favorite because everything was excellent! The freshest food, large portions and absolutely delicious. He was also so compassionate that he arranged for the food to be delivered to my Mom's house after the funeral, so we would have one less thing to worry about that day. What an amazing place!”

“The sangria is wonderful. I always get 2 bags when I see them.”

“Stopped in late afternoon on June 27th...a beautiful setting...great views...took a seat at the bar...music plating...fourteen taps ready to hydrate parched throats after a scenic drive...
Mike behind the bar poured a bossy little blonde...refreshing...light...hit the spot for my sister-in-law...brother chose a throwing hay IPA...spicy...refreshing...balanced and I started with the 200th American Strong Ale...a punch in the taste buds...very well put together...nice spice...great mouth feel...czech'n fences was another standout...the abso-hef'n-lutely was sweet...flavorful...nice nose and the perk up coffee blonde was a standout...amazing coffee nose...very flavorful brewed with espresso beans imparting flavor but not the color...
An enjoyable time was had by our party celebrating a family member's memory...
Ryan(co-owner and brewer) was a joy to talk to...ask questions of and Mike entertained us with a photobomb along with conversation...we will stop again...”

“Simply the best! Highly recommended!!”

“Ive already posted this on google reviews so I’ll post it on Facebook as well! I haven’t been in Cooperstown in quite some time and having to wait for a bit for my wife’s surgery to be completed I went to Upstate bar and grill for the first time. With my mind being everywhere (even for a minor surgery that takes a bit to do) this place was literally wonderful. I don’t do many reviews if at all but I wanted to do one for here. Food was great and the service was SPOT ON! Most importantly so very polite and Nice. My servers name was heather and like I said she was wonderful and thoughtful. I wish most places were kinda like this. Thank you for the service and polite hospitality. I’ll be sure to bring my wife and son when I can!”

“Amaaazing!”

“Today I had their bakery pizza. Wow!! It was just great!! Some of the best, I have had in a very look time, bread and donuts are great too. Just a really good old fashion bakery.”

“great food! great service! 5 stars on the burgers!”

“Just had dinner after seeing the Glimmerglass lights with my Husband and 2 boys (5 years & 6 months) we walked right in to a table at 730pm on a Saturday, great cocktails, the antipasto board blew us away and the strip and seafood risotto were to die for. Great portions, the renovations are beautiful it is so cozy, yet modern and the different salt and pepper shakers on every table are such a cute touch! We will definitely be back and frequently!! Caesar was an amazing waiter, the service was incredible. Can’t wait to return.”

“Finally a decent cup of coffee in upstate New York. It is a little Starbuckish, only better!”

“Best organic meat, fresh produce Milk, eggs Buy local and organic What are you waiting for?”

“Great atmosphere! Fast and friendly service. Great food and drinks. Great option for lunch and dinner between games.”

“The best bbq truck in the 315, and I mean that!!! The bbq fries are simple but addicting. Pulled pork? To die for.”

“Good Food, Fair Price, and great atmosphere. Very Friendly!”

“i grew up in West Winfield and happy to got mine!”

“We pulled up to Rusty Bison at 8:16. After checking their hours and realizing they closed at 9:00, we figured we'd just get food to go. However, the staff gave us a table and didn't rush us at all. (They still had other customers in there as well) We had brisket sandwiches, wings, the shrimp and a fish sandwich. All of the food was really good, and like I said, the staff did not rush us at all. If we're ever back this way, we will definitely eat at Rusty Bison again!”

“Hidden secret ! Ice cream was delicious”

“Every Columbus Day weekend about 30 members of our tractor club goes to Cooperstown for tractor fest. On Friday evening we order pizza and wings and on Saturday we order catered pans of food. From the minute you place the order to the time you pick up the food, all of the employees are very helpful and extremely pleasant to deal with. They are just genuinely nice people, even though they are always extremely busy. The food is always excellent. In a world of short staffed, frazzled restaurant employees, the staff at New Yok Pizzeria of Cooperstown stand out for their awesome attitudes and excellent service.”