11 Best Bakeries near Shelter Island

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Bakeries near Shelter Island.

Showing 11 of 11 restaurants

  • Kyle's 27 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island Bakery · $$

    1 Kyle's

    4.5 Superb 53 Reviews

    27 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Frittata of the Day

    “Stopped in for lunch yesterday. It was a beautiful, cool shady spot on a quaint island porch. The lunch was all home-made and fresh even down to the English muffins. The dessert case had a plethora of delicious freshly baked treats. We sampled a bunch and one was better than the next! Definitely a must visit!”

  • Aldo's Coffee Company 103-105 Front St, Greenport Bakery · $

    2 Aldo's Coffee Company

    4.5 Superb 155 Reviews

    103-105 Front St, Greenport · 2.6 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chocolate Croissant
    • Over Ice
    • Scones

    “the best coffee very good”

  • Levain Bakery 354 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott Bakery · $

    3 Levain Bakery

    4.5 Superb 56 Reviews

    354 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott · 9.58 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookie
    • Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie
    • Levain Cookie Tin Bundle
    • Milk for Cookies Package

    “We took a drive out east for a little day of recharge and stopped at Levain Bakery—what a treat! The shop smelled amazing and had such a cozy vibe. The sweet girl behind the counter really made our visit special. She chatted with us like we were old friends, packed our cookies so beautifully, and made us the best coffee to go with them. It’s rare to meet someone who genuinely loves what they do, and she made the whole experience even better. Between her warmth and those incredible cookies, this stop was the highlight of our day!!”

  • Carissa's the Bakery - Sag Harbor 3 Bay St, Sag Harbor Bakery · $$

    4 Carissa's the Bakery - Sag Harbor

    4.4 Superb 57 Reviews

    3 Bay St, Sag Harbor · 5.13 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Pain D' Epi Baguette

    “What nice people! Such a pleasure to go in and talk with them and get recommendations. Everything they have is incredible. I love everything in this beautiful shop. I embarrass myself because I buy so much. People are happy when in this shop and smile and talk. If you eat one of their grilled cheese sandwiches you will lie in bed dreaming of them. Did I mention how nice everyone is. Linda”

  • The Blue Duck Bakery Cafe 130 Front St, Greenport Bakery · $

    5 The Blue Duck Bakery Cafe

    4.4 Superb 44 Reviews

    130 Front St, Greenport · 2.7 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chocolate Croissant
    • Blue Duck Cookie
    • Apple Turnover

    “Delicious baguettes-traditional or multigrain. Also love the rye loaf to die for. Delicious coffee, pastries and hometown charm.”

  • Blue Duck Bakery Cafe Southold 56275 NY-25, Southold Bakery · $

    6 Blue Duck Bakery Cafe Southold

    4.4 Superb 41 Reviews

    56275 NY-25, Southold · 4.26 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Croissant

    “highly do not recommend. keith kouris harasses people on the internet ! I ALSO GOT FOOD POISONING !! avoid avoid avoid!!!”

  • Stone Street Cafe 54180 Main Rd, Southold Cafe · $

    8 Stone Street Cafe

    4.4 Superb 95 Reviews

    54180 Main Rd, Southold · 4.62 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Sandwich Display
    • Quiche

    “The first time I tried the pretzel croissant I became addicted! All of their croissants are amazing... Their coffee is awesome too! So glad it opened in Southold. Lately, they've been making the pretzel croissants into egg sandwich which I'm sure is delicious too, but I prefer to ask for it alone :) Whoever is making these croissants, thank you Chef!!!!”

  • Round Swamp Farm 97 School Street, Bridgehampton Bakery · $$$$

    9 Round Swamp Farm

    3.8 Good 44 Reviews

    97 School Street, Bridgehampton · 9.35 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Salad and Chicken Salad
    • Chicken Tenders
    • Peach

    “I love the place. I tried the curry chicken salad last weekend. Now my mouth waters when I think about it.”

  • L&W Market 2493 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton Bakery · $$

    10 L&W Market

    3.2 Average 11 Reviews

    2493 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton · 9.26 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “They have the best coffee! The deli is fresh and inviting! It’s such an awesome place to grab the most amazing food for a bite to eat or take in In a picnic basket to the beach!”

  • Armin and Judy 1970 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton Bar · $$

    11 Armin and Judy

    3.6 Good 100 Reviews

    1970 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton · 9.48 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Buttermilk Cookie Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes Curbside pickup: Yes
    • Ruby Red Grapefruit Brûlée
    • Flavigny Orange Blossom
    • Eggs Benedict Supreme

    “Had a very wonderful evening spent at Arman and Judy last week. Most importantly, the food was outstanding with the best french fries I think I've ever tasted and a delicious steak. Judy was gracious as always, even though she was shorthanded that night one would not have known it. Highly recommend for a pleasant evening all around. Paula”

Bakeries Nearby