Shelter Island Seafood
CLOSED$$ •
About Shelter Island Seafood
Shelter Island Seafood Reviews
70 ratings
![Restaurantji Rating]()
Ratings
Menu
Add a Menu
People in Shelter Island Also Viewed
Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe
Seafood Markets, Seafood, Barbeque
Crabby Jerry's
Seafood, American, Pet Friendly
Claudio's Waterfront
Bar & Grill, Seafood, American
Shelter Island Seafood, owned by a husband and wife, offers high-quality fish and shellfish. Customers love the delicious seafood options, including lobster rolls, oyster po’boys, and fish ‘n chips. The menu also features newer choices like scallop sliders. Guests appreciate the friendly owners and the reasonable prices. Popular items include grab-and-go shrimp cocktail trays, as well as fish tacos and scallop sliders recommended by the staff.