10 Best American Restaurants near Sherburne

Columbus Public House American • $
4301 NY-80, Sherburne

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
Shepherd's Pie
Buffalo Wings
Burger

“The burgers are great! Fries are generous and a great cook on them! ?Service was outstanding. When a burger came out slightly less than medium well, they rectified it promptly to perfection! ??Atmosphere was great! Very chill with great music! ?Will definitely go back ?!“

4.6 Superb36 Reviews
Gilligan's Island American • $
64 N Main St, Sherburne

Customers` Favorites

Bacon and Cheese Burger Side of Onion Rings and Gilly Fries Made Two Meals Out of One
Bigger Than the Island Burger
Soft Serve Twist Ice Cream
Homemade Hard Ice Cream
Sweet Potato Fries
Soft Ice Cream
Black Raspberry
French Fries
Hamburger
Sandwich

“Gilligan's, NEEDS to be a HISTORIC LANDMARK!When going to/leaving Binghamton or Pennsylvania, we always make a obsessive stop for Gilligan's. Never have we selected a ice cream, that's out-of-stock. And we order something different each visit. The inside, to most, may seem nothing fancy, and is very typical small-town diners, which can have better food than those over-rated fancy restaurants. Need a meal, they've got an entire menu. Ice Cream, is the most popular, all four seasons. The staff(The Gals), is always busy and very considerate. Public restroom, is kept clean, and the kitchen area, where all the ice cream is, is very sanitary. Three important factors to have returning customers. I find that average & below average Google reviews, are customers whom have poor attitudes and a general "I hate the world," moral. Ya stop-in at Gilligan's, ya just can't give'em a bad review when you taste the ice cream. Outstanding. Tasteful. Prompt. Welcoming. Devoted. Best-of-all: Ya cannot possibly miss the location. It's on Main Street. Just make sure you are attentive and obeying the speed limit. You'll get a ticket for going more than 5 mph over the posted speed limit.“

4.5 Superb61 Reviews
Sherburne Diner Diner • $
47 N Main St, Sherburne

Customers` Favorites

Turkey Club Sandwich
Garlic Pierogies
Egg & Cheese

“Fast Wifi available here. Waitress was great! Portion size is adequate. Prices are fair. Strangely, my english muffin was "bite size". I've never seen an english muffin so small. Lol. That said, I'll come back again. Great little Diner!“

4.3 Superb49 Reviews
Lewis' Restaurant American • $$
93 N Main St, Sherburne

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Shells at Lewis' Restaurant
Cheeseburger Dressed w Fries
Linguine with Clam Sauce
Grilled Chicken Salad
Garlic Strip Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Tenders
Shrimp Cocktail
St Louis Ribs
Coconut Shrimp

“I just ordered four of Lewis’ stuffed shells dinners for the family, and those are the best stuffed shells I have had in years. The portions of salad, bread, and shells are large, and you just can’t beat the price. I will definitely be back! That was an excellent meal, and I do not know how one meal couldn’t more than fill a person to the brim, leaving leftovers. Two thumbs up and five stars!“

4.1 Good24 Reviews
Hamilton Eatery Sandwich Shop • $
41 Lebanon St, Hamilton - 9.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Pot Pie

“Passing through town for work and wanted to find a good spot for lunch. Look no further. You’ve found it. Small place, with great options and a very nice staff. Sandwhich or wraps hot or cold. I got the classic turkey club but did not disappoint. Fresh, toasty bread with all the proper fixins….had a little mac and cheese to live on the edge, which also slaps. Hip hip hooray. Cheers!!“

5 Superb18 Reviews
Ye Olde Landmark Tavern American • $$
6722 US-20, Bouckville - 10.09 miles

“We go here every year in June and August. Forget any negative reviews left by ignorant fools. This restaurant has the best wait staff and service. The warm setting and wonderful charm of this historic building is simply enchanting. The food is divine, never once in all years we've eaten at the Landmark have we ever had a negative experience. The prices are very reasonable when you consider the quality of the ingredients and the skill of the chef and their staff in preparing each dish to order. So long as the landmark is open and I am alive, I will always eat their when I'm in town.“

4.9 Superb18 Reviews
Maxwells Chocolates & Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $$
14 Utica St, Hamilton - 9.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

Maxwell's

“An adorable little candy and ice cream store. The service is good even when busy. The chocolates are delicious, but my fam's fave is their milkshakes. Would definitely recommend trying them if you are in the neighborhood. Thank you for the wonderful service.“

5 Superb9 Reviews
Rusch's Bar & Grill open for in dining or take out Bar & Grill • $
22 Lebanon St, Hamilton - 9.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Bacon Cheddar Burger
Sweet Potato Fries
Chicken Riggies
Street Tacos
Steak Salad
Quesadilla
Sandwich
Meatloaf

“Affordable family meal. Enjoyed the chicken riggies. The kids meals were very reasonably priced with good options. Service was pretty quick. Decent drink options..Kid-friendliness: Kids menu, friendly, decent food optionsParking: Only limited on street parking.“

4.4 Superb22 Reviews
Seven Oaks Restaurant American • $$
73 Payne St, Hamilton - 9.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Marinated Chicken Breast
Buffalo Blue Mac N Cheese
Blackened Chicken
Chicken Sandwich
Classic Caesar
Garden Salad
Primavera
Burger

“Wonderful golf club atmosphere. Overlooks the golf course and a stones throw from Colgate University. You have to try the Phuket chicken wrap. A wonderful combination of sweet and savory with buffalo sauce and sweet chili coleslaw. Laura and Adelina made sure I was well taken care of and although very busy took the time to make sure everyone was enjoying their visit.“

4.4 Superb23 Reviews
The Tavern American • $$
1 Payne St, Hamilton - 9.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Applewood Smoked Bacon
Burger Cooked Medium
Caesar Salad
Hamburger

“Had lunch here today and it was great ! Server Shannon is prompt with food delivery and makes sure you have what you need during your meal. The food is always excellent, freshly prepared and the prices are decent . The restaurant has a relaxing atmosphere and is a very clean .“

3.8 Good42 Reviews
Loading...

Sherburne’s related cuisines

map Map