50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Stillwater

“There's a reason this place has been open 20+ years in a small town with 3 pizza shops!! try it for yourself!“

“Big fan of this place. never disappointed. always good food and service.“

“Good pizza? Good atmosphere. I only gave it a 4 star. The We got a meat lovers underneath. The toppings part of the crust could have been a little more well, all in all, very good pizza.“

“Food that I could eat was ok, but the staff really needs to have a book readily available that lists all ingredients in each dish.
Even if they don't show it to customers, it's critical that at least the staff have access to this information to be able to alert customers whether or not their allergen is in a particular food item.“

“Very delicious pizza, very good recommended to anyone.“

“First time at H&H and the shrooms pizza was outstanding! The crust was perfect, the flavor delightful. Truly looking forward to trying all the other varieties of pizza.“

“The best pizza I’ve ever had! I highly recommend Villa Pizza in Clifton Park!“

“We love Sergios, the foods always good, the staff are always super nice & it’s overall fantastic. Tonight we tried quite a few new things: Grandma Pie, Pinwheels and a chicken cutlet sandwich… all of them were delicious!! It’s not often that a place does so many different choices so perfectly, but these guys crush it. Will definitley continue to return“

“The food here is fabulous. The quality of the food here is way above the cost. I have never had such a delicious eggplant parm is the best I have ever had and my friends burger and sweet potato fries with raspberry dip was HUGE and just as amazing.“

“My bestie recommended Clifton Park Pizza Shop and it did not disappoint 🥰 I ordered the Lasagna and it is hands down the best lasagna i have ever had! The sauce is so good. You can definitely understand why this small place is always so busy!! Highly recommend.“

“First, the pizza was phenomenal! Hubby and I both got a couple slices. They were fresh, hot and delicious! I would have given five stars but I was extremely disappointed in the fact that there is NO BATHROOM and you have to use cash. How can you have a restaurant where there are tables so people can eat there, but not provide someplace for them to wash their hands and use a restroom???? That is totally unacceptable in my opinion. At least let me wash my hands. And who doesn’t take cards these days? But other than that the pizza was 👌🏻“

“Ordered here for my daughter’s birthday dinner last night. The food was delicious and prices on point. Thank you guys“

“First time here and was impressed with the food. I highly recommend this Pizzaria. I am a local guide for Google. See my review on this establishment. Mama Mia, you'll go, eat and be satisfied.“

“I have ordered a couple of times here and my girlfriend always recommends this place for good food. Their boneless wings, AMAZING!!! Literally my favorite in the area, please keep doing what you're doing, their pizza has never disappointed and everyone has always been very friendly and attentive. My number one pizza place by far!“

“Yo Venezia is the best dam Pizza & Pasta Shop !! Highly recommend this Old school family oriented restaurant. Been coming here for years. Food & service is outstanding.“

“Best pizza ever. I’d eat it everyday if I could. Just really disappointed in their shortened hours into the evening and only being open 4 days a week. Im writing this review on a Sunday and am ordering pizza somewhere else because my favorite place isn’t open. They close early too. One time I called at 6:30 pm and was told I couldn’t order bc they wanted to close early that evening. So just make sure you order for an early dinner or else you’ll be out of luck. Still the best pizza ever. We usually order their square cut regular pizza. Perfect crust and amount of cheese. Never had another pizza like it.“

“My daughter ordered two Strombolis tonight and she wanted to let you know they were absolutely delicious. Not only were they huge, but they were prepared perfectly. Also, the delivery guy was so nice, even after he couldn't find our main door. I would have turned around and left, but he waited and was so kind. Thank you for the wonderful service!“

“I have been here a few times and the service is great! The food is great and everyone is very friendly!“

“I’ve been going to this pizza place for the past year now ……. I can say this is the best pizza place in Ballston spa hands down !!!!! I’d even go so far to say in Saratoga as well ….
If you want real pizza and really good food, I would suggest going here anytime you want a pizza!!!!!!!!!“

“the gluten free pizza was AMAZING!! And the price was great!! Will definitely be going back!!!“

“I ordered a BBQ chicken pineapple calzone with extra sauce. This thing was huge! It ended up being lunch and dinner. Best calzone I have ever had!“

“The music , the food and service is excellent w the waiters that make u feel very comfortable ❤️ I suggest panzas especially for a celebration… My friends took me there and it was fabulous“

““I ordered the Chicken Parm with penne pasta through Uber Eats and was really impressed with both the portion size and the flavor — absolutely delicious! I also got the house salad, which was fresh and crisp, and easily enough for two people. The garlic bread was tasty and plentiful as well. Everything arrived hot, all the way to Saratoga Springs at 10 PM. Great food, generous portions, and excellent service. I’ll definitely be ordering again!”“

“Great pizza and wings, our go to in Clifton Park!! Highly recommend checking out Paulie's.“

“The Brick: great place for cold beer, pizza, wings and good people. And. . . for the watching the Celtics.“

“So glad I picked this place tonight for dinner! A lot of friends talked about this place for years and tonight I got linguine and eggplant Parmesan. Outstanding perfect! The atmosphere, the owner everything was spot on great price definitely want to pass it on to people.“

“Richies is always a great place to eat. None of those fancy rolls that some sub shops make with added saw dust. Richie has a bakery make his rolls and he focuses on the meats and cheeses that go inside. I hate a roll that takes away from the taste of the ingredients.
As for his pizzas, it's nearly impossible to find a better pie and I've been in Italy. Those Italian pizzas made me miss America but mostly, miss Richies pizzas.“

“First time trying Napoli’s. We are new to the area from Long Island. The Margherita pie and meatballs were good. ( It’s hard to please a Downstater who’s Italian)!? The sauce was very good. We will definitely return. They were polite and efficient“

“Hosted our Wedding Welcome Drinks party here last weekend and wow was it amazing!
Frank and the team are so kind and generous. Our friends and family loved the space and we couldn’t have imagined celebrating anywhere else! Food and drinks were 10/10 🤩
📸 @austinryanphoto“

“Lived in Toga my whole life and only just ordered from West Ave tonight and they have the best tenders and hands down the best ranch i have ever had 😳🤤 Honestly you should sell that in bottles if its homemade! The West Ave Sampler is perfect to share for 2!“

“We had a party of four. The staff was very accomodating, assisting one of our party who was using a walker. Appetizer and drinks were promptly served. Our meals arrived piping hot and after the appetizer was finished. The waitress was young and a bit inexperienced but she did well, remembering who had ordered what. We were very pleased with our experience and will be back again.“

“I have been coming here for 25 years. My favorite is Antipasto and a Pepperoni Pizza, calzones. Always fresh, hot. Sometimes there is extra grease so make sure to have extra napkins. Owners are very nice and welcoming. There are a couple of booths to sit at. My order is always ready in 20 minutes. Always a good experience for me. Recommend.

Parking: The pizza shop is in a type of strip mall with a huge free parking lot. So plenty of spots.“

“the hot delivery driver who wore shorts all winter.“

“Kinda feel.lile your grabbing your pizza out of the oven... By this I mean there is no enthusiasm no care. It's very quiet and just like yup got my pizza. Idk maybe I'm expecting to much. And where the heck is everyone anyway. We wait forever sometimes to see an employee.“

“We're new to the area. We were looking for something different. This place is absolutely phenomenal. My son is lactose intolerant the wonderful woman behind the counter made sure that his burrito was completely dairy free. The food tasted so so good. I highly recommend this place, I know we will be back soon.“

“Best Egg Sandwich in town!“

“Stopped in for drinks, great bar selection Ordered the tuna tartare, beet salad and French fries. All exceeded expectations. So delicious and generous sized portions. Wish we were staying in town longer so we could return.“

“Great service very helpful and polite!!!“

“Food was delicious and delivery was fast! Super impressed!“

“They have a new pizza maker he is very good and the pizza speaks for itself“

“these guys are amazing 2025 crew!!!!!! Dallas, the only one who ever answers the phone there is amazing and the food is unbelievably fast and top notch, quality, fresh food. I say everyone deserves a raise! lol no I don't know a single worker I just order weekly. and this year has been your best so whoever is on your staff you best keep them. $20 tip on my order tonight 😘“

“Kiera was so friendly! My boyfriend and I came from the Albany Blaze after cancelling our order with them since our wait would've been an hour past our online orders estimated time. Since I was grumpy leaving Albany Blaze, I wanted to treat myself to my first s'mores pie. Kiera saw I was sad by the lack of smore they had available, and even though I said it was okay, she made me a fresh smore pie because I looked sad ? I was beyond thankful for her kindness tonight, and I look forward to seeing her for my weekly pizza Fridays“

“Great service and very friendly. Pizza and cannoli were excellent.“

“Super nice, speedy, and yummy food!“

“Love love love the Mango Solomon Sushi Roll….DELICIOUS.“

“Exceptional restaurant and staff. My husband and I are regulars. Amazing bar staff that treats us like family! Outstanding food and service!“

“We just moved to this area and have already been here a few times. We cannot recommend it enough! The food and service are top notch!“

“Awesome, best place to be in Saratoga“

“Great service and food thank you - Granddaughter loved it and our server was wonderful with her (Roberta) very helpful“

“Best doughnut I’ve ever tasted 10/10 would try again. Super soft“