39 Best American Restaurants near Tomkins Cove

“Brunch was not as extensive as it used to be but food was still as delicious and satisfying. Staff was wonderful and accommodating. They went out of their way to make sure we were ok with gluten free options and pasty chef even created a special GF pistachio crusted cheesecake that was so delicious! Thank you!“

“I don't usually write reviews on Google but I feel compelled to write in support of Lisa, Dan and The Tasty Table. My husband and I are frequent weekend guests at The Tasty Table because we like the food and the way we are treated as guests. I've noticed some less than positive reviews focused on difficulties getting a table during their busiest weekend times. This should indicate to all who are interested in going to The Tasty Table of how wonderful a restaurant it is. My suggestion is to take advantage of the 30 minute call aheads that are offered. You won't be disappointed!“

“I'm a local and I've been here a few times because of how picky my daughter is, but the quesadillas are her favorites.Today I tried the fish bowl that has cilantro rice and I loved it.The staff is very friendly and the guys who prepare the food are very cool. ?“

“This place is amazing! We had 25 people coming from an Army game and called to see if they could take us all in an hour- they said yes and we are so glad they did! Servers Michael and Justin were incredible! We walked in, tables were set, water glasses filled and menus ready. They handled separate bills with ease, drink orders, soups, appetizers, meals and desserts with amazing customer service- and the food was a home run!! True comfort food with a flare! The Schwing burgers & Mac/cheese, deviled egg appetizers and skillet cookie were just a few of our favs! The list of beers on tap was long and something for everyone’s tastebuds for sure! We will all be back!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“WOWThis was a huge surprise. I was visiting a customer in Peekskill New York, and pulled over to grab a small bite to eat from a food truck. I pulled into the lot and noticed there was a big line. When I got on line there were a lot of regulars talking about what they were going to order. I asked one of them what they would recommend, and they said you cannot go wrong with anything on the menu. They were so right.I got an order of taco's. You got to pick any three taco's you wanted. and the order came with hand cut fries, and this amazing lime aioli. I had a chorizo, fish, and chicken taco. They might have been the best I ever had. After I finished I had to tell the owner how great the food was. He happened to be the nicest guy, and was truly happy to hear that I thoroughly enjoyed his food. He makes all of his food fresh daily, and makes his own chorizo.I went home that night, and told my son about the truck. That weekend I stopped by again, this time with my son and his fiance. Octavio remembered me right away. We ordered a braised short rib grill cheese on Texas toast, a Cuban sandwich that he made with his own smoked pulled pork, and his home made empanada's. All three of us were amazed with his food.My son was getting married in three weeks, and we had rented an Airbnb for the weekend, and were throwing a rehearsal dinner for about 40 people the night before the wedding. We had already planned on having it catered, but my son mentioned why don't we do something different, and see if Octavio would bring his food truck to the Airbnb instead of using a caterer. It wound up being fantastic. We spoke with Octavio, and picked five items off the menu to serve that night. Everyone at the party raved about the food, and Octavio surprised us at the end by serving his home made caramel stuffed churro's with chocolate sauce.If you love great food, you must give him a visit...“

“It was a beautiful Friday evening just at the beginning of the anticipated "happy hour". Walking into Peekskill public you get an immediate nostalgia for Dublin, Ireland, it's a cool feeling.U guys got wings? Yes some of the best, the friendly bartender said and of course they'll all say that.With a good selection of cold NA beers, was happy to have 2 before being handed a plate of wings (buffalo), a perfect mix of drums and flats. Wow, is all I can say, and also look forward to going back.If you're in the area this spot is a must go. Little nightcap with some billiards and friendly crowd to shoot it with. Cheers“

“Great people - terrific food! I had the grilled mahi-mahi with tropical salsa - excellent!“

“My wife and I visited this spring before it opened. They were painting inside, but Sarah, the manager, invited us in and gave us a tour of this beautiful historic building. In the five or six times we've dined there since, Sarah greets us with a hug like old friends and fits us in no matter the hour or crowd. The food is excellent, the menu vegan/gluten and dairy-free friendly, the service top notch. There's even a ghost. Alexa served my birthday dinner for nine yesterday (which Sarah arranged despite over-abundant holiday reservations). Thanks to her and Alexa - who's charming, efficient, and knowledgable on every dish - it went flawlessly. My guests, no strangers to world-class dining, were blown away. The Bird & Bottle is wonderful, but Sarah's special touch with the guests and staff elevates it to something truly extraordinary.“

“We had a wonderful experience and meal. Fresh food. Great wait staff and friendly.“

“I ordered the porchetta sandwich. It looked better than it tasted. The ciabatta was not a true ciabatta and did not go with the sandwich. The porchetta was just crisped up pork belly and was skimpy on the portion considering the price of the sandwich. The waitress said I can substitute the fries for any of the sides but didn't state there would be an upcharge. There was tiny fine print under the sandwiches that says they'll be an upcharge but it's very easy to overlook. I opted for the warm cabbage side which was very tasty and would order again.My friend ordered the beet salad and that looked amazing. I'd suggest trying that and if I go again I'll order that instead.Lastly, the water glass had lipstick on it. I wasn't wearing any. When I asked for a fresh and clean water glass, there was no acknowledgement about the lipstick, even after I pointed it out. That was unprofessional, in my opinion as a former waitress and bartender.Overall, will I go back? Eventually, yes but it's towards the bottom of the list of things to do.“

“I had my daughter-in-law‘s shower here, and everybody still talks about it three years later! We had it in the restaurant part, as long as you have 50 people or more, you can have the Champagne Brunch. We had about 80! It was one of the best showers ever! UNLIMITED mimosas and champagne, and the buffet goes from breakfast foods, all the way into lunch foods! Everything imaginable from baked ziti, Penne vodka, fresh shrimp, eggplant parm, chicken parm, AND the owner/Chef himself was slicing up fresh Prime Rib!!! The service was impeccable! They treated us like royalty! Very attentive and efficient and also sweet. Evan really works with you and your Budget to achieve one of the best celebrations you can imagine! We ALSO go there for dinner, and always have the NY strip steak smothered with onions, peppers, and fried potatoes. It’s absolutely amazing! We recently booked a dinner party in the main dining roomfor my husband’s 60th birthday! I’m sure it will be fabulous!“

“Great Place,Great Food,Very Friendly people working, Been there 3 times in two weeks and have had nothing but good things to say. Thanks for a great experience“

“Delighted that we finally gave this a try with some 'foodie' friends. This was a very pleasant surprise. The service was friendly and excellent. When we asked about two of the Portuguese wines on the wine list. The waitress brought us a sample of each to help us decide. Just that deserves an extra star for service We had two appetizers: the lobster tostones and a special bacalhau. They we both delicious. We tried three of the entrees on the menu. The risotto with lobster had nice chunks of lobster on an al dente risotto with gruyere, the crab cakes with a small salad and the fish and chips. All three of the entrees were done very well. We all agreed we will be again!“

“Great staff great food and great atmosphere ! New location !“

“Great food , amazing service!“

“This was our seventh time celebrating Thanksgiving here and we were so happy to be here! Genera was our server and she was wonderful and kind. Dad is a Marine living at The VA Nursing Home at Montrose and this is his favorite place because they always treat him well and the food is delicious. George and his team make it look easy though you can taste the effort and love the team puts into every meal. I highly recommend eating here. GO!“

“Incredible food and service is beyond expectations. What a total hidden gem.“

“We had a fabulous evening … the shepherds pie was perfect and we could not have asked more from the staff .., attentive, professional, prompt and so very friendly !!! Great night !!!“

“Absolutely excellent dinner location for Thanksgiving. Authentic Revolutionary War Era Inn setting with phenomenal dinner menu for Thanksgiving. 4 of us came here for Thanksgiving- my wife, me and her parents, we all got something different and this place did not disappoint on anything. The chateubriand filet mignon and New Zealand rack of lamb were on point in every way. The side vegetables- the sweet potatoes, the stuffing, the arugula, the green beans, and the carrots were all perfectly cooked to an optimome composition and coloring. The popovers were a nice throwback a little dry but the strawberry butter more than made up for them. The dessert the Belgian chocolate mousse was impeccable. The overall ambiance and atmosphere of this place was very Yankee in a great way, it reminded me of Olde New England Inns and Taverns. Pricing wise it was not the most economical menu but doing Thanksgiving at home with guests wouldn’t have been cheaper. I definitely recommend anyone slightly interested in a place like this come here as they will fully enjoy. We did not reside here but if their hotel accommodations are on par with their dining accommodations, you will get what you pay for and then some.“

“The food here is absolutely delicious! “Hands down, the best schwarma I’ve had since visiting Isreal. Real fresh ingredients. Not only is the food exquisite, but the portions are also incredibly generous, ensuring you leave fully satisfied!“

“Firehouse Grille, oh what a thrill! With beer towers high, and wings that thrill, Fireman's ice tea, a blaze of delight, In the heart of New York, a beacon at night. Burgers so juicy, they'll make you cheer, Flames of flavor, from far and near. Sip on brews tall, reaching for the stars, In this culinary inferno, where taste buds spar. With each bite and sip, a fiery dance, At Firehouse Grille, take a chance. So if you seek a culinary spree, Come to Firehouse Grille, where taste runs free!“

“Pastel's has been a part of Peekskill for as long as some of its landmarks. It's a great little Diner that brings together friends and family for good food and conversation.It's small and quaint. It has a vibe that makes you want to come back over and over. Just makes you feel at home.“

“Bella Vita Authentic Italian Deli is absolutely fantastic! The Italian Wedding Soup is outstanding and a fair price. Cookies, candies, and pastries are fresh and delicious! Huge selection of pasta’s, spices, meats, a fun Italian foods. Highly recommend!“

“Went here with my Mom and Sister for Mother's Day. Never been before. The food was out of site! Everything we ordered was incredible. Service was great. Everyone was kind, attentive, and accommodating. We sat outside and enjoyed watching ppl prep their boats for the season. Such a nice ambience. Definitely recommend.“

“Such a nice ambiance in the bar area. Got the Chicken Taco's which was very good & Cosmo was also very good. My husband got a burger which he enjoyed. Service was pretty good too! Will come back!“

“What a gem, of a place, definitely a keeper to revisit. My husband and I went with friends last night (Friday) we had a great time, everyone was friendly; very welcoming, music was great. The food was absolutely delicious, Ben, Jay thank you for your hospitality, we will be back soon.“

“The service is on point and the food is excellent. Unless you are riding a motorcycle, parking is almost non existent. That said, I rated it a four for atmosphere because it is a biker bar with a restaurant and that is honestly not my thing. If you are a bike fan, you would likely rate this place a five.Parking: Motorcycles have a reserved parking area, cars are on their own to find street side parking.“

“A small cafe that serves the newly built water front development. There is only few tables inside, but a nice outdoor seating area. We were pleasantly surprised by stumble upon this place by searching Google. The food was fantastic, we ordered a salmon dish which was cooked to perfection and a nice cheese burger with sweet potato fries. The portions were abundant, tasted delicious and reasonably priced. We really enjoyed it!“

“We are at The Burger Loft on a Friday night. it was very busy, but the service was good and the food was outstanding!“

“I absolutely love Shannon and Anna, they always provide fantastic service. The managers Will and Carl provide excellent customer care. I bring my autistic 2 year old nephew, he’s very limited with the foods he eats and they are amazing at ensuring he has what he needs. I feel like family when we’re there!“

“delicious food............“

“I have been here multiple times and everytime the food and service are excellent. This time it was for breakfast with the Easter bunny. It was a perfectly executed passed brunch. With all the kids it was nice not to have to wait in a buffet line.“

“Just tried Richie's for the first time while staying in Bear Mountain area. Brought my mom visiting from Europe, and we were both impressed! The prime rib roast and lamb chops were so tasty and tender. The service was super friendly and polite. The old-school restaurant vibe and decor added to the charm. We loved it and definitely recommend it. Excited to go back next time I'm in town!“

“Great food and atmosphere. Owners and staff are wonderful.“

“We love most everything….especially Frank’s chicken salad“

“I love Beni's! Their sauce is very similar to my mother's. I love to take my grandchildren to eat there. Their pizzettas are delicious! It's just a great place to go have a nice Italian meal with a glass of wine in a very comfortable atmosphere. I'm sure you'll enjoy what they have to offer.“

“I took my daughters there for a 7 year old birthday party. It was cool for the kids, and the pizza was good. I would have liked some more game options, especially since they have a sports bar section for adults. They also have an axe throwing setup as well. Part of this place is under renovation. I would definitely go back for an adult night out after renovations are complete. Looks like it may be even more fun.“

“A cool local bar. our waiter/bartender was so sweet ? wish I could remember her name. We had mozzarella sticks, dirty tater tots, and teriyaki garlic wings. Portions were big ! Flavor on point. We had Jack and cokes that were perfect ! May not look like anything when you walk in, but don't judge a book by its cover! I almost did, and I'm glad I didn't. The tables had all New york sports teams. Sorry, I missed that because I would have picked the Knicks one, lol. Thank you for a great time and great bar food.“

“Very interesting menu, the four of us ate different things and we all loved everything! The asian food was delicious and different from typical Japanese restaurants. Oysters were fresh, clean and delicious. Definitely going back there when we have Paramount Theatre tickets!“