50 Best Sandwich Shops near Tuckahoe

“The absolute best Subway experience, from the food to the service there’s no corners cut. I’m greeted with smiles every time I enter and it brightens my day. This Subway is the absolute top line, crème de la crème if you’re ever nearby don’t be afraid to take a step in to experience what a Subway should be.“

“Stopped in tonight, not very crowded which was great and the food was served super quickly. Loved every bite!

The highlight of the night was Lourdes the cashier/ attendant. She was so friendly and welcoming and attentive. She was able to recommend things on the menu and elaborate on the options.

While I was eating she kept checking in on me and my guest and walking around cleaning surfaces and tidying up the space. Amazing customer service from her. Would absolutely recommend this place and I hope anyone that stops in gets to meet Lourdes.“

“Drove by this spot a couple of times and was intrigued by their decor. Decided today I was going to try it and I was really happy with the atmosphere and the sandwich was excellent! I had the “Lady Lover” cuz you know… I loved it!“

“First time but not the last. Hope they don’t run out of chicken cutlet next time“

“First time visiting and I will definitely be back when I come back to Harrison!“

“The House Beef was the best roast beef ever! The food always exceeds my expectations! Thank you! 5 Stars!“

“Great customer service! Tell Missy we said Hi.“

“Chicken Curry soup is 🔥..“

“Had them for my first time today. Amazing!!!“

“PROS: I had a great experience add Jersey Mike's. It was very quiet and calm workers were super helpful and overall it was a really chill and easy experience. The sandwiches were very fresh including the vegetables inside. The atmosphere inside it was great, there were many nice posters along the walls and it is in general very clean on the tables. It's usually quiet inside and I would recommend eating there even though you can definitely take your sandwich outside as it is comfortable to eat it on-the-go. When I went, my friend was vegetarian and it was a great experience for him as the workers were very accommodating to his dietary needs. A+ for that!

CONS: The sandwiches did get a little soggy after a few minutes, however it was fine as you can eat it pretty quickly. While sitting outside is sometimes available, it doesn't feel right. There are very few chairs and it feels a bit out of place. Perhaps if they added more chairs and maybe some umbrellas it would be a lot more comfortable to eat outside.“

“Excellent salad bar and cold food section. Vast selection of beverages, chips and snacks. Hot and cold roll or hero sandwiches made to order, as well as hot food dishes. Staff isn't very friendly, but they are efficient. The deli is next to a medical office building, so parking is tough.

Vegetarian options: Excellent salad bar options.“

“yum yum....nom nom.... two tries. two salads. both awesome. i'll be back again and again :)))“

“Their sandwiches are outstanding. Also great fries! Very friendly staff.“

“Delicious delicious 😋 food“

“Nice and friendly atmosphere and I recommend The Jibarito with Steak on fried Plantain..it’s my Fav!“

“In the area at hair salon, stopped by eggy 8 for early. Afternoon eggs. We sat outside, nice day. I ordered veggie omelet, loaded with veggies, asparagus, spinach, zucchini, green beans & goat cheese. Buttered rye toast & coffee & water. Food was fresh & delicious. Service was quick & pleasant. Another plus for me in any resturant is a clean restroom. This one was immaculate! Will go back“

“The presentation transforms good food into something special. Their kitchen delivers excellence and their team always shows care. The staff displays sincere hospitality. The positive facial expressions create a pleasant environment. I've stated the essentials.“

“Pruzzo's is AWESOME!!! The food is fresh and delicious, the delivery is fast, everyone is always friendly!“

“Mr Jarmar R Williams an employee there excellent customer service to us.My partner & myself frequent Jersey Mikes in Fort Lee NJ & Mr.Jamar addressed our issues immediatey.My personal opinion he def needs to manage that particular store his customer service is ova the top..💪“

“Very good Philly Cheese 🧀 Steaks 🥩.“

“The best! They brought back the Landy Sandwich and it’s addicting!🤤“

“I can't believe I'm reviewing a Subway, but I have to, because this place is the fastest, friendliest Subway in New York City. Normally I do not expect great service from any fast food place, especially in this city, but this place blows me away every single time for just being decent human beings and not slow and for making me feel welcome. Great work, guys!“

“This deli functions and operates beautifully 😍 I love coming in here the employees are great from the deli guys to the counter guys THEY ARE ALL GREAT,NICE SERVICES AND NICE EXPERIENCE...“

“Everything I have ordered from there is always delicious the grilled chicken salad especially it's the best I've ever had!“

“Had a really great experience at Subway! The staff was super nice, and the place was clean, which is always a plus. Service was quick too, didn’t have to wait long at all. My sandwich was fresh and made just the way I like it—tasted so good. They’ve got a ton of options too, so there’s pretty much something for everyone. Definitely coming back here again!“

“Emmanuel and his staff are the pinnacle of excellence. Always polite and respectful, energy is always positive, and they treat their customers like human beings. They don’t seem bothered to be there and they’re glad you stopped by. In repetitive conversation (that comes along with multiple visits), you see they are exceptional human beings. The service is top notch and the food is great, always fresh. Clean store too. If this location isn’t his/theirs, I hope they franchise their own location soon. They deserve that and more.“

“Coming to this local eatery made me feel like home. They serve the best pastries in the community and customer service was so warm. I appreciate the time it took to handle my order. The croissant, donut, and coffee rolls were in good quality in look and taste. I appreciate staying for a while to enjoy the environment of Blimpie. Thank you guys for having me over.

Vegetarian options: Most pastries here are vegan friendly. Enjoy the sweet and savory donuts, croissants and coffee buns while at Blimpie.“

“I brought 2 blimpies best sandwiches. I was so happy when I realized there is a blimpies 2 minutes from Montefiore hospital. I haven't had my favorite sandwich in years. Blimpies seems to be housed in other stores. Before this time, I found it in a twin donut on 161st and it was 16 dollars. The one on Gunhill and Bainbridge Avenue is in a store named Tasty Picks and was the normal 13 dollars.“

“I was apprehensive what I saw that it had 3.8 Stars. But I was presently surprised this is actually a very nice Subway the guy working at the counter was very friendly and they had everything we wanted. The food is good the service is good only thing I can complain about is it doesn't have a restroom but honestly with that small of a space I wouldn't expect it to have a restroom“

“great food“

“Wow, if you want some late night Halal that is super fresh, this is it! Don't be confused by the restaurant name and the food I got. This place sells sandwiches as well as Halal, it's a dual spot called Blimpie & The Gyro King. I got chicken over rice on three different occasions, and each time, it was so fresh (cilantro makes it bomb), service was super friendly, and it was prepared so quickly. When I'm up there again, I'll be back!“

“Amsterdam Gourmet is wonderful! I've stayed across the street from it 17 nights in the last year, and I am well supplied with all kinds of deli food, fresh fruits, milk, yogurt, etc. Extra special. Can eat at a counter there, or take out.“

“Delicious Jalapeño Cheese Steak Wish there would be indoor seating. I had to eat in my car.“

“This is far and away my favorite location. The entire staff is always so nice and efficient and their sandwiches actually look like the picture and the ingredients are always the freshest. I live a couple of blocks away from the subway on East Tremont, but this is totally worth the drive. I come here every time. Thank you for always making my lunch perfect!“

“This store is located next to the 6 train. Morrison/Soundview stop. They are open twenty-four hours. Their cold and hot sandwiches are very good. The store is clean. Especially the grill area. When I go back, I'll snap a picture of the menu. They have Lotto, too.“

“This subway is the best subway I have ever been to in New York. You got to come to this one. Its clean and the manager Micheal is the best. He makes your sandwiches just like you asked him to or want it to be. Fresh food and no complaining from them if you ask to add more to your sandwiches like the other subways do that are stingy. Enjoy ???“

“I’m a delivery guy. Piking stuff from DD.
I don’t know about food quality.
But two guys who work there always nice with me. Orders always ready for pick up, drinks always fixed in the cart box.
Pick up counter always clean.
Sometimes I’m using a restroom (I’m sorry): it’s always clean.
I think, guys taking care of the place.
Maybe sometimes they are looking tired.
But they are hard workers.
Please be patient with your orders.
Thank you.“

“I love this spot because not only because the food is accurate every time (and yummy) but because of the workers there. They are so nice!!! I would have given 5 stars but they do not open at 830am like this says(or their door) they always seem to open by 10am. No complaints just would like that to be updated if its not accurate. Please update the sign, its clearly causing people to get mad in your reviews and is affecting your rating.

Vegetarian options: Very minimum though“

“Went to this location with my partner today to grab a bit to eat and was welcomed by a huge smile by Tony! He was so professional and friendly! The store was so clean too! Would highly recommend this location the most! Thanks Tony for making our day!“

“This place is an awesome and convenience spot and that has great hours. I believe they are 6 or 7:00 a.m. until midnight which is rare these days. And being that my boat is in a marina right down the block it is a truly wonderful place to have. The store is extremely clean. The food is fresh. The beverage selections are great and they even carry ice. What more can you ask for“

“Good music and polite staff. Food is mid, but hey it is open after the caf closes, and accepts dining dollars. I think they serve coffee and tea, good alternative to starbucks. I would have rated it lower but compared to what else is available here its arguably the better choice.“

“Went in yesterday for a flbogo Eli manning deal . The subway sandwich artist was kind . Had the food ready and got a nice deal on 2 foot long subs . Only 16 dollars . Over all pleased with the hole transaction . Must of changed since the issues posted about in the past . Nice to see :) always enjoyed a subway until the advertising fiasco of the past ?“

“I recently visited the Subway restaurant and had an outstanding experience! The food was fresh, delicious, and made to perfection. But what truly stood out was the exceptional service provided by Litonur Rashid. He was attentive, friendly, and went above and beyond to ensure I had a great experience.

Litu's dedication to his work and passion for delivering top-notch service is truly commendable. He took the time to understand my order, offered recommendations, and made sure everything was to my liking. His positive attitude and warm smile made me feel valued as a customer.

The restaurant's cleanliness, ambiance, and overall quality of food were also impressive. However, it was Litu's exceptional service that made my visit truly memorable.

Kudos to Litunur Rashid and the entire Subway team for a job well done! I highly recommend this location to anyone looking for a great dining experience.

Keep up the fantastic work, Litu! You're an asset to the team!“

“A Standout Subway— Clean, Friendly, and Truly Welcoming!
This Subway truly sets the bar high! From the moment you walk in, you can feel the difference. The store is spotless, the team is welcoming, and everything runs smoothly — even during busy hours.

The sandwiches are always fresh, and you can really taste the quality in every bite. I’ve been to many Subways, but this one consistently delivers the best experience. The staff are fast, polite, and genuinely care about getting your order right.

What makes this place even better is how thoughtful it is for everyone — it’s fully wheelchair accessible, and very kid-friendly too. There’s plenty of room to move around, and the layout is super comfortable whether you’re coming in solo, with kids, or with mobility needs.

If you’re looking for a clean, reliable, and welcoming Subway that goes above and beyond — this is the one. A hidden gem that deserves to be at the top!“

“Great sandwiches or subs exactly how you want them, great selection and very fresh and very tasty, nice coffee and very friendly professional curtious staff working here, enjoyed my sandwiche/sub and left a happy customer, place was very clean and very busy the day I was in the place.Good location.“

“Right when I walked the staff greeted me with a smile and helped me out right away. What amazing customer service. Made my sandwich with amazing high quality ingredients the perfect way. The store inside out was spotless and I definitely will be coming back“