19 Best American Restaurants near Wading River

North Tavern American • $$
2028 N Country Rd, Wading River

Customers` Favorites

Cuban Sandwich

“From service to presentation to flavor, North Tavern is absolutely wonderful. The Italian Toast appetizer is a great way to start the meal for a salad/bread plate beginning. The Fish Tasting had beautiful presentation and the flavor was phenomenal! Rounding the dinner off with a warm brownie recommended by our server was the way to go! Thank you to the owners, server, and especially to the chefs; my family and I talked about the meal on the way home… until it was too much and then had the change the subject. ?“

4.6 Superb57 Reviews
The Rock Golf Club Bar • $$$
141 Fairway Dr, Wading River

“We recently ate at the new Italian restaurant named Pulcinella at the rock golf club. We went for our 35th wedding anniversary and we are so glad we did. The decor, the service, and especially the meal were all superb. The portions were large and the prices were high average but well worth it. If you are looking for a great meal in a beautiful setting this is the restaurant you want to try. Reservations suggested.“

4.7 Superb12 Reviews
La Plage French • $$$
131 Creek Rd, Wading River

Customers` Favorites

Slow Braised Pork Osso Buco
Pan Seared Branzino
Pan Seared Fluke
Sweet Corn Puree
Blueberry Crumble
Sweet Corn Soup
Duck Leg Confit
Lobster Ravioli
Dessert Trio
Pei Mussels

“Amazing amazing amazing! Me and my wife come here for special occasions, our anniversary, her 40th birthday, and it is worth every single penny and then even more! The food is absolutely to die for, every bite is balanced and seasoned to absolute perfection. We've never been to a place that's done it more right than La Plage.Mufasa was not only an incredibly attentive, kind and knowledgeable waiter, he was a somerlier to boot! Can't wait to come back!“

4.3 Superb94 Reviews

4
Phil's

Phil's Bar & Grill • $$
1856 Wading River Manor Rd, Wading River

Customers` Favorites

French Onion Soup
Smothered Burger
Buffalo Wings
Chicken Wings
Steamed Clams
Sauerbrotten
Burgers
Ribs

“Phil's was pretty nice. It's a decent sized place, the food was great. The waitress was forgetful,to the point she even forgot a whole order of ours. The kitchen had to rush making it so it wasn't exactly what we ordered but didn't want to send it back. Other little things were forgotten and had to be reminded of. The place wasn't too busy but maybe she was new. I understand being frazzled so it's no biggie. I will come back again and you should as well is worth a try like I said the food was very good.“

4 Good87 Reviews
Desmond's Restaurant & Pub New American • $$
5720 NY-25A, Wading River

Customers` Favorites

Poached Pear and Brie Sandwich with Shoe String Fries
Baked Stuffed Clams
Chicken Pot Pie
Shrimp Cocktail
Pear Panini
Baked Clams

“One of the few local places that has a true happy hour! Discounted drinks and bar menu. Tracy at the bar is amazing! Friendly, always attentive and quite the mixologist! They have live music too close to the weekend. Nice size bar. But even if it's packed there's plenty of tables in bar area you can sit at. Love their wood fired pizza! One of my favorite local spots to catch up with friends and have some drinks!“

3.6 Good48 Reviews
Wings Cafe Cafe • $
135 Dawn Dr, Shirley - 9.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

2 Eggs Any Style
Cinnamon Roll
Home Fries
Pancakes
Burgers
Toast

“A charming, well-run restaurant that we are lucky to have in our town. Operated by wonderful people who make fabulous food. I can’t believe I waited so long to check it out. My father and I will be frequenting Wings Cafe for a long time to come.“

4.9 Superb65 Reviews
Maggie's eatery American • $$
465 NY-25A, Miller Place - 7.41 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Chicken Bowl
Chicken Milanese
Fried Fluke Gyro
Steak Sandwich
Avocado Toast
Arugula Salad
Shrimp Tacos
French Fries
Greek Salad
Salmon Bowl

“At this point we’ve had 5 different orders. And all are awesome.Greek salad (x3 because it’s that good compared to anything else nearby… even all the Greek spots).Fish and chips (best I’ve had in quite a while, it’s a must try)Shrimp taco'sSteak bowlThe burgerWould recommend each of these!“

4.8 Superb75 Reviews
Cooperage Inn American • $$
2218 Sound Ave, Baiting Hollow - 4.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

Rosemary & Garlic Marinated Rack of Lamb
Jumbo Shrimp & Chicken Francaise
French Onion Soup Du Jour
Braised Short Rib Pot Pie
Overstuffed Baked Clams
Broiled Seafood Medley
Coconut Cream Pie
Chicken Pot Pie
Eggplant Fries
Seafood Bisque

“Had a great time, love the restaurant, but the grilled chicken was over cooked this time, required a steak knife to cut through, it is usually tender, perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection. With that said, a great restaurant, highly recommend it!“

4.5 Superb364 Reviews
JC's Restaurant Manorville Family • $$
2 Country Club Dr, Manorville - 7.9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Jumbo Pretzel with Honey Mustard Dip
Bacon Cheeseburger w Fries
Baked Clam Fritters
French Onion Soup
Marinated Burger
Mac and Cheese
Shrimp Tacos
Ahi Tuna
JC

“We spent valentines at one of our favorite local places yesterday, it was really busy our reservation was at 7 the height of dinner rush. We enjoyed every aspect of JC’s from the hostess to the servers to the much needed delicious dinner and ambiance! We started with chicken nachos and garlic bread, main course we had Norwegian lamb chops on a mountain of potatoes yum! I ordered the panko chicken with baby rigatonis peas buratta in a sherry sauce and what a trip to flavor town! The food here never disappoints even when we order takeout it’s always delicious. We had the pleasure of meeting the owner what a lovely hard working lady! All that she does to provide the best experience shines bright through her staff and patrons. We tested out little cheese cakes that were outrageous I don’t even like cheesecake and I ate them at first not knowing what they were. they were creamy and yummy and delicious I didn’t know I could like something so much that I didn’t like anywhere else. The strawberry was Huge and I ate every last bit we were stuffed I had to take home almost half of my dinner which we ate today! Jcs you do a exemplary service to our town thank you for a wonderful night, my pictures don’t do your food justice but I’m posting them anyway lol!“

4.6 Superb68 Reviews
Jimmy's Diner Diner • $
1535 Montauk Hwy, Mastic - 9.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Toast with Bacon Sausage
Eggs Benedict with Home Fries
Silver Dollar Pancakes
Cheeseburger Deluxe
Biscuits & Gravy
Eggs Any Style
Meat

“Jimmy's is the best possible version of a solid, regular, old fashioned diner. The staff here is so incredibly nice, accommodating, and competent. We had a large group come in for brunch for my aunt's birthday. Despite the size, Jimmy's said it'd be no problem as long as we didn't mind waiting a little for a few tables to clear out. They managed to take all of our orders and get us food shockingly quickly.The food itself was all well prepared and delicious. If you are looking for a nice diner to stop by for breakfast or lunch, I could not recommend Jimmy's more. I hope I am in the area again so I can come back for another meal“

4.7 Superb42 Reviews
Athens Diner Diner • $$
837 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island - 6.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hot Open Roast Beef with Brown Gravy
Quesadilla with Fries
Corned Beef Hash
Greek Salad
Chef

“We have eaten in the Athens Diner a number of times, for breakfast, this time lunch. It is clean, the staff are happy to serve, the food is delicious and served attractively. I had a roast beef on whole wheat bread, so good! Thank you so much! Oh! Parking has always been esay!“

4.6 Superb58 Reviews
Tony’s on the boulevard Italian • $
175 Sound Beach Blvd, Sound Beach - 6.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Meatball Parmigiana Sub
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Parmigiana
Broccoli Pizza
Grandma Pizza
Tiramisu
Lasagne
Pie

“Food was fantastic! We wanted something different and decided to check this local place out. The wings were fresh and crispy with amazing sauce. Fresh bread with dinner. Our main dishes were shrimp parm, chicken Marsala, and penne ala vodka. All of those dishes were phenomenal. After, we ordered some freshly made desserts. Every part of the meal was amazing. Definitely will return!“

4.5 Superb64 Reviews
Papa Juan Deli Deli • $$
451 Rte 25A Store #12, Miller Place - 7.44 miles

“This deli is so underrated! I can’t believe I’ve been so close the whole time and never heard of it! I decided to try after craving a gyro and was so impressed. I also ordered the bean and cheese pupusas which were fantastic. The spanish food is as authentic as it gets around here. Highly recommend this place!! Will most definitely be coming back.“

4.8 Superb20 Reviews
Millhouse Inn Bar • $$
284 Mill Rd, Yaphank - 8.98 miles

Customers` Favorites

Loaded Seafood Potato Skins
Seafood Fra Diavlo
Chicken Ala Rachel
French Onion Soup
Mill House Salad
Chicken Parmesan
Seafood Platter
Sauerbraten
Sea Scallops
Burger

“Had a great lunch here with a coworker. Views were great and the food was very good. The Thai chili wings and the cob salad, I can attest, are spot on. The only thing keeping this place from five stars with me is the dining room is a bit cramped. Nevertheless, I'll be back with the wife. She'll enjoy it too I'm sure.“

4.5 Superb51 Reviews
Gourmelos Mediterranean Market & Catering Mediterranean • $
99 NY-25A suite 5, Shoreham - 2.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Build a Bowl Spinach Chicken Meatballs Beets Cucumber Salad and Roasted Veggies

“This place is the absolute best!! I cannot rave enough about the food. It's so hard to find, healthy, fresh clean food around here. I LOVE knowing that I can always order food that fits my lifestyle from Gourmels. Not only health but delicious and satisfying. Do yourself a favor and give it a try.Dietary restrictions: I eat a very restrictive diet and I absolutely love the build your own bowl options. Loaded with protein and fresh veggies. Just perfect!“

4.8 Superb19 Reviews
Triangle Pub Pubs • $$
381 Old Montauk Hwy, Eastport - 10.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fully Loaded Steak Tidbits
Battered Mushrooms
Triangle Wings
Onion Rings
Hamburger
Sandwich
Burger
Salads

“If you can get past the extremely loud bar area to the quiet-ish dining room you'll enjoy yourself. The food is okay. Can tell a lot is cooked from frozen pre-made and overcharged but I guess that's business. Fish and chips clearly from frozen. Corn nuggets clearly from frozen. Disappointed in that because these things are not hard to make and I shouldn't really be paying $25 for a few frozen fish sticks.“

4.5 Superb40 Reviews
eat + drink American • $$
Shoreham Plaza, 99 Rte 25A, Shoreham - 2.7 miles

“Eat + Drink in Shoreham is a fantastic dining spot! The atmosphere was great, creating the perfect backdrop for a memorable meal. The food is delicious, and the service is exceptional. Whether it's a special occasion or a casual night out, this place delivers. Five stars all around!“

4.6 Superb24 Reviews
Brewology295 | Speonk Gastropubs • $$
295 Montauk Hwy, Remsenburg-Speonk - 11.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Chicken Burger
Duck Nachos Duck
Truffle Fries
Poutine Fries
Soup de Jour

“Food is good and staff is nice, staff is young don't expect great service in the sense that they know the menu in depth. Friendly and kinda however, and also have a fun trivia night most Wednesdays. Don't buy their ramen though, ramen is my all time favorite food, I get it whenever I can. I live 5 minutes away from this place and never get their ramen cuz it's not very good. Great place for a burger and beer and to just hang out“

4.4 Superb62 Reviews
Drifters Kitchen and Bar American • $$
1600 Middle Country Rd, Ridge - 4.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Short Rib Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Braised Boneless Short Rib
Drifter-A-Rita Flatbread
The Morning After Burger
Everything Pretzel Logs
Drifters Fish Sandwich
Mac & Cheese Balls
Short Rib Poutine
Drifters Nachos
Fish and Chips

“For a vegan, nothing much to choose from without modifying menu options. Servers were polite and ready to help. Music was a bit too loud, but patrons seemed to really enjoy the place.Vegetarian options: Needs expanding and more creativity. So many restaurants now have a Beyond burger, salads without cheese/egg, etc.Kid-friendliness: Kids not offered activity like coloring page/crayons, doesn't seem children-oriented.“

4.3 Superb249 Reviews
Loading...
map Map