25 Best American Restaurants near Shirley

Wings Cafe Cafe • $
135 Dawn Dr, Shirley

Customers` Favorites

2 Eggs Any Style
Cinnamon Roll
Home Fries
Pancakes
Burgers
Toast

“I arrived just after they closed, but they offered to make me a sandwich anyway, I picked the tuna lettus and tomato, asked me if I wanted macaroni or coleslaw since I was driving and honestly am not a fan of either, they let me get a bag of cheetos. the made the sandwich and the Tuna sandwich was amazing! now stop for just a minute and think back the entirety of your life, have you ever heard the phrase the tuna sandwich was amazing? probably not, but this one was great. maybe because it was amazing or maybe i was really hungry, but I think it was both. it was a really good sandwich. the people were nice, and the place had an enjoyable atmosphere, I'll be back for a $100 burger. they aren't $100 it's a pilot's expression. but I will be back.“

4.8 Superb65 Reviews
Applebee's Grill + Bar American • $$
855 Montauk Hwy, Shirley

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Sticks Spinach and Artichoke Dip French Onion Soup
Fresh House Salad with Blue Cheese Dressing
Bourbon Street Chicken and Shrimp
10 Pitcher of Red Apple Sangria
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
Oriental Chicken Salad
Chocolate Lava Cake
Fiesta Lime Chicken
Quesadilla Burger
Nachos and Wings

“Wait time takes forever and it's definitely not worth it, since the service isn't that good either. The servers are fine, but the time you have to wait to get served is outrageous especially when I went (it wasn't empty, but there were barely any customers). Food is alright, not the best but it works out in the end. The prices are alright as well. Even with the complaints I stated above, I'll still be coming back either way“

3.8 Good102 Reviews
Friendly's American • $
940 Montauk Hwy, Shirley

Customers` Favorites

Honey Barbeque Burger and Loaded Waffle Fries
Honey BBQ Chicken Supermelt
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
Candy Blast Monster Shake
Honey BBQ Super Melt
All American Burger
Royal Banana Split
Mozzarella Sticks
Jim Dandy
Sundaes

“Wow Friendlys in Shirley is amazing ... out hostess was so great . She was so quick and moved around like she had skates on . The food was awesome and freshly prepared it was the crispy chicken salad and we are so demanding and she helped us no problem ...with a smile . All the hostess here are great ....“

3.6 Good58 Reviews
Maggie's eatery American • $$
465 NY-25A, Miller Place - 11.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Chicken Bowl
Chicken Milanese
Fried Fluke Gyro
Steak Sandwich
Avocado Toast
Arugula Salad
Shrimp Tacos
French Fries
Greek Salad
Salmon Bowl

“At this point we’ve had 5 different orders. And all are awesome.Greek salad (x3 because it’s that good compared to anything else nearby… even all the Greek spots).Fish and chips (best I’ve had in quite a while, it’s a must try)Shrimp taco'sSteak bowlThe burgerWould recommend each of these!“

4.9 Superb72 Reviews
Chachama Grill American • $$$
655 Montauk Hwy, East Patchogue - 6.75 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pan-Seared Long Island Crescent Farm Duck Breast
Grilled Filet Mignon
Potato and Leak Soup
Warm Rice Pudding
Pan Seared Tuna
Chocolate Cake
Beef Empanadas
Oysters Rubio
Creme Brulee
Lamb Chops

“I cannot say enough good things about this place. Highly recommend! Food is mouthwatering and the ambiance is everything I need during dinner. I am obsessed with the duck. My husband loves the pork and sweet potatoes. Service is always excellent. Don’t think twice just go and you’ll be happy you across this gem of a “

4.7 Superb135 Reviews
Two Morrow's Pub Bar • $$
300 E Main St, Patchogue - 7.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
Swiss Mushroom Burger
Pastrami Sandwich
Chicken Sandwich
Reuben Sandwich
Seafood Bisque
Piggy Platter
Potato Skins
Roast Beef
blt

“First time here with friends on a Sunday , food was fresh and delicious, best wings we have had in a long time , burgers were cooked perfectly and had lots of flavor , our server I can’t remember her name but we absolutely loved her she was fantastic, very nice and very professional with a side of humor ? we had 5 people in our party , our food was hot and we now have a new wing spot nothing touches there wings within a 20 mile radius. Thank you keep up the good work“

4.6 Superb163 Reviews
The Tiki Bar At Sunset Harbour American • $$
90 Colonial Dr, East Patchogue - 7.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Blackened Cowboy Rib Eye
Sesame Seared Tuna Salad
Gorgonzola Walnut Salad
Jumbo Stuffed Shrimp
Twice Baked Potato
Steak and Fries
Shrimp Ceviche
Fried Calamari
Tiki Crab Cake
Chicken Fingers

“Went to The Tiki Bar for my cousins birthday on Saturday. Had an amazing time. Drinks were great, hospitality was spot on. The live music was just an extra layer that made the night even more enjoyable.Tiki bar is great place for good food/drinks, dancing, fun and of course picture perfect spot to see the sunset. Definitely will go back to the Tiki Bar. Loved it so much I had to buy a t-shirt before I left!“

4.6 Superb151 Reviews
JC's Restaurant Mastic American • $$
1086 Mastic Rd, Mastic - 1.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheeseburger and Fries Onion Rings
Chicken Breast Parmigiana
Marinated Steak Sandwich
Cheeseburger Deluxe
Our Signature Wings
Sweet Potato Fries
French Onion Soup
Mozzarella Wedges
Cowboy Burger
Lobstah Roll

“Went to lunch with some old friends. We had a great time catching up. This place is the best. The food is always delicious. My waitress Sue was wonderful. I loved that they ask if we wanted the garnishments (so they aren't wasted and thrown away). Portions were plentiful. My go to place always. Fran at the bar is always a pleasure to see.“

4.7 Superb63 Reviews
Lola’s Southern Cuisine American •
2717a NY-112, Medford - 6.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Baked Macaroni and Cheese
Southern Fried Chicken
B B Q Beef Short Ribs
Fried Chicken Wings
BBQ Wings Combo
Grilled Salmon
Fried Catfish
Candied Yams
Potato Salad
String Beans

“I ordered fried chicken and pulled pork for a family gathering. Their food is delicious, the order was ready on time, and the people that work there are very helpful and nice. I live over 20 miles away from their location, and it’s well worth the extra miles.“

4.5 Superb119 Reviews
JC's Restaurant Manorville Family • $$
2 Country Club Dr, Manorville - 3.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Jumbo Pretzel with Honey Mustard Dip
Bacon Cheeseburger w Fries
Baked Clam Fritters
French Onion Soup
Marinated Burger
Mac and Cheese
Shrimp Tacos
Ahi Tuna
JC

“We spent valentines at one of our favorite local places yesterday, it was really busy our reservation was at 7 the height of dinner rush. We enjoyed every aspect of JC’s from the hostess to the servers to the much needed delicious dinner and ambiance! We started with chicken nachos and garlic bread, main course we had Norwegian lamb chops on a mountain of potatoes yum! I ordered the panko chicken with baby rigatonis peas buratta in a sherry sauce and what a trip to flavor town! The food here never disappoints even when we order takeout it’s always delicious. We had the pleasure of meeting the owner what a lovely hard working lady! All that she does to provide the best experience shines bright through her staff and patrons. We tested out little cheese cakes that were outrageous I don’t even like cheesecake and I ate them at first not knowing what they were. they were creamy and yummy and delicious I didn’t know I could like something so much that I didn’t like anywhere else. The strawberry was Huge and I ate every last bit we were stuffed I had to take home almost half of my dinner which we ate today! Jcs you do a exemplary service to our town thank you for a wonderful night, my pictures don’t do your food justice but I’m posting them anyway lol!“

4.6 Superb68 Reviews
Peter's Luncheonette American • $$
409 E Main St, Patchogue - 7.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Onion Soup
Steak Sandwich
Grilled Chicken
Cuban Sandwich
Mashed Potato
Fried Chicken
blt Sandwich
Eggs Benedict
Classic Gyro
Tuna Salad

“Peter’s is our new place for breakfast when we go out. We used to go to the place down the road but the staff at Peters is so warm and welcoming! Our breakfast always comes out quick is plentiful and reasonably priced. Peter’s will be our place from now on, you won’t be disappointed !“

4.6 Superb66 Reviews
Jimmy's Diner Diner • $
1535 Montauk Hwy, Mastic - 1.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Toast with Bacon Sausage
Eggs Benedict with Home Fries
Silver Dollar Pancakes
Cheeseburger Deluxe
Biscuits & Gravy
Eggs Any Style
Meat

“Jimmy's is the best possible version of a solid, regular, old fashioned diner. The staff here is so incredibly nice, accommodating, and competent. We had a large group come in for brunch for my aunt's birthday. Despite the size, Jimmy's said it'd be no problem as long as we didn't mind waiting a little for a few tables to clear out. They managed to take all of our orders and get us food shockingly quickly.The food itself was all well prepared and delicious. If you are looking for a nice diner to stop by for breakfast or lunch, I could not recommend Jimmy's more. I hope I am in the area again so I can come back for another meal“

4.7 Superb42 Reviews
PORTERS on the lane American • $$$
19 Bellport Ln, Bellport - 4.83 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pan Seared Sea Scallops
Pulled Chicken Pot Pie
Bacon Wrapped Meatloaf
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Scallops with Risotto
Baby Shower Setting
Tuna Nicoise Salad
Sweet Potato Fries
Potl Lobster Roll
French Onion Soup

“Love,love, love ❤️, coming here each and every time. Especially right before the rush or after the rush. Lol, it's even BETTER!! I've been eating here since they opened, and I will continue to do so. I have tasted it ALLLLLLL through the years.“

4.5 Superb68 Reviews
Athens Diner Diner • $$
837 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island - 6.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hot Open Roast Beef with Brown Gravy
Quesadilla with Fries
Corned Beef Hash
Greek Salad
Chef

“We have eaten in the Athens Diner a number of times, for breakfast, this time lunch. It is clean, the staff are happy to serve, the food is delicious and served attractively. I had a roast beef on whole wheat bread, so good! Thank you so much! Oh! Parking has always been esay!“

4.5 Superb59 Reviews
Millhouse Inn Bar • $$
284 Mill Rd, Yaphank - 4.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Loaded Seafood Potato Skins
Seafood Fra Diavlo
Chicken Ala Rachel
French Onion Soup
Mill House Salad
Chicken Parmesan
Seafood Platter
Sauerbraten
Sea Scallops
Burger

“Had a great lunch here with a coworker. Views were great and the food was very good. The Thai chili wings and the cob salad, I can attest, are spot on. The only thing keeping this place from five stars with me is the dining room is a bit cramped. Nevertheless, I'll be back with the wife. She'll enjoy it too I'm sure.“

4.5 Superb53 Reviews
Drifters Kitchen and Bar American • $$
1600 Middle Country Rd, Ridge - 6.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Short Rib Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Braised Boneless Short Rib
The Morning After Burger
Drifter-A-Rita Flatbread
Everything Pretzel Logs
Drifters Fish Sandwich
Mac & Cheese Balls
Short Rib Poutine
Drifters Nachos
Fish and Chips

“We came here Friday night. I started off with a house margarita. It was delicious. My friends has wine and a jalapeño margarita. They liked them.For dinner I had a rare steakhouse burger and onion rings. The burger was very good but the onion rings although good were pretty greasy. One of my friends had the turkey burger and fries. She felt it was a bit dry but tasty. The other had a strawberry chicken salad. And loved it. For dessert we shared the apple blossom ala mode. It was perfect.“

4.3 Superb253 Reviews
Papa Juan Deli Deli • $$
451 NY-25A Store #12, Miller Place - 11.52 miles

“This deli is so underrated! I can’t believe I’ve been so close the whole time and never heard of it! I decided to try after craving a gyro and was so impressed. I also ordered the bean and cheese pupusas which were fantastic. The spanish food is as authentic as it gets around here. Highly recommend this place!! Will most definitely be coming back.“

4.8 Superb20 Reviews
Peter's on the Green American • $
40 S Country Rd, Bellport - 5.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crab Cake Benedict
Shepherd's Pie
Potato Salad
Onion Rings
Fries
Slaw

“Peter’s on the Green is a little hidden gem at the Bellport Country Club. My review is based on my wine which tasted a bit sour but this is coming from someone that is hard to please LOL. My sibling and I visited at the end of November 2023 for an afternoon lunch on a Saturday. Our meals came with a salad, mine was Greek and it was delicious. My brother got a chicken dino and I ordered an Uncle Peter (chicken, cheese, pasta…) and we shared a yummy dessert. We both took leftovers home and enjoyed them at a later time. I think the menu selection is great, location is gorgeous and the bathrooms could use an update. Overall, it’s a solid option for a nice lunch.“

4.5 Superb33 Reviews
Coram Diner American • $
383 Middle Country Rd, Coram - 8.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Shortcake
Cheeseburger Deluxe
Coram Diner Salad
Corned Beef Hash
Chicken Pot Pie
Eggs Benedict
Spinach Pie
Carrot Cake
Greek Salad
Cobb Salad

“??????????The food was great here and service was amazing! I’m from Queens, NYC and I had some business here, so I decided to stop by to grab a bite. This place is definitely my favorite diner! It’s too bad it’s so far from where I live.“

4.3 Superb101 Reviews
Roll & Bowl Grill Salad • $
508 E Main St, Patchogue - 7.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Noodle Soup
Southwest Burger
American Panini
American Burger
Chicken Club
Cuban Panini
Italian Hero
Chicken Parm
blt on a Hero
French Fries

“Fantastic service. Santos has such great customer service and the food was incredible. We had a group of 25 over people and Santos recommended and provided such delicious options. Everyone finished all the food! Thank you Santos and Roll & Bowl Grill Team!“

4.5 Superb32 Reviews
Triangle Pub Pubs • $$
381 Old Montauk Hwy, Eastport - 7.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fully Loaded Steak Tidbits
Battered Mushrooms
Triangle Wings
Onion Rings
Hamburger
Sandwich
Burger
Salads

“If you can get past the extremely loud bar area to the quiet-ish dining room you'll enjoy yourself. The food is okay. Can tell a lot is cooked from frozen pre-made and overcharged but I guess that's business. Fish and chips clearly from frozen. Corn nuggets clearly from frozen. Disappointed in that because these things are not hard to make and I shouldn't really be paying $25 for a few frozen fish sticks.“

4.4 Superb45 Reviews
J and R'S Steakhouse American • $$
4362 Middle Country Rd, Calverton - 10.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Marinated NY Strip 12oz with Sauteed Onions
Half Loaf of Garlic Bread
Steak N’ Coconut Shrimp
Onion Soup of the Day
Strawberry Cheesecake
Extra Lobster Tail
Sauteed Mushrooms
Buffalo Wings 10
Classic Burger
Creamed Spinach

“You can't get better food for the price. They also have authentic German beer on tap. This is one of the few places where I will eat a steak because they cook them just as good if not better than me. I have a customer near the restaurant and eating here makes putting up with the traffic bearable.“

4.2 Good92 Reviews
Friendly's American • $
2220 Rte 112, Coram - 8.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hunka Chunka PB Fudge Sundae
A Disaster of French Toast
Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad
Reese's Pieces Sundae
Mini Mozzarella Sticks
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Crispy Chicken Salad
Bacon Cheeseburger
Ice Cream Sundaes
Honey BBQ Burger

“They are literally always so friendly when we go there! This time I had submitted a pickup order, and I was literally in and out in 30 seconds. Food is always good. Great place!Vegetarian options: My go-to is the veggie burger but there are other options as well!“

4.2 Good56 Reviews
Genova's Pizza & Pastaria Pizza • $
3316 NY-112, Medford - 7.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Large Regular Pie
Sicilian Square
Chicken Marsala
Cannoli Bites
Garlic Knots
Everything

“Totally stoked we stumbled upon this gem! It's the ultimate pizza spot, no contest. The Grilled Chicken with Black Olives pizza? Mind-blowing. The freshness and quality of the ingredients? Unmatched. And the crust is just heavenly. Plus, the staff are super welcoming! This place has quickly become our go-to for pizza. Definitely making this a regular haunt and shouting out to all pizza aficionados. The flavours are next-level, and that crust is just perfection. They've got a killer selection of unique pies that I can't wait to dive into.“

4.2 Good35 Reviews
The Bellport American • $$$
159 S Country Rd, Bellport - 4.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Coq Au Vin with Mashed Potato and Veg
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
Forbidden Rice Pudding
Country Fried Chicken
Chicken Tikka Masala
Cobbler
Pickles

“Every time I come here the food is great and so is the service, but it's a once in a while dine for me as it's a bit priceyParking: Yk, depending on the day and what time, there's either plenty of parking or there's no good spots.“

4.2 Good33 Reviews
Loading...
map Map