50 Best Bakeries near Wantagh

“I’ve had Katie’s blueberry pie, cupcakes and her signature carrot cake and everything has been absolutely delicious! Her carrot cake is SO moist and full of delicious, fresh goodness that you can actually see the carrots and raisins. The frosting adds the perfect sweetness and enhances the cake’s flavor. The best I’ve ever had! Her blueberry pie, another winner, delicious and made with fresh blueberries and not overly sweet. As she said everything is made from scratch with fresh ingredients and best of all you can taste the love she puts into her baking. Good luck with your new store and I will definitely be stopping by!!“

“I tried the personal size chocolate bourbon pecan pie from Uncle Jeff’s. It was delicious! Mr. Church actually texted me and asked me to give him an hour to bake one fresh, since he didn’t have any on hand when I ordered. It was still warm when I picked it up. My wife, who normally doesn’t like sweets, tried a slice and she told me it was the best pecan pie she ever had! She said it wasn’t too sweet and it was the perfect consistency for a pecan pie. I can’t wait to try some of Uncle Jeff’s other varieties of pies!“

“Staff is very friendly, love the coffee!“

“Mama Custom Cookie’s for a recent event and I couldn’t be happier. I used to use a woman who moved to PA and have not been able to find cookies with her level of detail and deliciousness until now. Highly recommended !!“

“First time at Leonetti. Loved the place, the layout and open space of the sitting area, the way they have their cakes placed inside the fridge, not overcrowded and are able to appreciate the beauty of the cakes. Everything looked amazing and very clean. I really recommend Leonetti to anyone in the area or just passing by!“

“Thank you for the most delicious bday cake on 4/13/25!“

“We just had a batch of cookies delivered to Englewood Florida fire Academy from one of the students everybody loved him good job and thank you“

“This place is the best place to get your cake orders made ! They make the best cakes and they all taste amazing ! This is the only bakery I will go to from now on. Bishnu and his wife have amazing hospitality and treated me like I was their family. They made my daughter’s Berry First birthday cake and did an amazing job. They made my vision come to life! What a beautiful cake they made ! Everyone at the party enjoyed the cake and the cake was so good there were no leftovers ! They have earned my business forever and I will always return here. Thank you Bishnu and your wife for the stunning job I am very appreciative of you two.“

“Had them for the first time tonight when wife surprised me and the linzar tart cookie was the best one i have had in a very long time! Soft and loaded with fresh raspberry jelly! Also the donut my wife got was great! Very cool concept and will be back asap to try some other treats for us and the kids! Keep up the good work! 👌🏻😋🍰🍩🍪🧁🥮🌈“

“✨✨✨Best sweet cream churros EVER !! Yummmmmm 🥠🥠🥠 OMG …. Confection perfection.!!! 💯✨✨ We are in Easton Pa !! Love the owners & ♥️ excellent customer service!!! 100% recommend for coffee ice cream cookies, churros and especially the Dubai chocolate creamy crusted pistachio strawberries What a special treat !!!! 🍓🍃🍫☕️“

“I stopped in to Emilia’s Bakehouse Café on Walt Whitman Rd in Melville yesterday (they have another location in E. Northport) and boy, was I glad I did! I entered into a well-lit shop filled with pastries, scones, cookies, brownies, croissants, breads and quiches, etc. and was greeted with enthusiasm and a smile by 2 attractive young ladies. It was a great vibe just being there, very stress relieving. The chocolate brownie is perfection in texture and taste! The scones and peanut butter coconut power bites are delicious! Their organic Colombian coffee is the bomb, and you can get it with your favorite milk - for me it’s Oat Planet oat milk. Stop in, it’ll make your day! A feast for the eyes and tastebuds :)“

“The cheesecake and crumb cake are our favorites“

“✨✨✨Best sweet cream churros EVER !! Yummmmmm 🥠🥠🥠 OMG …. Confection perfection.!!! 💯✨✨ We are in Easton Pa !! Love the owners & ♥️ excellent customer service!!! 100% recommend for coffee ice cream cookies, churros and especially the Dubai chocolate creamy crusted pistachio strawberries What a special treat !!!! 🍓🍃🍫☕️“

“My mom has been purchasing their Rosca de Reyes since 1997 when we lived in Brooklyn. Now she goes to the one in the city. They are delicious and well made. Just perfect! My children love it as well as all my family. They are by far the best ones in town.“

“My family has ordered 3 cakes from Nita's because her desserts are that good. Recently she made the cake for our babyshower and everyone loved it. She is extremely professional and follows the design you ask for while adding a personal touch. Highly recommend her!“

“Been coming here since they opened. The owner & everyone who works here is amazing. The bagels & sandwiches never disappoint and i love to support small business!“

“Chip city is insane !! They are such a caring company to donate to the NYC Ronald McDonald house. I was honored to have tasted a cookie (or 2) and was blown away. Absolutely amazing love for their community. Thank you Chip City !“

“Excellent baked goods. Delicious pastry and the CANOLI“

“Such an awesome old school bakery ,my favorite!!!!awesome cheesecake I’ve been going there for years….“

“Family bought the rainbow cookie cake for my birthday today! Was the best cake I have ever had! Everyone was obsessed with it!! Thank you Capri Bakery for making my birthday extra sweet!“

“I highly recommend Baked by Emily Rose! They made a beautiful cake for my mom’s special birthday. Mom loved it. Very delicious!“

“Received one for my birthday, lemon. Absolutely delicious!! Also tasted the strawberries and cream. And the white chocolate raspberry. Delicious!!😊“

“Custom cake that not only was beautiful but also delicious for my daughters Sweet 16“

“Thank you so much for the beautiful cupcakes for my daughters bridal shower! Everyone was Ravi g about them. Not only were they gorgeous but they were delicious ! I gave your name to a few of guests“

“Chip city is insane !! They are such a caring company to donate to the NYC Ronald McDonald house. I was honored to have tasted a cookie (or 2) and was blown away. Absolutely amazing love for their community. Thank you Chip City !“

“Everything here is so amazing. I took pastries to a party and everyone loved them. They had nothing to say but nice things! The kindness showed by the employees is unmatched. It is well priced and such good quality. Recommending this place to everyone!“

“Moved from Brooklyn and I am so happy I found this place. I used them once for a party at my in-laws for my son’s 4th bday. Went back for my son’s 6th bday and I couldn’t be happier. Now that I am officially in the neighborhood, I will be back for ALL celebrations.“

“The Real Deal - FLAVOR! Steak and Ale, Chicken Leek, Steak and Kidney, Shepherds, Cottage + bangers, rashers and all candies and crisps. Make this your local stop for all things British on Long Island!“

“Delicious sfogliatelle, cannolis, napoleons, and Italian bread 🥖“

“They are absolutely amazing, family owned for years their cannoli’s are superb, all of their stuff are unbelievable, I would travel to the end of the earth for all their desserts. Happy Thanksgiving to you & family always…I’m“

“✨✨✨Best sweet cream churros EVER !! Yummmmmm 🥠🥠🥠 OMG …. Confection perfection.!!! 💯✨✨ We are in Easton Pa !! Love the owners & ♥️ excellent customer service!!! 100% recommend for coffee ice cream cookies, churros and especially the Dubai chocolate creamy crusted pistachio strawberries What a special treat !!!! 🍓🍃🍫☕️“

“We celebrated our daughter's 6th bday virtually and we ordered the party boxes for all her friends. They had a blast decorating the cookies and they were delish! Thank you so much!“

“I ordered a specialty cake for my mother and it was FABULOUS! The cake was unique, 2 - tier choc and vanilla with a hazelnut cream filling. It was covered in a lovely lavender frosting with lace flowers and unique lettering. It was fresh and special!“

“The rainbow cookie cake is absolutely delicious! The perfect amount of sweetness and so moist. A new family favorite!“

“Visited with my 8 year old, lovely homey place, he said The colossal chocolate chip cookies are delicious. You can sit inside or outside, enjoy your meal, work on your laptop, or just relax while sipping tea or coffee Will definitely be going back“

“The best cheesecake on Long Island hands down!“

“Hands down best Macarons I ever tasted😋“

“Great for everyone. Friendly atmosphere. And great service“

“The food was amazing, I got the Texas Hold ‘em but with grilled chicken and they did an amazing job. They cook the chicken/bacon right in front of your eyes, plus the food tastes incredibly fresh. I recommend getting one of their panini’s, they know what they are doing and most likely what they have on the menu is a really good idea.The place has a huge drink selection on the wall, a few shelves full of chips, and the menu is incredibly easy to read and it actually includes the ingredients which you don’t see anymore nowadays.The staff was super nice and took your order quickly, somehow the (I believe manager) remembered my order (Texas hold ‘em with grilled chicken) in just three visits.Sadly soon I’ll have to leave New York and won’t be able to eat here anytime soon, but I will remember this place.“

“Whenever I'm in Merrick, which is usually two or three times a month, I always stop at Bagelman of Merrick. They have the best bacon and egg sandwiches and their tuna and chicken salads are always a welcome sight back home. Their bagels are always fresh and flavorful no matter what variety I get. I've come to know the owner, Boris, and his staff, and they are always most helpful. Looking forward to my next trip to Merrick.“

“Living in South Florida for the last 30 years I need a cake made and delivered to a nursing home in Plainview. All I can say is WOW what a great job ZuckerBakers did. The cake was beautiful and everyone loved it. I would highly recommend this bakery“

“I used to buy bagels and baileys from bell years ago. Lived 2 blocks away from the store from flatland's Avenue in canarsi The best Bagels and Bealies in ny homemade fresh daily!“

“everything is always so fresh and good! the bread is to die for“

“Rainbow cookies Cannolis Napoleon Cheesecake A MUST !! The bread… best in the world“

“I love everything about this place. The cookies. The atmosphere, the wall with the huge cookie. The people there are extremely nice and I just love watching everyone bake their cookies, and they are very sanitary too!! Cookies are absolutely the best I come here very often. I threw up eating the large Reeces Peanut butter though. It was absolutely bomb but I just can’t take sugar like that.“

“The vegan empanadas are delicious. Love this place. My favorites are black bean and the Mac n cheese. Red velvet cupcakes are to die for also.“

“The best everything is fresh , delicious , and there’s lots to choose from . Just amazing“

“Very nice place to join friends and or family for bkfast, light lunch, tea.“

“🌟 Hidden Gem Alert! 🌟

At first glance, you might think it's just a bakery there’s a simple sign outside that says so. But step inside, and you'll discover a cozy, beautiful place filled with warmth, charm, and the aroma of fresh, delicious food. The space isn’t large, but it feels like home. The service? Absolutely welcoming like being embraced by family.

Yes, it’s a bakery, and yes, the Colombian-style pastries are incredible perfect for grabbing on the go. But this place is so much more than just a bakery. It’s also a full restaurant offering both traditional Latin American and classic American breakfasts. And when lunch rolls around? Get ready for dishes prepared with genuine love and passion flavors that speak to the soul.

If you're driving by, live nearby, or just happen to be hungry and searching for a place that doesn't need flashy signs or a big name to prove its worth stop here. Eat here. Enjoy here.

Having visited over 2,000 restaurants in my life, I can confidently say this spot is a true diamond in the rough. Quality food, fair prices, exceptional service what more could you ask for?

Let’s keep putting places like this on the map. They deserve to be known, celebrated, and visited often. Support local. Eat well. Save money. Live fully.

❤️ With love and taste,
A grateful foodie“