13 Best Pizza Restaurants near Watkins Glen

“Delicious oven brick pizza! Perfectly cooked, leaves you craving for more, crust was crispy as it should be! Highly recommend! Friendly service from the guy running it! I’m a few hours from home but will definitely stop by again before leaving!“

“Their food is good, service is fast, and it’s pretty cheap! The cheese pizza and buffalo chicken pizza were both flavorful and good sized slices. They had two almost full cases of pizzas and calzones to choose slices from and we were served right away. Three slices and a drink came out to $14. The only minor complaint is that it’s a little too greasy, but nothing out of the ordinary for chain pizza.“

“Whenever they’re doing pizza and I’m back in town I always try to get a slice!“

“Nostalgic Mom and Pop shop. Simple menu, but the food is reasonably priced and hits the spot. I got the chicken cheesesteak and onion rings. A good lunch, for sure. The owner was incredibly friendly. Parking is on the street, but I had no issue finding a spot.“

“great food and service at a decent price a good place to hang out and sur enjoy the surroundings“

“There is so much more we could recommend. We have eaten here several times and we’ve not been disappointed! But something that touched us just yesterday, 2/2/25, was our waiter Shawn! We took our daughter, who has special needs, to Jerlando’s for lunch and Shawn was amazing. Not only was he an excellent waiter, but our daughter wanted a hug and Shawn never skipped a beat and leaned right in and let our daughter hug him!! His kindness toward her touched our hearts deeply! Thank you Jerlando’s for another fine meal and thank you so much Shawn for your extremely friendly attitude and your heart touching kindness to our special girl!“

“Great food and great service“

“They are always accommodating with special orders. I ordered a sheet pizza for my grandson's birthday to take to school and wanted it cut in smaller pieces. They made sure that the toppings were evenly divided by the smaller pieces and everything was exactly as ordered and on time. As always it was DELICIOUS!“

“ordered our first pizza. got wings and 2 pizzas, $32. felt the wings were small and didn't get many. flavor was good for spicy one. pizza was more like a medium sized but tasted good not greasy. ingredient amount was awesome. Will get again. loved how you express your love for God on box.“

“Good food, fair price, fast service. very friendly service. Love going here.“

“First time at this place, (not to the finger lakes though). After a long day of work and travel, it was the perfect wine down place for pizza and beer, and not just any pizza. The best Pizza and Beer. Amazing servers. Josh was so welcoming and made us want to come again!“

“Solid sour beers and amazing staff!“

“Best grilled chicken sandwich I’ve had in a long time. Could barely finish the sandwich let alone the chips and salsa. Definitely worth the four hour drive.“