11 Best Burger Restaurants in Webster

“I’ll preface this by saying that I’ve had garbage plates from Dogtown & Nick’s (the OG). I got a half-plate, which was still a huge portion weighing probably four pounds, with mac’n’homefries and cheeseburger topped with the cinnamon (mild but tasty) meat sauce and “a little bit” of onions, mustard, and ketchup. This was BY FAR the most delicious garbage plate I’ve ever had. I will ABSOLUTELY be coming back here. And it’s less than a 10-minute, quick’n’easy drive from Rochester General Hospital (so skip the Wolfgang Puck despite the convenience). I will add that the young woman who took my order was kind and friendly. The meal “to-go” was ready in less than 4 minutes. And the food was delicious, not at all greasy—literally PERFECT“

“We went here for a date night and could not have chosen a better place! The food was absolutely amazing and the staff was attentive but not too much so. We will definitely be back!“

“Bill Gray's is legendary and there food still proves it after all these years. I was at one of ther locations during my early military service and the food quality, wasteland customer friendly environment is outstanding. Im from buffalo and this place is worth the travel. The manager even spoke to us about our experience and encouraged an awesome desert. We'll done bill Gray's well done. Also your garbage plate should be sold everywhere.“

“the atmosphere and drink prices“

“A "neighborhood bar and grill" with much better food, drinks, and service. I've been there over a hundred times and love the consistency in the experience. The dining room is separate from the bar area if you want a quieter environment, but there are also tables in the bar area and outside. It's also great for take-out - the online ordering is a little flaky (hint: check out as guest and don't try to make an account) but you can always call your order in as well.

Kid-friendliness: Great for kids“

“Krystin was an amazing server! She was kind, attentive, and considerate of our needs throughout our entire visit. She checked on us often and made sure our needs were met: her personality and spirit were so bright and joyful! We loved eating off of the 2 for 25 menu and got drinks as well: all of which were fantastic!“

“Our server was fantastic and food was awesome but way to cold 🥶 in the building !!“

“Came to grab some food because a friend was running late to a job. Needed a place to grab a quick bite and use the bathroom.

Arrived on site around 5:15pm. One of the two double doors was locked. No sign. Made me feel silly. Maybe one table taken. Was greeted politely by a young man moping the floor. Walked back to bathroom. Bathroom was clean overall. Soap dispenser is mounted at eye level. Weird. It’s a palm push dispenser, it’s meant to be at sink level. Also not mounted to the wall properly. Sink handle was visibly dirty. Paper towel dispenser did not work and was not stocked.

Ran up to the counter, still only myself and one table in the whole facility. Everyone appeared to be working diligently. Austin took my order quick and smooth. I grabbed soda from the machine, some napkins and ketchup from the counter and sat down till my food was ready. Table I picked was clean. I did notice that the music was pretty loud, almost too loud to have a genuine conversation if I were to come with someone. While waiting for my order business picked up. Around 6-7 people were also waiting for food. Staff was handling it well. Grabbed my food and sat back down. Burger was cooked perfectly, fries were good, the right amount of salt. I finished my food and left.

The only gripe I have truly about a place like this, after not eating out for maybe a year is. $24 for a burger fry’s and a drink? Then you have the audacity to have the card reader ask me to tip? Tip for what? The service I was already paying for? Maybe I’m out of touch but I can see why a lot of food establishments are dying.“

“Great people, great food. Definitely our new sports bar when we come North.“

“My son and I ate at the Webster, NY Diary Queen today - April 2, 2026. We had a great experience. I used the App to order so that we could get the Blizzard deal. The food was ready about a minute or two after what the app had said it would be, and the employees could not have been nicer and more welcoming! I have read a few negative reviews about this location in the last year and I have no idea what happened to them. I would encourage them to give it another try! We could not have been happier.

We are from Syracuse and came into town to visit the Eastman Museum and go to Arcade 80s (highly recommend both) and stopped for a delicious treat at DQ. My son loves their chicken tenders and fries. I usually go with a burger; but had a fish sandwich today. The sandwich was unremarkable, but good; the fries were good as they always are - which is why I would have given the food a 4.5 if I could; but since I can't 5 is more accurate than 4 for the food! As it always is the Blizzard was the star of the show.

I wish I had asked the name of the young man working the cash register, he could not have been nicer and more friendly. We had such a good experience today, it will be our DQ of choice when we are visiting Rochester!“

“This place is always smoking. I swear they make the food to order. It’s always been fresh, sometimes there is a bit of a wait for being fast food, however I don’t recall ever having incorrect items. We tend to order later in the evening and sometimes they do have to prep things & let us know our option of waiting or declining. They’ve always been super nice, surprising for a fast food chain.“